Advanced

LXer Feature: Welcoming Newcomers to Linux and FOSS, or, the Least You Can Do is Not Chase Noobs Away

Posted by tadelste on · 14 comments
LXer Feature; By Carla Schroder
Mail this story
Print this story

What is the future of Linux and Free Software? A rigid little cult that accept only the Right People? Or a community that truly practices "Free as in Freedom"?

The Linux/Free/Open Source world is changing, and such is the price of coming closer to "world domination." The more people turn to FOSS, the more diverse the user- and developer-base is going to be.

This, like all great grassroots movements, mixes the bitter with the sweet. It's like when the Wrong People discover your favorite great, but not well-known, band. Suddenly all of these uninformed trendwits are listening to it, clogging their shows, talking at all the wrong times, saying all the wrong things, and dancing when they should be listening reverently.

Or, it's like when the black monkeys gang up on the brown monkey- it's different! It's wrong! It's a threat! It doesn't have a geekbeard or parrot the correct buzzphrases! Beat it with sticks!

More Points of Entry = More Better

Newcomers to FOSS sometimes get beat up pretty good. They get criticized for running FOSS apps on Windows. They get criticized for using Linspire, Xandros, Crossover Office, and other Impure Linux Borkenings. They get jumped on for asking noob questions. They get jumped on for not understanding that "Free as in Freedom" means "as dictated and overseen by the Meddling Judgmental Friars of Freedom."

Get a grip, ya crabpots. The more points of entry, the better. Beginners need a lot of handholding. Remember your beginning days? Perhaps they were brutish and painful. So why make it a tradition? Unless your real goal is to keep out "The Wrong People." So start a noob out with Firefox, Thunderbird, OpenOffice on Windows. Fix them up with a nice PC already running Linux- expecting new users to install Linux is an unnecessary hurdle, though it is easier than ever, and easier and faster than installing Windows. Help them with migrating their data- that's the biggest hurdle to Linux adoption.

Do please refrain from going all ballistic over specialized Linux User Groups. Groups created by and for women attract all the resident screaming meemies who just can't understand why us girls don't want to hang out with their unpleasant selves. There are faith-oriented LUGs, LUGs devoted to particular distributions, noob-friendly LUGs, advanced-user LUGs, coder LUGs, sysadmin LUGs- these all attract and support different users, and add to the overall strength and richness of the FOSS world.

Training wheels are good. Expecting someone who is new to Linux to instantly overhaul their entire computing infrastructure and personal philosophy is beyond unrealistic- it's delusional, not to mention counter-productive. One step at a time works very well, and is preferable to alienating new users, and possibly chasing them away forever. Bitching and preaching at people definitely does not work, and only hardens their opposition. Try something truly radical, something that is even more radical than FOSS itself- try listening to Linux noobs, and understanding what their real computing needs are. They know better than even the finest, most brainest FOSS geeks what their needs are.

Huzzah to the Good Guys

To the many fine folks who are patient and helpful with noobs, thank you, and please continue being patient and helpful. Especially with explaining the importance of Free Software, the difference a software license makes, and the importance of the underlying philosophy. Let the results speak for themselves- we don't need FUD or propaganda to make the point. Just the facts.

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial, LXer Features; Groups: Community

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (14)

I hope this is a continuing feature

Many, perhaps most points need repetition. My first answer to a Linux question was a response from a individual that is essence meant: Linux was his/her play thing and the hoi polloi would just ruin everything.
Strangely enough, my experience is completely opposite. I've only ever received nice and helpful replies to my questions. Maybe I'm just choosing the right people to ask instinctively ;) . Even when I filed a bug report to Debian with the wrong label, I got a really nice reply which pointed out my mistake extremely politely, and even corrected it!

On the other hand, don't start me about the so-called Windows "community", help forums, etc... I never got a useful reply from those people, and most often my very polite and informed questions were answered with flames.

Of course, YMMV...
I've seen both sides. So, I understand you having different experiences.

Lately, I'm seeing more friendliness than before.

When I first started in Linux, hostle or rude responses were not uncommon. The situation has gradually gotten better. Most people will now, at least try to, give you a civil answer.
"we don't need FUD or propaganda to make the point. Just the facts...oroblem is and will remain so...anytime there is a comparison of product a to product b, there will be some that construe it as Fud. If I tell you quite pointedly that The linux file system works without a registry, you can count on those who will respond. "aha! THATS why Linux fails...It Has no REGISTRY."

therefore the fud flies furiously fast.

helios

"aha! THATS why Linux fails...It Has no REGISTRY."

Wow helios! Now I know why Linux is so prone to crashing.

Good one :D.
Doesn't Gnome have a Registry? so we're OK!
Oh no! a sneaky attempt by Gnome to get Windows users to choose them :)

Talk about Byzantine.
Byzantine?

Ain't that some kind of Chocolate Drink for business people?
Forgot to mention that I was reading "Linux for Dummies".
dinotrac: Definitely a business drink... Not sure it's chocolate though.
Doesn't Gnome have a Registry? so we're OK!

Yes it has... sort of. I know, because I ended up editing it using gconf, when I upgraded from Evo 1.4 (Fedora Core 2) or such to 2.2 (FC4). Couldn't find its mail signature files... the paths had changed.

The good news is that it's not one file, but a directory tree full of XML files. (But I'm sure someone can construe this as a weakness :-/ )
As this is ressurected, let me point the way to THE EXACT person Carla may be talking about. I will supply the text here and the link as well for those who doubt.

Re: Linux - Why This Is Not The Time Linux is not about "coming out" for other people to try. Frankly, folks here in the open source community could care less if you folks try Linux or not. Only recent converts who do not know anything about Linux try to promote it. It's a cultural thing, ok. It's a community. Japanese people don't tell the whole world that they should all become Japanese. You do not expect people in Europe to use Chinese yen. We do not expect your relatives to try Linux.

By the way, if you expect Linux to be like Windows, you are not part of our community because we expect members of our community to be smarter than that, and check for hardware compatibility BEFORE they buy hardware ... if you do not do that, you do not know the first thing about our community, and we do not want you in it.

Now, that being said ... once folks realize that we do not want them in our community, then they will want to come into it all the more. People always want what they can not have. And until you understand how our community works you can not come in. To be a member of our community you must stop trying to use American dollars in our European grocery. We do not accept that currency. That is, the ignorance of the customs of our community.

The custom is RTFM.

http://lobby4linux.com/modules/weblog/details.php?blog_id=28

The Best Linux Distribution of them all

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post