Advanced

Welcome, OpenSUSE developers!

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 29 comments
MarkShuttleworth.com; By Mark Shuttleworth
Mail this story
Print this story

Novell’s decision to go to great lengths to circumvent the patent framework clearly articulated in the GPL has sent shockwaves through the community. If you are an OpenSUSE developer who is concerned about the long term consequences of this pact, you may be interested in some of the events happening next week as part of the Ubuntu Open Week.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: Novell, Community, Ubuntu; Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (29)

9 earlier comments in the full thread.

Oh here was I thinking linux was also about community not just business.

Dino, I agree devs are PITAS often (having been on the receiving end several times). All the more reason for Shuttleworth not to be like that.
richo123: Exactly what convention of the the Linux community did Shuttleworth violate?

This is how I see it. Ubuntu needs developers to be successful. OpenSuSE may have developers that are ready to move. This is an explicit invitation to the SuSE people to see how Ubuntu does things. I am certain that the patent issue and binary driver issues will be discussed in Shuttleworth's presentations on Tuesday, because his blog already has 4 comments about it. He won't be able to duck it, and he'll have to justify his stance. Once they have heard the Ubuntu pitch, the SuSE people can choose to work with Ubuntu, or go back to OpenSuSE, or join Debian, or even GnuSense. One of the things that I love about working in Free Software is that there are more cool things to do than I will ever have time for. Ubuntu has attracted me because of the openness of their communications, their involvement in the community at local levels (LoCo Teams), and their lack of elitist hogwash. What's needed here, to paraphrase the King, is "A little less talk and a little more installation." Ubuntu is getting it done. I hope a lot of people will come over.
>Oh here was I thinking linux was also about community not just business.

Business is fine, just not underhanded business, and I do not consider this underhanded business, nor harmful to the community. No harm, no foul.
>Business is fine, just not underhanded business, and I do not consider this underhanded business, nor harmful to the community. No harm, no foul.

Exactly.
"It's business, and it's not even underhanded business. Don't wanna go? Don't go!"

Well f****g said.

[Edited for compliance with ToS - dcparris]
I have no problem with the message and agree with some of the posts above. Just think it could have been done in a way not to cause ill will which it *undoubtedly* did. That is my idea of community. Here is a quote from a Ubuntu blogger that sums up my attitude:

"I think Mark had the best intentions with that mail, I also think it was done in a bit of a rush. I don’t think the problem is much with what he did, but how he did it. I think that reaching out to other projects and building bridges are great, but the tone of the mail was a bit divisive, and dismissive of the OpenSUSE distribution, which is in my opinion a fantastic distribution (even though it’s been a while since I’ve used it)." (Jonathon Carter)

BTW I think Mark has done a fantastic job with Ubuntu and I use it on four machines at home.
1c3d0g:

The moderaters are doing their best to police language on the fora (this is an open site, it can be accessed by minors). You might want to modify your post to avoid their official notice.
>Well f***ing said.

Never mind the minors. "Well said" is a sentiment that loses all meaning with f***ing in the middle. It's just hard to believe that anyone who expresses it in that fashion actually understands what "Well said." means.
> It's just hard to believe that anyone who expresses it in that fashion actually understands what "Well said." means.

Well, Dino, you notice I always try to be polite (though not necessarily agreeable). I don't always succeed, mind you, but I do try. This seemed the most polite way to point out the inappropriateness of the language.
jd -

You are polite to a fault. I am not, though I wish I were.
>Well f***ing said.

I, for one, am not offended...but we've covered this ground before. House rules, however, should be followed...although a friendly reminder at the top of threads might be helpful. A lot of folks drift over here from Slashdot, and there are NO inhibitions against some really nasty comments there, eh?
> and there are NO inhibitions against some really nasty comments there, eh?

Which is why some of us don't spend time there, eh?
> I, for one, am not offended...

As an old usenet reader, it takes a lot more than that to offend me, but given the nature of the forum, it is inappropriate. Especially since the * key is so easy to use.
>Which is why some of us don't spend time there, eh?

I've spent less and less as time goes by, not because of the language, but because it's hard to sort out the intelligent and intelligible comments from the mass of garbage. I usually pop over there once a day to see what the new news listings are, because things pop up on /. long before they do most other places.

Still, I say a friendly reminder at the top of the page is a good idea, rather than being reactive when it happens.
>Still, I say a friendly reminder at the top of the page is a good idea, rather than being reactive when it happens.

In a world where people can come from anyplace with any set of rules (or none), I agree.
Civil discourse (and disagreement) is always valuable.
>Civil discourse (and disagreement) is always valuable

***Content Warning!!!!! Editorial strokes follow --

This is one of those rare places -- on or off the internet -- where people can express themselves passionately, disagree vociferously and heatedly, yet retain a thread of respect and decency towards each other. The thread gets frayed on occasion, like our nerves, but doesn't seem to break.

Alert Ended --- Editorial strokes complete***

And, of course, the editors look best alongside plastic pigs.
Threadjackers.
Meandering back to the OP, yeah, of course it ruffles feathers. The OpenSUSE devs are not going to admit publicly that they like getting an invitation to jump ship from their newly-tainted distro. But it could have an effect over the long-term. After all, receiving invitations is a nice thing, and if M. Shuttleworth really wants to court devs and not just seek cheap publicity, he will privately contact individual OpenSUSE devs.

Meanwhile, back at the Fork Ranch, an OpenSUSE fork that is independent of Novell and truly community-supported could make life interesting in a lot of ways. No stench of Redmond, no hassles with Novell, and maybe they could even attract some of the old SUSE folks who bailed after Novell bought SUSE.

I have always been careful to ask people if I could contact them off-list if I wanted to discuss something that might be considered inappropriate as a list post. So, too, Mark should have felt free to do a little fishing, and then cast his line(s) with the developers privately. His move is definitely tactless. Hey, we all make mistakes, so let's see where it goes.

1c3d0g: you really should know better. You're not a newbie here.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post