Novell says desktop Linux costs 10% of Microsoft's Vista
|
|
|
Comments (36)
what?
> I see their 10% and raise it another 20% because we won't install novell products.
Does that mean if you install Debian it will cost say 2% of Vista, or 0% if you do it for yourself :D
Does that mean if you install Debian it will cost say 2% of Vista, or 0% if you do it for yourself :D
Novell and bad crack again
14 earlier comments in the full thread.
jsusanka,
There are circuit design apps in Linux, though not the best, and also free, but not open source CAD. This is one area that could use a lot of work. Autocad, for example, has mid tier business by the short hairs with a virtual monopoly. That really needs to change if we expect them to transition to Linux.
There are circuit design apps in Linux, though not the best, and also free, but not open source CAD. This is one area that could use a lot of work. Autocad, for example, has mid tier business by the short hairs with a virtual monopoly. That really needs to change if we expect them to transition to Linux.
"jsusanka,
There are circuit design apps in Linux, though not the best, and also free, but not open source CAD. This is one area that could use a lot of work. Autocad, for example, has mid tier business by the short hairs with a virtual monopoly. That really needs to change if we expect them to transition to Linux."
oh please - that is just an excuse - the point is there are cad apps available.
if someone wants autocad for linux then they need to go to vendor and tell them. threaten to use somebody else that does support linux - you are the customer tell them what you want
as far as "not the best" that is subjective - I think command line programs are the best (more effecient and flexible) but that doesn't mean it is true.
There are circuit design apps in Linux, though not the best, and also free, but not open source CAD. This is one area that could use a lot of work. Autocad, for example, has mid tier business by the short hairs with a virtual monopoly. That really needs to change if we expect them to transition to Linux."
oh please - that is just an excuse - the point is there are cad apps available.
if someone wants autocad for linux then they need to go to vendor and tell them. threaten to use somebody else that does support linux - you are the customer tell them what you want
as far as "not the best" that is subjective - I think command line programs are the best (more effecient and flexible) but that doesn't mean it is true.
> ...but not open source CAD.
There are opensource CAD programs, but I don't think there's anything in Autocad's class. For a list of free, cheap, or opensource progams for various platforms see: http://www.eland.org.uk/pages/Misc/cadnotes.html
There are opensource CAD programs, but I don't think there's anything in Autocad's class. For a list of free, cheap, or opensource progams for various platforms see: http://www.eland.org.uk/pages/Misc/cadnotes.html
qcad is probably the most useful of the bunch. Quite useable, but only for 2D and 3D wireframe.
I think that any "MS propaganda" may be in the way that CBR presented their take on the report.
What such a report does is assist the Novell salesforce to go to any potential major customer and say to them in essence "Hey Mr. Customer, we can meet 90% of your needs *immediately* at 10% of your usual cost."
Such a pitch is very compelling - and not at all good for MS. It's a foot-in-the-door kind of thing. Because Mr. Customer then considers how to take that 90% savings and satisfy the other 10% of requirements with a fraction of that leftover money.
As for the quality of add-on software such as Autocad - for shops that are entrenched with it, and facing software upgrade costs, if you can't support Autocad, you aren't going to get in the door. Current Open Source alternatives are not "good enough" for such operations.
Autocad aside, I was once doing work for a small company that had a single electronic hardware engineer on staff. To do his job to the quality that he was able to do with the two MS-based products would have taken jumping through several Open Source Electronic Design hoops, slowing him down significantly. The owner of the company was not adverse to using Linux - we based our entire custom designed Point-Of-Sale terminal on embedded Linux. It just would not have been cost-effective to switch products for the hardware engineer.
Now, some people mentioned that this is an "add-on" issue, and not about "Vista functionality". I did mention the MSAPI as one bit of functionality that I was aware of that there was no default equivalent in Linux - in distributions or kernel. Also, have you forgotten that IE is embedded in the OS? There is no embedded browser in the Linux kernel. And I don't believe there should be.
I guess what I'm saying is that the "90% functionality of Vista" is not necessarily a negative or "MS-propaganda", but the way it was portrayed in the CBR article certainly is.
What such a report does is assist the Novell salesforce to go to any potential major customer and say to them in essence "Hey Mr. Customer, we can meet 90% of your needs *immediately* at 10% of your usual cost."
Such a pitch is very compelling - and not at all good for MS. It's a foot-in-the-door kind of thing. Because Mr. Customer then considers how to take that 90% savings and satisfy the other 10% of requirements with a fraction of that leftover money.
As for the quality of add-on software such as Autocad - for shops that are entrenched with it, and facing software upgrade costs, if you can't support Autocad, you aren't going to get in the door. Current Open Source alternatives are not "good enough" for such operations.
Autocad aside, I was once doing work for a small company that had a single electronic hardware engineer on staff. To do his job to the quality that he was able to do with the two MS-based products would have taken jumping through several Open Source Electronic Design hoops, slowing him down significantly. The owner of the company was not adverse to using Linux - we based our entire custom designed Point-Of-Sale terminal on embedded Linux. It just would not have been cost-effective to switch products for the hardware engineer.
Now, some people mentioned that this is an "add-on" issue, and not about "Vista functionality". I did mention the MSAPI as one bit of functionality that I was aware of that there was no default equivalent in Linux - in distributions or kernel. Also, have you forgotten that IE is embedded in the OS? There is no embedded browser in the Linux kernel. And I don't believe there should be.
