Christians Challenge Microsoft to Support OpenDocument for Disadvantaged
Vision-impaired citizens of Massachusetts have found new allies in their efforts to defend their right of access to public documents. The effort by Microsoft to impose a proprietary, non-standard format for public documents is the threat to such access. Massachusetts CIO Peter Quinn recently chose the OASIS OpenDocument and Adobe PDF as standards for public documents instead of Microsoft's incompatible, proprietary XML format. He faces a well-financed political attack for that choice. Joining advocates for the vision-impaired are proponents of free and open standards led by spokesman Don Parris, an ordained minister and libre software advocate. Microsoft has made the Massachusetts decision to adopt OpenDocument as a standard appear to be one of locking out Microsoft. In reality, it is a rejection of Microsoft's proprietary document format, a format which hampers interoperability and shuts out competing office productivity programs. Parris finds this recasting of Massachusetts' decision disturbing, "Microsoft stated they were railroaded in Massachusetts. The truth is Microsoft has chosen not to support the OpenDocument format (ODF), thus ignoring the needs of Massachusetts' visually-impaired employees. Their unwillingness to support ODF sends the wrong message to visually-impaired people. It says Microsoft doesn't care if visually-impaired people have a need to share documents across office suites running on different operating systems." Currently, Microsoft Office has a monopoly on productivity software adapted to visually impaired users. Their refusal to support ODF effectively bars such users from access to ODF documents. Unlike Microsoft's proprietary XML format, the OpenDocument format was developed by a consortium of large companies and non-profit organizations to be an open standard that anyone can support. As ZDNet's David Berlind observed, "Compared to OXRS, ODF gives open source developers the latitude to pick whatever open source license they want, which is one reason why it passed Massachusetts' test for openness and why ODF was ultimately selected as a standard format for storing the state's documents." OpenDocument is more mature and more widely tested than Microsoft's own XML format (OXRS or MSXML), which won't be available until MS Office 12 is released sometime in 2006. Meanwhile, OpenDocument has been, or is being, adopted by a number of governments outside the United States. Because OpenDocument can be supported by anyone, Microsoft has the option to support OpenDocument alongside their own proprietary format. The libre software proponents, consisting mostly of Christian ministers and laymen, consider Microsoft's reaction to Massachusetts' decision appalling. "Rather than meet their customer's requirements, Microsoft is attempting to hold hostage the visually-impaired by not supporting OpenDocument when they could do so with relative ease," said Parris. It is the visually-impaired people who stand to lose the most in Microsoft's fight against OpenDocument in Massachusetts. Visually-impaired people deserve to enjoy the same document sharing capabilities as other people. Lee Dambrosky, a visually-impaired mission worker who has joined with the clergy in their challenge to Microsoft, agrees they should support the OpenDocument format. The Visually-impaired are not the only ones who will be negatively impacted by the lack of OpenDocument support in Microsoft Office. Low-income people seeking to lift themselves out of their poverty could face extensive difficulty trying to share documents with businesses requiring Microsoft's native document format for compatibility purposes. Low-income users could hardly afford Microsoft Office, the most expensive suite in common use today. OpenDocument gives low-income users, who are more likely to use OpenOffice.org than the costly Microsoft Office, an opportunity to run a powerful office suite to manage their entrepreneurial ventures, or even to work as free-lance writers. Additionally, the failure of government agencies to Adopt OpenDocument as a standard format could be viewed as depriving the less fortunate of their right to equal access to government information. The group of Christians believes it is imperative they speak up for the disadvantaged because many of them don't even realize there is a standard document format that will benefit them. IBM and Sun Microsystems have been encouraging businesses and other entities to adopt OpenDocument. Vendors of office suites that do support OpenDocument have pledged to add in features that help the visually-impaired. However, until that happens -- or Microsoft supports OpenDocument -- the visually-impaired will lose out on the benefits that OpenDocument offers all users around the globe. The group encourages Microsoft's customers to request support for the OpenDocument format, so everyone can share documents across operating system platforms and office suites. People can visit the OpenDocument Fellowship web site (www.opendocumentfellowship.org) to sign a petition for this purpose. Signed:
Oakdale Christian Fellowship |
|
|
Comments (15)
Doing what's right vs Doing what's Microsoft.
Microsoft could, with very little effort, solve this problem. Or, with all the money being spent lobbying over this issue, we could hire programmers and finance an open source solution to this problem.
Certainly this is not the end of this issue.
What are you, some kind of wild-eyed crazy radical? Get a grip.
Of course you are right. But being sensible has never been a microshaft trait.
Weird
Pastors are people, too.
Church is not a thing that happens on Sunday morning. Many ministries take active roles in their communities, reaching out to people in various forms of need. Many pastors, church volunteers, etc, become experts at doing a lot with a little. That fits in beautifully with the strengths of free software.
When it comes to government software support, they are perfect reminders that government is obligated to serve some people who can't whip out the checkbook and pony up for whatever they please.
Pastors - OpenDcoument - The disabled Truckers - Cell phone access - Hurricane survivors Chefs - HDTV - Female Jazz Banjo players
Having said that, it's nice to see people who we wouldn't expect to get involved in this fight stand up and take a stand.
Might just be my outlook, but it doesn't seem so far out.
Pastors, priests, etc. often function as advocates for people in need. If the advocates happen to be tech-savvy, it makes sense that their advocacy would extend into technical issues.
Quoting:Geeks do push religious issues. ...
Being irreligious type I tend to stay out of those threads.
Read an interesting article, perhaps weeks ago if not longer, where a leader of a core fundamentalist group was disagreeing with Bush's stand on environmental issues. Indeed he had traded in his s.u.v. for a Prius and was mounting a campaign to educate his various related flocks (proper word?), but he was still skeptical of environmental activists. All I would said to him would be: "Welcome, what took you so long?".
So too on this issue, it is long overdue that others see their interests in parallel to software freedom. That is, to recognize it has much wider impact upon world concerns. Hence, many more segments (and their leaders) should be speaking in support.
Just listen closely and you'll still hear the cries:
"Die you vi infidel!"
"Repent all Emacs heretics!"
See, geeks are very religious.
:)
Don't know what may have taken him a long time (presuming he's just come around), but lots of religious folks are seriously concerned about the earth's environment. There is a biblical command to be good stewards of the earth...which, if you are a believer, is God saying not to screw it up.
What might be a long time coming around is the realization, once common, that even people with real differences can have significant common ground.
Just goes to show that diversity is everywhere. :)
Technically, we're supposed to be stewards of the Earth. That means not 'screwing it up', though the emphasis is on the managing and caring for it. Unfortunately, we missed the lessons the Native Americans taught us about being good stewards of our natural resources.
dotmil, you should know that I *am* an odd mix. ;-)
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

It does...
because...
People do care about the moral high ground. That's why Microsoft argues about disrupting the operations of the state instead of disrupting its own bottom line. That's why the American civil rights movement gained momentum when decent people all over the country could see, in their own living rooms, the terrible excesses brought to bear against the freedom riders, et al.
It's why this approach will wear down Microsoft. It's not fast. It's not easy. You inevitably get roughed up along the way. But it works when you are clearly in the right. The trick is letting people see. I think this whole Massachusetts OpenDocument thing is fabulous. More of it will be better still, even if we lose every battle along the way. Remember -- the goal is winning the war, not the battles. One of the greatest generals of the American Revolution made a strategy of losing battles cheaply over winning them at great expense. He wore out the enemy until he was able, finally, to win for good.