Novell vows to keep fighting Microsoft 'juggernaut'
|
|
|
Comments (35)
15 earlier comments in the full thread.
> He claims that Novell is circumventing his intent by not providing equal protection to downstream users.
Based on the information we have available, Novell customers are now covered by an agreement which they are not authorized to pass on to other people. I think the facts are clear as to that. Allison's position is that this circumvents his intention to provide equal protection to downstream users.
I agree that the agreement is not the great evil some make it out to be, but Allison is the only person qualified to speak to his intent, and he has done so. He may be mistaken about the nature of the agreement, but there can be no denying that by his understanding, the agreement violates his intent.
Do I like the agreement? No; and since I have no desire to be covered by such an agreement, I won't use Novell's products. In all fairness, the odds of my doing so were slim to start with. This agreement is simply the final nail in the coffin.
Based on the information we have available, Novell customers are now covered by an agreement which they are not authorized to pass on to other people. I think the facts are clear as to that. Allison's position is that this circumvents his intention to provide equal protection to downstream users.
I agree that the agreement is not the great evil some make it out to be, but Allison is the only person qualified to speak to his intent, and he has done so. He may be mistaken about the nature of the agreement, but there can be no denying that by his understanding, the agreement violates his intent.
Do I like the agreement? No; and since I have no desire to be covered by such an agreement, I won't use Novell's products. In all fairness, the odds of my doing so were slim to start with. This agreement is simply the final nail in the coffin.
You know how far your arguments would get in a court of law? Without any specifics (and Allison et al have provided none) you'd get nowhere.
Oh wait, if you argued it like SCOG, I suppose you'd be able to stall for a few years before being tossed out on your ear (figuratively speaking).
So what I'm going to continue to say is "Where's the beef?"
So far, "Novell did this!!! Novell did that!!!" and so far no has answered when asked "Where did they do this? Where did they do that?" I keep getting more of "He said they did it, so they must have, because he wrote package X". That doesn't answer the need to be specific. What it does show is that FOSS supporters are just as willing to make accusations without backing them up with specific evidence as the enemies of FOSS such as SCOG. And that has to stop.
The deal is over 3 months old. No one has yet produced a single concrete instance of any anti-FOSS actions on the part of Novell (creating a OOXML plug-in for OOo doesn't count since it actually fosters further adoption of FOSS software.) And claiming that the MS-Novell covenant is anti-FOSS just doesn't cut it because the covenant doesn't take away anyone's freedom with regard to FOSS software.
Where's that big decision we were promised by Prof. Moglen? Or was he just blowing smoke when he said it would happen in 2 weeks?
Oh wait, if you argued it like SCOG, I suppose you'd be able to stall for a few years before being tossed out on your ear (figuratively speaking).
So what I'm going to continue to say is "Where's the beef?"
So far, "Novell did this!!! Novell did that!!!" and so far no has answered when asked "Where did they do this? Where did they do that?" I keep getting more of "He said they did it, so they must have, because he wrote package X". That doesn't answer the need to be specific. What it does show is that FOSS supporters are just as willing to make accusations without backing them up with specific evidence as the enemies of FOSS such as SCOG. And that has to stop.
The deal is over 3 months old. No one has yet produced a single concrete instance of any anti-FOSS actions on the part of Novell (creating a OOXML plug-in for OOo doesn't count since it actually fosters further adoption of FOSS software.) And claiming that the MS-Novell covenant is anti-FOSS just doesn't cut it because the covenant doesn't take away anyone's freedom with regard to FOSS software.
Where's that big decision we were promised by Prof. Moglen? Or was he just blowing smoke when he said it would happen in 2 weeks?
Darren,
You are hopeless to get convinced because you refuse to be convinced. You just keep going in circles. Go back and read the previous posts again and again and you will find the answers to your "new" questions.
No one is talking about the legality. Legally, Novell and MS found a loop hole and that is what we all are talking about. This loop hole has to and needs to be plugged. We are talking about a contract that many people don't like because it endangers FOSS. We don't need to give you a proof because you are just an atom in the FOSS Ocean. Pretty much don't count for anything.
