Open standards advocate comes out in favor of Microsoft
|
|
|
Comments (25)
Conversion not the issue...
Microsoft certainly has dirty hands in this whole affair. They absolutely were on the ODF committee. They had every opportunity to ensure that ODF could work well for Office. I have no sympathy whatsoever.
Anyway microshaft are poopyheads, which trumps everything else.
We do in the US, if you travel elsewhere it does become a problem.
Nope. You need to go back to your history books. We have one electricity standard because it turned out to be better than Edison's competing standard.
>Anyway microshaft are poopyheads, which trumps everything else.
Can't argue with that. In fact, it applies to Open XML, which is really just an open wrapper for closed "standards".
Quoting:I would have no problem with Open XML if it were truly open
On a bigger picture, I would have no problem with multiple standards if they are truly open. That would give you the many flavors of ice cream and tooth paste. It will also give you more innovations and creativity.
In the case of XML, there is no need for multiple ones, we don't need them since XML is eXtensible without limits. Practically speaking, XML allows you to have standards within standards. That is what MS is exactly using for their Open XML. But MS is being what it is. They have to have control, and they have to be different otherwise it can't be the abusive monopoly they want to be.
Questionable argument
"On whether Open XML was started to stop ODF, he pointed out that Microsoft had started work on developing an XML data format back in Office 2000, work that predates some of the ODF work."
I don't understand this at all. My understanding is that MS pretended to open up only a couple of years ago. Who cares if they were working on an XML data format for Office 2000?
They were working on it since 2000 and yet ODF started later and has made more progress than their openxml?
currently reading their 47 meg pdf standard and about halfway through it and there is now way anybody could implement this without possible patent infringement with microsoft. what a mess.
odf is nice you can easily implement it on any device IMO.
Follow the money
Is he on Microsoft's payroll now?
Looks like the work he did before was
a) Just a few days, b) Not covert, c) Ok with the Wikipedia folks.
If Micrsoft paid him to say the things that he said, it should be made public. Otherwise, it might do you well to grow up and let people make an honest living.
Quoting: it might do you well to grow up and let people make an honest living.
Nothing wrong in making an honest living, on the other hand, making a living by wrongly vilifying some one else isn't. Are the quoted really honest statements? Let's see.
Quoting: However, today there are two competing open standards, the Microsoft initiated Open XML which is part of Office 2007 and the Sun initiated ODF,Since when Open XML is open? Does its schema carry the qualification of being open? Not really. It is controlled by MS alone, isn't.
Quoting: On whether Open XML was started to stop ODF, he pointed out that Microsoft had started work on developing an XML data format back in Office 2000, work that predates some of the ODF work.Can he or MS verify that the work started in 2000? MS was a participant on the OASIS committee, how come they never mentioned it? If it wasn't to kill ODF, what was the real reason then if there was one? Couldn't MS work with OASIS on unifying the two standards for the benefit of "openness" and the consumers which MS claims to listen to?
Quoting: On the accusation that ECMA is a second rate organization, Jelliffe said that it was a different kind of organization than W3C and Oasis, aimed at standardizing contributed technology. It is not a standards invention organization.This is just fat and no beef. ECMA is a second rate organization when being compared to ISO, not to W3C and OASIS.
Quoting: Some have suggested the Open XML standard, at 6,000 pages, is too long and impossible to properly read and review. However, Jelliffe said that it grew to that size because during the review process at ECMA, non-Microsoft people demanded more complete documentation and thus it grew to that length because of its openness.They demanded more documentation because MS has a huge part of its previous file format supported in the specification without documentation. They added junk to fulfill the request. The complain is about junk in 6,000 pages, not the valid specs.
Quoting: ISO is an organization where each country has one vote. "I have been accused of selling my vote at ISO. I don't have a vote at ISO so I can't be bribed for that," he said.Influencing votes is even worse than selling a vote.