I guess what I'm saying is that the "90% functionality of Vista" is not necessarily a negative or "MS-propaganda", but the way it was portrayed in the CBR article certainly is.
Quoting:"Hey Mr. Customer, we can meet 90% of your needs *immediately* at 10% of your usual cost."That is totally different from saying "Linux product provides 90% of Vista's functionality and 10% of the price.". Don't you think!
It looks like, either you are putting words in Novell's mouth, or the article is twisting Novell's words! I wish I know which is true.
Linux is, without doubt, a much more capable, secure, and stable platform than anything MS has ever produced. About the only area of performance where Windows prevails any more is in video drivers.
In the category of server apps, most experts concede that Linux wins hands down. Either KDE or Gnome provide at least as good (I'd say far superior) a Desktop, and, it's only in the area of niche apps and video drivers that Linux continues to play catch up. Also note that Linux does continue to close the gap at a breathtaking pace.
So... 90% of what functionality? There's a huge suspension of credibility here. Could we just as easily say that Windows offers 75% of Linux stability? And, 50% of the security? And yeah, Linux is really inexpensive to run.
It's just a very poor way to promote Linux.
In the category of server apps, most experts concede that Linux wins hands down. Either KDE or Gnome provide at least as good (I'd say far superior) a Desktop, and, it's only in the area of niche apps and video drivers that Linux continues to play catch up. Also note that Linux does continue to close the gap at a breathtaking pace.
So... 90% of what functionality? There's a huge suspension of credibility here. Could we just as easily say that Windows offers 75% of Linux stability? And, 50% of the security? And yeah, Linux is really inexpensive to run.
It's just a very poor way to promote Linux.
In my well-known straw polls, the majority of those still dual-booting were either gamers or office workers tied - emotionally or technically - to one or two apps. Incidentally, very few of those were custom apps. Mostly things like Quicken/Books, AutoCAD, Photoshop, some video editor, etc. Not one person reported being tied to MS Office functionality or similar issues.
Darren, I'm glad to hear you say you don't believe a browser should be embedded in the kernel. I view that "functionality" as a bug, not a desirable feature. You almost had me worried... ;-)
Darren, I'm glad to hear you say you don't believe a browser should be embedded in the kernel. I view that "functionality" as a bug, not a desirable feature. You almost had me worried... ;-)
> I view that "functionality" as a bug, not a desirable feature.
Or, a virus. Like so many other wonderful Windows 'features'...
Or, a virus. Like so many other wonderful Windows 'features'...
Sorry Jim. I thought IE was the virus.
IE is a virus by any definition you throw at it. It installs without consent, runs without consent, slows down your system, can't be contained and it downloads all kinds of other malware. The only thing it doesn't do is spread to other computers because it is *already* on every MS computer.
> I thought IE was the virus.
Actually, the whole Windows OS is root-kited by design.
Actually, the whole Windows OS is root-kited by design.
Fortunately, like most viruses, it is mostly restricted to Windows.
Not true Mr. P, you can indeed install this windows virus into linux. Like many other windows virii though it does take some work on your part to get it in, and then a whole lot more work to get it to do anything like what it was supposed to do.
I remember reading an article some time back about someone who had collected up some of the more virulent windows virii and putting them into his Linux box. Even with him actively helping them they managed to work about like one expects microsoft software to work (barely), and they took constant babysitting to keep operating. The ones that could actually be made to operate.
I remember reading an article some time back about someone who had collected up some of the more virulent windows virii and putting them into his Linux box. Even with him actively helping them they managed to work about like one expects microsoft software to work (barely), and they took constant babysitting to keep operating. The ones that could actually be made to operate.
",,,if someone wants autocad for linux then they need to go to vendor and tell them. threaten to use somebody else that does support linux - you are the customer tell them what you want."
Well that's worked astoundingly well with Nvidia, ATI, Quickbooks and TurboTax now hasn't it. If I could have the money and time I've spent lobbying and visiting these people about just this issue, I could take a cruise to Roatan.
Look it up. And book me we with you the next time you go. Heavens it is nice.
h
Well that's worked astoundingly well with Nvidia, ATI, Quickbooks and TurboTax now hasn't it. If I could have the money and time I've spent lobbying and visiting these people about just this issue, I could take a cruise to Roatan.
Look it up. And book me we with you the next time you go. Heavens it is nice.
h
Lobbying is a feeble weapon against microshaft's wealthy bullying.
Quoting:",,,if someone wants autocad for linux then they need ...I read some where that the EU is trying to force AutoDesk to make AutoCAD available for Linux, that might help. But give them time and they will come around. In the mean time, we should boycott them as much as we can. One other thing we should do, make an example of others who come around and support Linux but we keep boycotting them by buying from other who supported Linux from the start. We should be serious about this issue. Adobe is a good example
Quoting:but we keep boycotting them by buying from other who supported Linux from the start
Huh? how in the world is that an inducement to support linux at all?
CEO: We need to get into the linux market.
Advertising Exec: There is a boycott on anyone who hasnt supported linux from the start, and we havent.
CEO: oh well, It was a thought, but if they dont want us then phooey on them.
Don't take me too seriously. Sometimes I just like to mumble
> Not true Mr. P,
I did say "mostly" - not completely. ;-)
I did say "mostly" - not completely. ;-)
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

I see their 10% and raise it another 20% because we won't install novell products.