RMS & Moglen authored GPL2 and happen to believe that Novell & MS contract doesn't comply with the intent of the GPL2. They, along with many other people, all believe that the contract is contradictory to the GPL spirit. So, they are writing GPL3 to remedy this situation.
When will GPL be ready? Well, when it is ready.
What ever you say is irrelavent. If you like GPL3, fine, help yourself and use it, it you don't, tough, do not use it. It is as simple as that. END OF STORY.
No one is talking about the legality. Legally, Novell and MS found a loop hole and that is what we all are talking about. This loop hole has to and needs to be plugged. We are talking about a contract that many people don't like because it endangers FOSS. We don't need to give you a proof because you are just an atom in the FOSS Ocean. Pretty much don't count for anything.
RMS & Moglen authored GPL2 and happen to believe that Novell & MS contract doesn't comply with the intent of the GPL2. They, along with many other people, all believe that the contract is contradictory to the GPL spirit. So, they are writing GPL3 to remedy this situation.
When will GPL be ready? Well, when it is ready.
What ever you say is irrelavent. If you like GPL3, fine, help yourself and use it, it you don't, tough, do not use it. It is as simple as that. END OF STORY.
> You know how far your arguments would get in a court of law?
Allison isn't arguing in a court of law. Everyone admits that the Novell/Microsoft deal is legal. Everyone admits that it's outside the scope of the GPL as currently written. It also acts counter to the intent of the people who wrote and at least some of the people who use the GPL. I know that if I were a programmer using the GPL, it would be counter to mine.
> Without any specifics (and Allison et al have provided none) you'd get nowhere.
I just gave you the specifics. The coverage provided by the Microsoft agreement cannot be transferred. This is counter to the intent of the GPL to treat all users equally. If you can't understand or accept that, as Abe said, there's no point in continuing the conversation.
And the worst of it is that I'm largely on your side in the discussion. :(
Allison isn't arguing in a court of law. Everyone admits that the Novell/Microsoft deal is legal. Everyone admits that it's outside the scope of the GPL as currently written. It also acts counter to the intent of the people who wrote and at least some of the people who use the GPL. I know that if I were a programmer using the GPL, it would be counter to mine.
> Without any specifics (and Allison et al have provided none) you'd get nowhere.
I just gave you the specifics. The coverage provided by the Microsoft agreement cannot be transferred. This is counter to the intent of the GPL to treat all users equally. If you can't understand or accept that, as Abe said, there's no point in continuing the conversation.
And the worst of it is that I'm largely on your side in the discussion. :(
I am not hopeless to be convinced, but you and a couple of others refuse to rise to my level of "proof": that is provide specific software package (which in this case Samba has been put forward) *AND* an applicable patent. So far, no one has done so. Ipso facto, the circumvention isn't real.
This isn't even addressing the issue that I've asked which freedom of the "seven software freedoms" has been violated by the MS-Novell. Again, no answer.
Allison is infallible? He also went on record to say that the deal is not about interoperability, but the information that has been put out by the parties to the deal contradict his public statements. So how can I trust his assessment that the deal circumvents his intent, when he can't even give an accurate depiction of the deal. It is obvious he doesn't understand the full nature of the deal because he can't even get what the objective of the deal correct.
That's what it will take to convince me. When someone shows me that I'm wrong with actual evidence, then fine, I'll admit I'm wrong. But here in this issue, no one has shown any PROOF that Novell is Anti-FOSS or that the deal "violates the spirit" or "circumvents the intent" - only a bunch of opinion that has no basis in fact.
And the problem is that a small faction is letting this deal, which has yet to be shown as negative for FOSS, cause more division. What should be happening is that the people who are dissing Novell without proof should stop talking about Novell and advocate the positives of Linux, and FOSS in general, and get at least one new Linux user each month.
edit: Don't forget to register those new Linux users: http://counter.li.org/
I registered years ago when they first started it, but didn't stay "active" and so had to re-register.
This isn't even addressing the issue that I've asked which freedom of the "seven software freedoms" has been violated by the MS-Novell. Again, no answer.