This next one takes the cake for dis-honesty. Let's work each statement alone
Quoting: "It's very good for Microsoft to be involved in standards again. For many years, the large companies have not been very engaged in the standards world.Sure it is good, on the other hand, what was the out come of MS participation in OASIS? A competing standard to serve MS interests alone by locking consumers and to compete to kill ODF. MS even didn't want to create a translator initially and was give an ultimatum, either you inter-operate or be isolated. They had to be forced by organization to cooperate. Is he being honest about a company that claims to respond to customer needs and requests?
Quoting: Being pro-Open XML doesn't make you anti-ODF.Yes it does, ODF & "Open" XML are not complimentary, they are competing standards for doing the same thing.
The next one takes the icing. A cheap shot at ODF.
Quoting: They have been developed for different purposes.Their purpose is not different, and they don't have to be different, they both are specification for document formats. MS and its lackeys (you) are making them different to serve MS interest. To lock consumers and to control the market using monopoly power.
Quoting: If you want something for interchange and if it is platform neutral, then I'd tend to ODF.Well, this is the purpose of the XML standard. ODF does a good job at, why doesn't "Open" XML do the same?
Quoting: However, if I wanted to make sure that all the data in the document opens up the same way, then I'd go for Open XML," he said.This is the cheap shot. Are you saying ODF doesn't? what a crock. If the MS claimed "Open XML" is truly open, ODF will sure make all data in documents open up the same way not for ODF files only, but also for "Open XML" files too without any fuss or hassle. This is dis-honesty my friend.
I see no honesty in this whole article. I see nothing but mean blue bones.
Oddly, that's how I view your posting.
But only because they can't. The computing landscape has changed dramatically in the last ten years. The US no longer dominates like it once did.
Survival means learning and adapting, and MS is trying to figure out how much and how far it has to go -- not to mention can go -- and still make great big whopping piles of money.
> I do think they simply want to be able to establish their own standard - and promote it as the 'superior' one.
The proprietary Office format will be the 'superior' format. It will be easier to "improve" on Open XML so that they can lock in their customers' data. They will respond that they do have an available open format, it just doesn't have very many features that customers demand. My speculation is that they don't like ODF because it would be much harder to "improve" it than to improve Open XML.
http://www.onlamp.com/pub/a/onlamp/2007/06/14/achieving-open...
Rick Jelliffe - Isn't that they guy who took MS Money?
Why is that enough said?
One very short contract to do a specific task, with no effort to hide the fact?
Sorry, pal, but there is nothing wrong with that.
The problem comes when you take money and don't disclose the fact.
Quoting:The problem comes when you take money and don't disclose the fact.May be he didn't hide the facts, but he sure twisted them badly.
Find the real facts here
http://www.onlamp.com/pub/a/onlamp/2007/06/14/achieving-open...
I'm talking about hiding Microsoft's payment for his wikipedia gig.
Quoting:I'm talking about hiding Microsoft's payment for his wikipedia gig.Sorry Dino, I guess I have to watch & calibrate my scope a little.
They guy also earns by selling XML-desktop tools, so the more XML-ISO standards, the more bucks for him. Off course he wants as much XML standards as possible, what'd you expect?
Nothing wrong with it, but people shouldn't believe his crap.
When you say that, you sound as bad as you accuse this guy to be. By the evidence, Microsoft paid him to do one rather small thing. If Microsoft paid him to flog OpenXML, or regularly paid him to puff their stuff, that would matter greatly.
From what I can see, you're just making yourself look silly.
>They guy also earns by selling XML-desktop tools, so the more XML-ISO standards, the more bucks for him.
That, OTOH, makes a ton of sense.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

It is simpler to have a single standard, but it's also simpler to have one flavor of ice cream, one brand of toothpaste, and one model of car.
The question is, how do you get a single standard? The old Soviet Union should have taught us a thing or two about relying on a group of qualified planners to divine the best choices for the rest of us.
I would have no problem with Open XML if it were truly open. People could choose to use it or pass it by. Most importantly, though, is competing solutions could choose to reliably read it or write it, thus eliminating lock-in.
To me, freedom is the real issue, not convenience. The problem with Open XML is that "open" doesn't go much further than its name.