Advanced

Linux users tell Ballmer to put his code where his mouth is

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 30 comments
engadget
Mail this story
Print this story

We're pumped for a real showdown in the upcoming months, since the Linux community has just launched Show Us the Code, a website / movement humoring Steve Ballmer's repeated claims of burgled Microsoft IP within the open source OS -- accusations he's been making ever since Microsoft and Novell went into cahoots with each other back in November. The grassroots organization challenges Ballmer to bring it on: if Microsoft forks over the evidence by May 1st, Linux developers will alter their code accordingly to maintain freeware status.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: Microsoft, Novell, Community, Linux; Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (30)

IP does not HAVE to be code

I'm not really sure where the free software community got off track... but IP infringement does NOT have to be with code. It can be as simple as a concept or merely how things are presented. IANAL, but a quick look at Microsoft patents (thank you google) show that pretty much every operating system violates existing Microsoft patents.

There's no need for Microsoft to put up code.... I don't think they plan on trying to show that Linux contains Microsoft code somehow. There's many, many easier IP issues they can pick on.

Just my two cents.
>There's no need for Microsoft to put up code...

I'm not sure I'm following your thought on this.

Many of us have followed SCO v IBM closely, and the big collapse of SCO's case in Dec 2005 was when they couldn't show The Judge code.

>It can be as simple as a concept

While there are more sophisticated arguments against this, if concepts are patentable, then I can patent "love," justice" or any abstract, and charge you a fee. Scary argument you made. Do you really want that?

>how things are presented

While I'm not sure about patents for presentation actually having been litigated, it seems clear presentation cannot be copyrighted: The results of both Apple v MS and Lotus v Borland were pretty clear on that, the "look & feel" issue.

>pretty much every operating system violates existing Microsoft patents

We knew this. Did you have a point to add?

That leaves Trademarks and trade secrets as IP goes. While a trademark probably does not have computer code associated with it (except those cool DeCSS code t-shirts maybe), Linspire/Lindows won the trademark case against them by MS in a really telling way.

So did you have a point about Microsoft's trade secrets? Remember that any patent is no longer secret, you have to state publicly what you invented to get a patent on it.

What we want to know is, with specificity, which MS property they think has been violated or infringed. Without that, what they're claiming in the media is the worst kind of FUD.
>While there are more sophisticated arguments against this, if concepts are patentable,

In theory, at least, concepts are not patentable -- a claim must reduce theory to practice.

However, IP embraces more than patents, and copyright law protects concepts up to a point.

For example, it is not sufficient to change names and places to avoid copyright infringement on novel, etc.

With regard to code, it would apply to a non-literal copying, ie, writing code "heavily influenced" by the source.

It's why they have Chinese walls.
silly me, I thought all this "eye pee" craziness was just an implementation of the old saying "in a town with only one lawyer, the lawyer starves. Two prosper, and three build an industry"
(EU) "Software as such isn't patentable, but in a computer implemented innovations are".

Yeah, crap! Darn those EU compromises!

Quoting:but IP infringement does NOT have to be with code


Please read their site. It states:

Quoting:If Linux developers are made aware of the code and pantented ideas
http://showusthecode.com/

Please read 'computer implemented inventions' instead of 'ideas' (stupid writer over there), since ideas are not patentable, even in the US, as far as I know.

BTW: Sadly for him, $teve Ballmer doe$ have plenty of ($trange) idea$, but mo$t of them are not even computer related.
> since ideas are not patentable, even in the US, as far as I know.

Tell that to MS. The number of idea patents we've seen listed from them seems infinite. What the pattent office is thinking by even concidering these is behond me. Lets hope the courts set these guys straight.
Better do it quick, before MS patents the judicial process and demands royalties on every decision. Sigh.
> Better do it quick, before MS patents the judicial process and demands royalties on every decision.

They don't need to. They bought it lock, stock, and barrel in 2000. :(
Quoted from http://www.m-w.com/cgi-bin/dictionary

Main Entry: 1code Pronunciation: 'kOd Function: noun Etymology: Middle English, from Middle French, from Latin caudex, codex trunk of a tree, document formed originally from wooden tablets 1 : a systematic statement of a body of law; especially : one given statutory force 2 : a system of principles or rules 3 a : a system of signals or symbols for communication b : a system of symbols (as letters or numbers) used to represent assigned and often secret meanings 4 : GENETIC CODE 5 : a set of instructions for a computer

What I'm thinking, in the broadest sense of the term possible, is that all "IP" is in fact code. This is a philosophical argument, and not necessarily a legal one.

In this sense, a song and a computer program are not really different, the song may be expressed as sheet music (a symbolic code) or represented sonicly.

A computer program may be expressed as a written symbolic language (C, JAVA) or represented digitally.

Maybe IP does HAVE to be code, in some sense?
You didn't watch in the sun while your mother told you shouldn't, I hope, Aladdin?

(If you don't get that, http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0138704/)
Quoting:There's no need for Microsoft to put up code


Yes there is. MS has to point to specific *linux* code and tell us exactly what MS patent it infringes (and why). This is about Linux code, not MS code.