Allison is infallible? He also went on record to say that the deal is not about interoperability, but the information that has been put out by the parties to the deal contradict his public statements. So how can I trust his assessment that the deal circumvents his intent, when he can't even give an accurate depiction of the deal. It is obvious he doesn't understand the full nature of the deal because he can't even get what the objective of the deal correct.
That's what it will take to convince me. When someone shows me that I'm wrong with actual evidence, then fine, I'll admit I'm wrong. But here in this issue, no one has shown any PROOF that Novell is Anti-FOSS or that the deal "violates the spirit" or "circumvents the intent" - only a bunch of opinion that has no basis in fact.
And the problem is that a small faction is letting this deal, which has yet to be shown as negative for FOSS, cause more division. What should be happening is that the people who are dissing Novell without proof should stop talking about Novell and advocate the positives of Linux, and FOSS in general, and get at least one new Linux user each month.
edit: Don't forget to register those new Linux users: http://counter.li.org/
I registered years ago when they first started it, but didn't stay "active" and so had to re-register.
> Allison claims that the MS-Novell deal circumvents his intent in using the GPL v2. Ok. That's the claim. But as with the claim about the moon and its composition, there needs to be proof.
He has to prove it was his intent? lol. Remember what you were trying to argue against? "Or more specifically, attempted (and succeeded) to circumvent the intent of the authors of that software.". If he says it was against his intent, it was against his intent, period. That's not what you are now trying to argue against, you're trying to change the argument.
> For each claim, there must be supporting evidence. So far, not a single critic of the MS-Novell deal has been able to point out one single instance where any freedom was lost by any user of GPL software.
You're trying to change the argument again, the problem isn't that it takes away freedom directly, it's that it creates a situation where it's profitable to attempt to take away freedom, so is much more likely to happen. It's taking away a RESTRICTION. Like I said, "It opens a path to classic UNIX destructive behavior by allowing one entity to profit from freedom by attacking that freedom given to others. Section 7 is intended to prevent this scenario with patents, but the indirection used by Novell circumvented it.".
If you don't like that restriction, fine, license your own code under the BSD rather than the GPL. We didn't, we used the GPL.
> For each claim, there must be supporting evidence.
Like your claim Novell's market cap is much larger than Red Hat's? :)
You seem rather anxious to defend Novell even to the point of it being ridiculous..
> It is time for the Novell bashers to put up or shut up. Provide real evidence and not just "reasoning".
Have you intentionally not been listening to anyone for the last few weeks? I have to wonder why you're so anxious to defend Novell..
He has to prove it was his intent? lol. Remember what you were trying to argue against? "Or more specifically, attempted (and succeeded) to circumvent the intent of the authors of that software.". If he says it was against his intent, it was against his intent, period. That's not what you are now trying to argue against, you're trying to change the argument.
> For each claim, there must be supporting evidence. So far, not a single critic of the MS-Novell deal has been able to point out one single instance where any freedom was lost by any user of GPL software.
You're trying to change the argument again, the problem isn't that it takes away freedom directly, it's that it creates a situation where it's profitable to attempt to take away freedom, so is much more likely to happen. It's taking away a RESTRICTION. Like I said, "It opens a path to classic UNIX destructive behavior by allowing one entity to profit from freedom by attacking that freedom given to others. Section 7 is intended to prevent this scenario with patents, but the indirection used by Novell circumvented it.".
If you don't like that restriction, fine, license your own code under the BSD rather than the GPL. We didn't, we used the GPL.
> For each claim, there must be supporting evidence.
Like your claim Novell's market cap is much larger than Red Hat's? :)
You seem rather anxious to defend Novell even to the point of it being ridiculous..
> It is time for the Novell bashers to put up or shut up. Provide real evidence and not just "reasoning".
Have you intentionally not been listening to anyone for the last few weeks? I have to wonder why you're so anxious to defend Novell..
> I am not hopeless to be convinced, but you and a couple of others refuse to rise to my level of "proof": that is provide specific software package (which in this case Samba has been put forward) *AND* an applicable patent. So far, no one has done so. Ipso facto, the circumvention isn't real.
Stop building strawmen. Even without ANY valid patents, this allows Microsoft to litigate while Novell is immune. This would be profitable for Novell, as it would force customers to them. This gives Novell a profit motive to cause, or allow, Free Software's freedom to be attacked. "Liberty or Death" has become "Liberty or Death or Novell".
