Advanced

More on Active strategy

Posted by Fettoosh on · 54 comments
http://aseigo.blogspot.com/; By Aaron Seigo
Mail this story
Print this story

We get a lot of questions about Plasma Active, and I'd like to address a few of the more common once in this entry.

Openness ...

QtQuick / QML ...

Plasma Desktop / Netbook ....



Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story; Groups: Community, KDE

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

Comments (54)

34 earlier comments in the full thread.

@ta: I agree about the resizing icons.

Usually, you resize something to get more space, but they grow to fill the space.

It just feels incredibly annoying. Would it be SO hard for them to add a setting to switch the behaviour off?
Quoting:Dolphin is unnecessary,


It might be unnecessary to you, but necessary for many others. Besides, I believe it will become more obvious how necessary Dolphin is when the planned integration of PIM & Symantec desktop indexing & search are added to it.

Like I said before, I agree the automatic sizing of the icons is unnecessary, but that doesn't make Dolphin useless to everyone. There are many other features that make Dolphin an important tool.



tracyanne, hmm, it seems that you can close the places bar in the dialogs but it comes right back the next time. That is annoying if one wanted it off.

The old KDE konqueror had a sidebar with several different selectable panels, one of which (if memory serves through mist) was very similar to places.

I'm not trying to be difficult, but what exactly is it that you hate about having a place panel (I already gather the silly resizing issue and not turning off)? I mean do you hate the GTK places bar to the same degree in Firefox?
@patrokov, in case you have not already read what I wrote earlier.

"... I find it incredibly annoying that the icos resize to fill the available space, it's annoying and unnecessary especially as I don't get the choice, and I didn't/don't resize it to get bigger icons.. I don't want bigger icons I want more space... "
Actually trying out KDE, I had a bit of a Windows XP moment.

One of the the first things I did, after trying out the menu and discovering the same awful in-place-type menu thingy that I have on Windows 2008 server, was to switch to "Classic" mode. I'm not an old stick-in-the-mud, I just prefer whatever is easier. For example, the new menu organisation of Windows 2008 Server is really unforgiving if you make a mistake when navigating around it with a mouse. It almost punishes pointer mistakes.

All these new-fangled (crikey, I sound like an old man) application launcher designs seem like people scratching around for a different way of doing something that works really quite well as it is.
Quoting:One of the the first things I did, ...


I do the same. I still find classic hierarchical menus to be most effective and practical. Lancelot does a much better job at combining the classical features with the new style menus. One of the nice things about KDE plasma is it accommodates for multiple menus and allows placing Lancelot menu as a widget either in the panel or any place on the desktop.



@tracyanne, and in case you didn't read what I already wrote, "I already gather the silly resizing issue"

But is that really the ONLY source of your venom? ridicule? certainly, but it's seems that you hate it. I mean, how often do you resize the place menu? Is it because Dolphin doesn't remember your settings? Now THAT would seem much more annoying.

[Edit: AHA moment]: Is it that you wanted to see the full name of the folder, but the only way to do that is to get larger icons AND text?
Wow.

Just one more day and this thread will have been running for a full month.

At least it's not about something trivial like war, peace, poverty, or curing cancer.
@dino, we don't have time for such trivia.
@ta

And a good thing it is, too.

Besides, beauty contest entrants are already hard at work on those issues.
@patrokov: "But is that really the ONLY source of your venom?"

A single very annoying behaviour can foul your experience of a whole product, if it is something that you encounter regularly during the course of your work.

Really, this particular issue breaks one of the most fundamental rules of UI design, that it should never surprise you, that it should do exactly what you anticipate.

The side bar should behave exactly the same as the main window, because that is what one would expect. My perception of what I would expect is the behaviour that we see in Nautilus, KDE 3.5, Mac OSX and Windows Explorer for the side bar, that its width would be fixed (by the user) and scroll bars should appear when there is not enough space vertically. It is no coincidence that so many different UI implementations do it this way. It just feels right.
Quoting:A single very annoying behaviour can foul your experience of a whole product, if it is something that you encounter regularly during the course of your work.


And I do. I use a file manager application a lot. I don't, when a using KDE desktop, use the plasmoids, for the same reason I don't use desktop icons. I don't like having to clear, or partially clear my desktop, in order to access something that always only available on the desktop, as a consequence I don't have file view plasmoids. I simply find a full blown application, such as a file manager more useful. As a consequence I find the behaviour of the places panel annoying, so I don't use Dolphin, and I remove the places panel from Konqueror.

Other than that my experience of KDE4 (4.6) has been pretty good.

One small annoyance has been that on my netbook, I can't find a Network Connection Manager, when using the KDE Desktop. So if I suspend the machine from the KDE desktop, I can't reestablish a wireless connection when I unsuspend, and have to either go back to GNOME or reboot.

That more than the places panel is stopping me from using KDE full time.
Those "trivial" things, namely war, peace and poverty, (you forgot to mention economics) serve to provide daily examples of the Peter Principle in action. At least in the fields of FOSS and Linux, most people are (perhaps only somewhat, but nonetheless significantly) more cognisant of the limits to their competence and expertise.

(As for curing cancer -- those guys are doing about as well as (or better than) can be expected.)

Quoting:I can't find a Network Connection Manager, when using the KDE Desktop. So if I suspend the machine from the KDE desktop, I can't reestablish a wireless connection when I unsuspend, and have to either go back to GNOME or reboot.


I am running Kubuntu with KDE 4.7.1 and don't have this problem. I have no idea what is causing this issue for your, but I believe KDE 4.7.1 has a newer version of KNetworkManager among many other enhancements and bug fixes that made it more reliable and robust than 4.6. I would give it a try.

>> I can't find a Network Connection Manager, when using the KDE Desktop. So if I suspend the machine from the KDE desktop, I can't reestablish a wireless connection when I unsuspend, and have to either go back to GNOME or reboot.

In PCLinuxOS, there's an applet called "Network Center" in the system tray that manages wireless (and wired networks).

How do you quote in HTML? I just have a blank text box with no formatting assistance/direction.
@patrokov, on this site, use (quote) and (/quote), but change the parentheses to square brackets.
Quoting:How do you quote in HTML?


You mean here on Lxer?

Just put the text you want to quote between opening and closing tags like [ quote] some text [ /quote] without the blanks I inserted after each [ to prevent quoting.

another hint: if you go to preview then the help appears. so write text, hit preview, check the help to use the tags (bbcodes), then send.

greetings, eMBee.
Quoting:another hint: if you go to preview then the help appears. so write text, hit preview, check the help to use the tags (bbcodes), then send.


so helpful. I thought I had somehow turned formatted posts off in my profile but couldn't find the option.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post