I suggest you search groklaw.net for a rundown of SCO-IBM, especially the "methods & concepts" part. In order for Linux to violate an MS patent, the patented material has to exist in code somewhere in Linux. If it's not implemented in code then there is no violation. Period.
Yeah, Microsoft can threaten all they want. Until they show us where the patent infringement lies, they really should just shut up. :-)
>Yes there is. MS has to point to specific *linux* code and tell us exactly what MS patent it infringes (and why). This is about Linux code, not MS code.

Agreed.

>I suggest you search groklaw.net for a rundown of SCO-IBM

Agreed.

>especially the "methods & concepts" part. In order for Linux to violate an MS patent, the patented material has to exist in code somewhere in Linux.

Agreed as to form and principle. But I have to grant this fact from above as well,

>However, IP embraces more than patents, and copyright law protects concepts up to a point...

We've gotten our Copyrights and Patents confused (patent pending) in this thread it seems. There's little if anything about patents in SCO v World+dog (always wanted to say that).

Still, whatever MS is complaining about, I'm sure demanding specificity is the right strategy.

Groklaw fall down. :-(

"Sorry, there are hardware problems with the database server, the RAID card is fried. Prognosis is that it will take till tomorrow EST to fix the machine. Groklaw will be down until then."
> Until they show us where the patent infringement lies, they really should just shut up. :-)

We'll all concede the code for SOS to them. Whenever they're ready....
>Groklaw fall down. :-(

>"Sorry, there are hardware problems with the database server, the RAID card is fried. Prognosis is that it will take till tomorrow EST to fix the machine. Groklaw will be down until then."

Thankfully, the main ibiblio.org site is not impacted. And tldp.org is still up and running. I wonder what other ibiblio.org hosted sites were impacted.
I noticed LXer was down for me as well most of the day for me. Is someone having a go at major Linux sites here? Groklaw and LXer down at the same time really got to my nerves (as in withdrawal symptoms).

Going the wrong way, need to address the patent system

they're going about it the wrong way - we already know basically everything we've ever written violates some set of patents and we surely violate some of Microsoft's given how many they've filed and for such trivial things. That's the problem with the software patent system - people patent the obvious, or even other people's inventions (BlueJ), and wait and watch to see if anyone else steps on it as if they were landmines. You don't know they're there until your leg gets blown off. How do landmines 'foster innovation'?

What needs to happen:

1) Get it out in the open and start trying to change the software patent system.

2) In combination, start a defensive patent movement to tear it down from the inside - start filing patents on damn near everything you write with terms that permit use in any non-proprietary Open Source (hopefully some lawyers will step up to define this in a way that works). Make the big players in the industry hate the software patent system as well, and they'll help tear it down.
> change the software patent system.

You mean eliminate it altogether.
jimf,

You can't eliminate something that doesn't exist. So-called "software patents" are actually either "design patents" or "utility patents". The trouble comes in when unethical corporations submit patents that are solely software-based. The patent process is designed to protect inventions in progress, so with the right weasel words, it is not so apparent to a non-programmer patent reviewer that a "device" is made up solely of software code and no one else will review it because of the need to protect the inventor's "invention".

This sort of thing isn't limited to the PTO. While in the USAF, because I needed a hard drive to put in a PC that originally came with just dual floppy drives, I created a requisition for a "large capacity data storage device." I knew this wording would go right over the heads of the logistics people at SAC HQ. The reason I had to go to this extreme for such a simple request (back in 1990) was that all requisitions for "standard" computer parts had to go through command channels to be bought off the national contract. The idea was to cut costs for hardware and software. The result was having to wait several months for things like hard drives, mice, monitors, etc. There was a loophole - for "non-standard" hardware, the Chief of Base Supply (my boss' boss in this case) could approve purchases on a case-by-case basis. In the end, I got my hard drive (40 Meg RLL as I recall) in 48 hours instead of 48 days - and at less cost than the national contract for computer equipment to boot.

And I don't care what many of the old-guard "experts" say - software code is not simply a form of expression for mathematical algorithms. No more so than an artist drawing a circle is performing a mathematical expression. But that's a different debate for another time.
> You can't eliminate something that doesn't exist. So-called "software patents" are actually either "design patents" or "utility patents". The trouble comes in when unethical corporations submit patents that are solely software-based. The patent process is designed to protect inventions in progress, so with the right weasel words, it is not so apparent to a non-programmer patent reviewer that a "device" is made up solely of software code and no one else will review it because of the need to protect the inventor's "invention".

So obviously, as far as US law is concerned, they do exist. At least until they are reviewed, which could be never.

As I said, eliminate it altogether.

>As I said, eliminate it altogether.

Eliminate what exactly? Patents? Not going to happen ... EVER. The fact of the matter is that by and large the US patent system does work. Occasionally you do have anamolies that give indications that a legislative repair may be necessary, but that's the way the system is built. It's very organic in nature. Identify the exact source of the problem and fix the cause but let's not throw the baby out with the bath water.
Quoting:Eliminate what exactly? Patents?