This is EXACTLY the kind of attack on Free Software's freedom that section 7 is intended to prevent. It's the major advancement over the BSD license, and what has kept the community strong. Since Microsoft and Novell claim to have bypassed section 7 with their deal, we are now vulnerable to this kind of attack.
If you don't get this, you are indeed hopeless.
Stop building strawmen. Even without ANY valid patents, this allows Microsoft to litigate while Novell is immune. This would be profitable for Novell, as it would force customers to them. This gives Novell a profit motive to cause, or allow, Free Software's freedom to be attacked. "Liberty or Death" has become "Liberty or Death or Novell".
This is EXACTLY the kind of attack on Free Software's freedom that section 7 is intended to prevent. It's the major advancement over the BSD license, and what has kept the community strong. Since Microsoft and Novell claim to have bypassed section 7 with their deal, we are now vulnerable to this kind of attack.
If you don't get this, you are indeed hopeless.
Quoting:"Liberty or Death" has become "Liberty or Death or Novell".
swbrown: To be more specific, I would say "Liberty or Death" has become "Novell or Death". Doesn't that remind us of a monopoly saying "MS/Windows or Death"!!!. It sure seems like Liberty has been totally removed as a choice. Fat chance in H*LL for the MS-Novell alliance.
They haven't bypassed section 7 and if you don't get that you never will.
Even without the MS-Novell deal, there was always the same level of threat against FOSS developers and users. What this deal actually does is force MS to sue Novell directly if they want to file suit over a patent.
Which is better Redhat's "indemnity promise" or Novell's contractual obligation to stand in my place in court? If MS decides to sue me for some IP I got from using Redhat, Redhat will pay the costs, but I still end up spending my time in court. If MS decides to sue me for some IP that I got from SLED, then they have to take Novell to court instead.
Even without the MS-Novell deal, there was always the same level of threat against FOSS developers and users. What this deal actually does is force MS to sue Novell directly if they want to file suit over a patent.
Which is better Redhat's "indemnity promise" or Novell's contractual obligation to stand in my place in court? If MS decides to sue me for some IP I got from using Redhat, Redhat will pay the costs, but I still end up spending my time in court. If MS decides to sue me for some IP that I got from SLED, then they have to take Novell to court instead.
> They haven't bypassed section 7 and if you don't get that you never will.
They've stated they have! They have a FAQ with a topic "How is this agreement compatible with Novell's obligations under Section 7 of the GPL?" that states they have! Eben Moglen himself looked at the agreement for weeks and decided it does bypass section 7! RMS agrees! At this point, are you really serious or just trolling?
> Even without the MS-Novell deal, there was always the same level of threat against FOSS developers and users.
No, now there is a DIFFERENT level of threat - threat against Novell vs. threat against the world. Novell not only gets a free pass to watch its partner sue to destroy the rights of others to software it can distribute immune, but they PROFIT if that happens. If section 7 was in effect, this would destroy Novell's business as well and they would have to fight it. Liberty or Death has been circumvented. That's one of the reasons we license software under the GPL, and it's been circumvented.
If you don't understand why this is dangerous to Free Software, you're blind. The fewer people that have to stand up to defend Free Software, the more likely it will be harmed. Getting people to stand together against an adversary is the essence of the GPL.
They've stated they have! They have a FAQ with a topic "How is this agreement compatible with Novell's obligations under Section 7 of the GPL?" that states they have! Eben Moglen himself looked at the agreement for weeks and decided it does bypass section 7! RMS agrees! At this point, are you really serious or just trolling?
> Even without the MS-Novell deal, there was always the same level of threat against FOSS developers and users.
No, now there is a DIFFERENT level of threat - threat against Novell vs. threat against the world. Novell not only gets a free pass to watch its partner sue to destroy the rights of others to software it can distribute immune, but they PROFIT if that happens. If section 7 was in effect, this would destroy Novell's business as well and they would have to fight it. Liberty or Death has been circumvented. That's one of the reasons we license software under the GPL, and it's been circumvented.
