Advanced

"What's this 'DEEE-bee-en' you write about?" Or will Linux ever (ever?) make its move on the desktop?

Posted by Steven_Rosenber on · 37 comments
Click; By Steven Rosenberg
Mail this story
Print this story

The entries in this blog flow through my Twitter and Facebook feeds, and once in awhile a friend of mine who has nothing to do with the open-source software world wonders what the hell I'm talking about. Just this weekend, somebody asked me, "What's this 'DEEE-bee-en' you write about?" Would the question be any different with the word "Ubuntu" in there? I don't think so. When it comes to desktop Linux (not to mention BSD, which is even further in the geek ghetto), nobody knows what we're talking about.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial; Groups: Community, Debian, Fedora, Kernel, Linux, Slackware, Ubuntu

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (37)

17 earlier comments in the full thread.

Bigg: Good point. My case, PSU and fans are all about ~6 years old I believe, though some other parts are only ~3 years old, so in the long run DYI is probably cheaper.

Probably the feeling I described arose when I built two desktops almost 'from scratch', and then I eagerly looked at some Dell-advertisements.
I haven't built from scratch yet, but the ability to pick your parts is very enticing.

I'm not looking to do anything fancy - just a motherboard with some kind of quad-core, 6 GB of RAM, decent and Linux-friendly (and cheap and preferably fanless) graphics, a 1 TB hard drive or two and a fanless power supply.
The "bare-bones" offerings you can get are often decent as a start. And I have built my own machines in the past. But the time lost & component failure rate is a money/time pit. If you are looking to build for a defined purpose (eg: server or HTPC) then it may make sense. But if just for pride/ego, I feel it's a waste of time.
For anyone in Australia go to http://www.pioneercomputers.com.au/ you can order computers with and without any OS or with Ubuntu preinstalled. Sometimes you will have to send the machine back because the BIOS doesn't support Linux properly, but I've had several netbooks where they installed a different BIOS, and all worked fine.

What I find is best is to get them to make sure it works properly with Linux before shipping.

It's also a good idea, and can save you money (and also you can become a conduit for friends etc) is to become a business customer. You will need to register a business name (as a minimum) first.
Build-your-own means you get better parts, if you pick well. OEM machines, especially lower-end ones, are specced to the absolute minimum and as cheaply as possible. Crappy little power supplies, cases that savage your flesh, cheap fans that don't last, noisy, small capacity hard drives...ZaReason and System76 don't cheap out on parts, and you're guaranteed Linux compatibility. The big OEMs invest considerable resources into customizing their Windows machines; you can't even be sure a generic 'full retail' (what a scam) Windows will work on one of these. They're usually not upgradeable or customizable either. What they want is for the software to be so bound to the hardware that we get brainwashed into always buying them as a unit. And a lot of people do this, they have no concept of the hardware and software being separate.
ZaReason has an entry-level desktop for $299. You can upgrade to a dual core processor and it costs $338.

System76 offers a nettop for $259.

Thus it is not as though you need to go with the big boys to get an inexpensive desktop. From everything I've read, the service is very good, and of course Linux is installed when you get it.
There is a local company in Phoenix called Red Seven that sell computers that get upgraded to new hardware and whatever version of Linux you wanted on it upgraded for the life of the machine/contract.

Getting free hardware/software upgrades seems pretty cool to me.

http://www.redsevenlinux.com/services/

Scott, that's a vendor I haven't heard of. And while I'm calling for the big vendors to offer Linux, I'm very grateful for System 76 and ZaReason. The more I hear Earl and Cathy from ZaReason, the more I like what they're doing.
building your own it cheaper in the long run. if you buy a good case it can last you years and through numerous motherboards. same can go for the power supply.

with linux hard drives last a long time. linux seems to be easier on hard drives than windows and this is the reason I am still using ide drives on my main server at home. I am forced to used windows at work and we lease our laptops and I go through like three hard drives during the lease and they all have been dells.

I also bought a netbook from system76 and it has been nothing but quality. they give you one with 2gig of ram when everyone else has 1 gig of ram for the same price or even more. I have also put numerous distros on it and they all work out of the box sleep,hibernate,3d, and everything.

but this little netbook is great. I have been using it so much I am thinking of giving up my servers and just use the netbook. But I will see as time goes on and components fail.
I pretty much got rid of all the desktop machines I had. They were all old and not upgradeable.
I've had just as many component failures on machines that I've bought vs. built. The trouble with built is that you then have one component holding your project up. Then you have build time, burn-in (not that manufacturers burn machines in anymore), OS installation & tweaking, etc. Hardware choice is nice, but too much trouble, unless you are going with the same components in multiple build projects (2+ of the same machine).

I spent weeks researching what I wanted for my server & front-end HTPCs, & ultimately went with stock, consumer machines. It was way simpler & cheaper.
Picking your own components -- it's a crapshoot, for sure. For desktops/servers anyway, it looks like ZaReason does the "is it compatible?" work for you, and uses replacable/upgradable components.
I've strongly considered ZaReason or System7 for my wife's next laptop. Her (circa 2002) Dell Inspiron has seen better days.
I'm with you. Letting the "pros" figure out the hardware seems like a good idea.
Seems I never bought hardware that didn't run with Linux last seven years, except for 'newer' onboard-ethernet chips; the drivers were not in the Linux kernel back then (though they were a few months later). Most of the times I checked on the internet for Linux-compat before buying.

But of course _both_ my desktop and OS are from scratch, which also helps a little since you don't have to rely on choices other people made.
> ...except for 'newer' onboard-ethernet chips...

Ethernet and sound are normally the ones which have given me problems. But like you, I've found they're normally resolved within a few months. Often, simply upgrading to the latest kernel will fix all my problems.
The last hardware problem I had was with the ASROCK motherboard. The CPU clock was stuck at 800 MHz, after supposedly being tested for 3 days by the integrator.

Fixing that was a matter of doing a ROM update.

What really sucked is that they had no facility for doing a ROM update from Linux. Only Windows and DOS.

DOS? FreeDOS? Yep. FreeDOS live CD, format thumbdrive; reboot Linux, write the updater and data file to the thumbdrive; Freedos live CD again, flash ROM.

I wrote back to ASROCK that they could easily make a FreeDOS minimalist live CD image with their updater and ROM image available to customers, they didn't write back.
The new Asus ROM-flashing technique, involves a thumb drive formatted to FAT12. No need to boot a DOS or Windows system; the BIOS can read the update directly. (About dang time!)
> formatted to FAT12

That's _wonderful_.

I was so pleased when the USB keyboard was recognized and used by the boot sequence, so I didn't need to use the PS2 connector keyboard that I've kept "for just such emergencies".

Anyway as a quick aside, just how big a disk can I format in FAT32? I ask because I'd like, as another tool for the "my computer is broken", to have one of those external USB driven disks that both Linux and WinXP/7 can read and write.

The problem being that those disks are coming formatted in NTFS, and how to get Linux writing to NTFS is not easily obvious.
> ...and how to get Linux writing to NTFS is not easily obvious.

Debian, correct?

http://technowizah.com/2006/11/debian-how-to-writing-to-ntfs...

Though I'm surprised it's not already in there by now. As you can see this is an old howto.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post