No, we were talking about software patents (I thought). The US patent system may work rather well, software patents don't, at all. Software should be protected by copyright, not by patents, since patents (ought to be / ) are about implementations, and software patents are (most of the time) about processes and ideas, and are very vague / say nothing about implementations most of the time.
My point is that there is no such thing in the US as a "software patent" so they can't be eliminated. What obviously needs to be changed is the review process for patents involving software code. "Utility Patents" and "Design Patents" which make use of software code are perfectly legitimate. And it has been held by the US courts (as was highlighted by Microsoft in MS v. ATT) that software code itself is not patentable, but must be attached to a device or process.

So again my question is: Eliminate what exactly?
DarrenR114,

You're just playing with semantics, or being obtuse.... But either way it's annoying. In any case software, in any way shape of form (yes, that includes "Utility Patents" and "Design Patents") belongs with copyrights, and 'not' patents (ie generic "software patent").

Is that exact enough enough for you?
jimf,

WRONG.

Having gone through the patent process quite recently, I can tell you from experience that you are incorrect.

Yes, the company I work for also did the copyright route for the software source code, but the software still had to be included in the patent claims for the utility patent because some of the claims were based on the way a certain set of softwareis being used in a certain manner.

I'm told by the patent attorney it works the same for design patents. All components of an invention must be specifically described. If a component of a new device is "control software", for instance, then that software must be described in its function and design. This would not make the said patent a "software patent". It would be an invention that includes software.

And it's not just "semantics". You go to your congresscritter and ask that laws be enacted to eliminate "software patents". You'll be told that the law already exists - software is not patentable in and of itself. If you want things to change, you've got to be specific *and* correct about what's wrong with the situation. The problem isn't that the law allows for software patents - it doesn't. The problem is that the current review process is not necessarily adequate for the literal deluge of patent applications.

A patent is supposed to worded so that a layperson, not necessarily employed in the field of endeavor, can reproduce the invention independent of the inventor. What do we need to do to change the process? If you're not intimately familiar with the complete process, then you're not in the position to make suggestions. Having the PTO asking you or me for improvements to the patent application process would be like the engineers of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge asking the pedestrian off the street how they could have improved their construction process. The pedestrians would certainly be able to point to the results of the problem, but I doubt even 1 in 100 of the witnesses could have identified the cause of the failure of the Tacoma Narrows Bridge.

Instead of demanding that software patents be eliminated, how about asking your congressional representatives how Microsoft seems to be able to circumvent the law as you understand it? Who knows? Maybe by you asking the question, a congressional inquiry might just happen, and then maybe, just maybe, some needed patent reform.

Let me just close with this analogy:

Calling for the elimination of software patents is like demanding laws be enacted against murder, stealing and rape: the laws are already there - we just need to find out why they don't seem to be working.
> WRONG.

Well, yeah, you are indeed wrong. Sorry, If you (and undoubtedly your company) disagree, I'd expect that.

> the laws are already there

Yes they are and they need to be changed or repealed. It may not be good for Corporate, but it is in the best interests of the US Citizens...
@jimf -

You want to *repeal* the laws that preclude software patents??

Could you do me a favor and re-read my previous with an attitude toward comprehending what I wrote. You're now making zero sense.
> You want to *repeal* the laws that preclude software patents??

Absolutely...

> comprehending what I wrote.

Oh I do, I do.

> You're now making zero sense.

No, what now exists makes zero sense. Way past time to correct that. What you did get right is that this needs to be handled through legislative action.
I think we agree - but I'm not sure ... I'm SOOOO confused.

Is your main complaint that it seems that the flimsiest of patents seem to be getting approved a lot more? If so - I agree.

I don't believe "eliminate them" is a valid answer, because there's nothing for Congress to act on - the current law is supposed to prevent them from getting approved. Now, "Fix the law so inventors don't get patents on software inventions" is something to chew on - but may still be unnecessary: I don't know because I have only a small bit of direct experience with the patent process. What may be necessary may be as simple as gettting the PTO to hire some more application reviewers who have extensive IT experience so that the existing law may be more effectively administered. I think the first step is definitely getting Congress to at least start an inquiry as to why it seems there are so many "software inventions" (which is different from inventions that use software).

The patent process does work for the most part - I think that what's happening is akin to the $600 hammers that get sold to the DoD. Anomalies that get a lot of publicity give the impression that the whole system is broken.

So, now that leads us to the next question: Who wants to start the drive to get Congress to actually investigate the problem?

I think I'm being a little more expansive than you in what I see 'software' needs to cover, but otherwise, yes I agree with you. I think that 'anything' software needs to deal with copyright law 'not' patents. This probably means that we'll have to get rid of patents in that area by passing specific legislation (more laws :P ) to actually accomplish the goal.

> Who wants to start the drive

Oh boy... I don't even know where to start, and I suspect that there will be certain parties opposing that have more experience (and a lot more $) than we do. Or maybe this is just one of those days I'm feeling a little old to have to keep up with the revolution ;-) ...

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post