If you don't understand why this is dangerous to Free Software, you're blind. The fewer people that have to stand up to defend Free Software, the more likely it will be harmed. Getting people to stand together against an adversary is the essence of the GPL.
Novell does NOT get a free pass - MS can sue them over the same IP rights that you're so worried about. The customers of Novell don't get a free pass - they simply have Novell as a shield. No one is getting a free pass. Novell's customers simply have been granted deeper pockets to resist pariahs like Microsoft and SCOG. Novell does NOT profit if MS sues customers of Redhat, or Debian users.
How exactly is being COMPATIBLE with section 7 of GPL v2 a circumvention of the license again?
As for trusting the pronouncements of Professor Moglen, we were promised by him that a "ruling" from the FSF board would be announced a week ago (Feb 15, 2007). Where is that "ruling"? Shouldn't he at least made a follow-up announcement if there was a delay? He verified that the quote was correct with another journalist. Since I can't trust him in this, how can I possibly trust him in any other pronouncement regarding the MS-Novell covenant?
How exactly is being COMPATIBLE with section 7 of GPL v2 a circumvention of the license again?
As for trusting the pronouncements of Professor Moglen, we were promised by him that a "ruling" from the FSF board would be announced a week ago (Feb 15, 2007). Where is that "ruling"? Shouldn't he at least made a follow-up announcement if there was a delay? He verified that the quote was correct with another journalist. Since I can't trust him in this, how can I possibly trust him in any other pronouncement regarding the MS-Novell covenant?
> How exactly is being COMPATIBLE with section 7 of GPL v2 a circumvention of the license again?
It's not. It's a circumvention of the intent of the copyright holder. The copyright holder has stated so, and he's the only person qualified to determine such. Why you can't take his word as to what his intent was is beyond me.
It's not. It's a circumvention of the intent of the copyright holder. The copyright holder has stated so, and he's the only person qualified to determine such. Why you can't take his word as to what his intent was is beyond me.
Because Mr. Allison has also stated two things:
1. He doesn't know all the details of the deal.
2. He made the claim that the deal is not about "interoperability" whereas everything made public about resulting developments from that agreement show that the agreement is about nothing BUT interoperability.
Edited: Besides, Allison's "strawman" argument isn't even valid since offering protection against lawsuits is *not* one of the software freedoms intended (as stated by the author of the GPL) nor does it restrict in any way against the freedom of the endusers to do what they want with the Samba software. If Mr. Allison has some other "intent" then he should have clearly outlined it in further licensing, prior to releasing Samba under the GPL.
As Mr. Stallman has so eloquently pointed out on numerous occasions, the GPL is intended to foster software freedom. Mr. Stallman has even outlined what those software freedoms are. The MS-Novell deal in no way removes or restricts any of those freedoms with regard to the Samba software package. Therefore, there is no circumvention of the intent of the GPL, since the intent is clearly software freedom as defined by the seven software freedoms.
What Mr. Allison is yelping about is really unspecified intent on his part. He has never outlined anywhere that organizations distributing Samba should not be allowed to become proxy defendants in lawsuits, acting on behalf of their customers. If that was his original intent, then he should have licensed Samba to specify such. If that only became his intent *after* learning about the MS-Novell deal, then he has no reason to continue squawking.
Edited: Besides, Allison's "strawman" argument isn't even valid since offering protection against lawsuits is *not* one of the software freedoms intended (as stated by the author of the GPL) nor does it restrict in any way against the freedom of the endusers to do what they want with the Samba software. If Mr. Allison has some other "intent" then he should have clearly outlined it in further licensing, prior to releasing Samba under the GPL.
As Mr. Stallman has so eloquently pointed out on numerous occasions, the GPL is intended to foster software freedom. Mr. Stallman has even outlined what those software freedoms are. The MS-Novell deal in no way removes or restricts any of those freedoms with regard to the Samba software package. Therefore, there is no circumvention of the intent of the GPL, since the intent is clearly software freedom as defined by the seven software freedoms.
What Mr. Allison is yelping about is really unspecified intent on his part. He has never outlined anywhere that organizations distributing Samba should not be allowed to become proxy defendants in lawsuits, acting on behalf of their customers. If that was his original intent, then he should have licensed Samba to specify such. If that only became his intent *after* learning about the MS-Novell deal, then he has no reason to continue squawking.
> 1. He doesn't know all the details of the deal.
He doesn't need to know all the details to determine that a specific detail violates his intent.
> 2. He made the claim that the deal is not about "interoperability" whereas everything made public about resulting developments from that agreement show that the agreement is about nothing BUT interoperability.
That is entirely a matter of individual judgment. You don't know all the details of the deal either, and probably fewer details that he does. Why should we value your judgment over his?
I will also point out that he was most likely referring to the deal from Microsoft's viewpoint, not Novell's. Microsoft and Novell have admitted that their views of the deal differ. For Microsoft, it appears that the IP sections of the deal are far more important than the interoperability sections.
He doesn't need to know all the details to determine that a specific detail violates his intent.
> 2. He made the claim that the deal is not about "interoperability" whereas everything made public about resulting developments from that agreement show that the agreement is about nothing BUT interoperability.
That is entirely a matter of individual judgment. You don't know all the details of the deal either, and probably fewer details that he does. Why should we value your judgment over his?
I will also point out that he was most likely referring to the deal from Microsoft's viewpoint, not Novell's. Microsoft and Novell have admitted that their views of the deal differ. For Microsoft, it appears that the IP sections of the deal are far more important than the interoperability sections.
>Non of them signed an agreement that included FOSS or GPLed software. Novell is the only company that did, no body else
Says who? Says you?
I can almost (but not guaranteed) that you are dead wrong. For one thing, their consulting arm does a lot of work with GPL'd software (hint -- they support Linux, including Linux on the mainframe). It's been years since I looked at an IBM support contract, but I would be shocked if it does not contain provisions that provide more or less the same kind of protection that the Novell agreement purports to provide.
Better, actually, because the world's largest IT patent portfolio happens to belong to none other than IBM.
Says who? Says you?
I can almost (but not guaranteed) that you are dead wrong. For one thing, their consulting arm does a lot of work with GPL'd software (hint -- they support Linux, including Linux on the mainframe). It's been years since I looked at an IBM support contract, but I would be shocked if it does not contain provisions that provide more or less the same kind of protection that the Novell agreement purports to provide.
Better, actually, because the world's largest IT patent portfolio happens to belong to none other than IBM.
Quoting:I can almost (but not guaranteed) that you are dead wrongCite one example and I am willing to admit I am wrong right here on LXer.
Quoting:HopelessDidn't I say he is hopeless before? Guys, He keeps going in cirlces. Save yourself time and drop it
Well, if nothing else, The Microvell deal has certainly spurred discussion. Over 60 posts on one thread, plus several other threads devoted to the topic, plus threads in which somehow this deal became the topic of discussion. I can honestly say that I have never seen a topic bring so many people together to talk about one thing for so long. :-)
/me goes back to dark cave...
/me goes back to dark cave...
don, I think it's a sign that the deal and what novell and microshaft have said about it are deliberately vague, ambiguous, and full of doubletalk, to the point that a rational analysis is not possible. Hence all the circular 'blind men describing an elephant'-type discussions.
Which in itself is telling- when they can't say what's what in simple, direct language it means the truth is ugly.
Which in itself is telling- when they can't say what's what in simple, direct language it means the truth is ugly.
:-)
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help
Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

Allison claims that the MS-Novell deal circumvents his intent in using the GPL v2. Ok. That's the claim. But as with the claim about the moon and its composition, there needs to be proof. He claims that Novell is circumventing his intent by not providing equal protection to downstream users. OK - where specifically is this occurring.
For each claim, there must be supporting evidence. So far, not a single critic of the MS-Novell deal has been able to point out one single instance where any freedom was lost by any user of GPL software. And that includes the great and infallible Jeremy Allison.
The deal has existed for 3 months. Prof. Moglen claimed on February 2 that we would see some big decision come from FSF on this whole issue with Novell in 2 weeks. That decision is overdue - so far, all I've seen is a lot of smoke blowing. It is time for the Novell bashers to put up or shut up. Provide real evidence and not just "reasoning".
It's one thing to claim that Tux was assassinated but it's a whole other thing to prove it.