Advanced

Linux vs. Windows: Fight to the Death

Posted by grouch on · 90 comments
LXer.com; By Carla Schroder
Mail this story
Print this story

LXer Feature - 9-June-06

Every time someone boots up Windows, god kills a kitten. Bill Gates is the devil. Steve Ballmer is a sweaty gorilla. Linux is better than Windows, cures bad breath, and improves your love life. Linux advocates are foaming religious zealots who want to control everyone's lives.

Here we go again. More headlines: MORE WINDOWS WEB SERVERS THAN LINUX, HAHA! More sensationalism, more absence of facts, more junk reporting, more wailing and gnashing of teeth and indignant rebuttals from the FOSS crowd. THERE ARE NOT NEITHER GAINS BY WINDUHS, AND HERE IS LONGWINDED EXPLANATION WHY. Then all the analysts chiming in, WINDOWS WINNING! NO, FIREFOX IS GAINING! NO, IT'S NOT! Until I just want to slap them all into silence.

Incidentally, FLOSS is stupid. It's FOSS, Free and Open Source Software. This is computing, not dentistry. And if you want people to take you seriously, for god's sake learn to spell, where to put apostrophes, and the difference between "loose" and "lose."

I suggest that everyone take a deep breath, relax, and get a grip on the important issue, which is a very simple one. Yes, Microsoft software sucks. Yes, it is true that removing all Windows PCs from the Internet will instantly eliminate 95% of spam and malware. It's buggy, inefficient and insecure, and no amount of propaganda, fake studies, or fakier analysts will change that. Microsoft's business tactics set all-time records for corruption and bullying. Their new Live OneCare is the ultimate in both cynicism and contempt for customers, because the schmucks will pay up, and continue to pay and pay and pay for the privilege of using one of the most defective consumer products on Earth.

But none of those are the important simple issue. The most important issue is this:

Choice.

That's all. I shouldn't have to care what computing platform other people elect to use, what type of hardware they buy, or what software applications they think are teh hawt. I shouldn't have to care about converting users to Linux, or taking market share away from Windows.

But I have to, because all those things affect me personally. Ballmergates have devoted their lives and incredible resources to taking away my choices. Because of their corrupt tactics, I cannot walk into a computer store and have a wide range of pre-installed computers running different operating systems to choose from. I have to shop very carefully to find Linux-supported hardware because the Borg work very hard to maintain a lock on hardware. If it weren't for tireless volunteer coders and reverse-engineering, there wouldn't be much left for us.

Because of Ballmergate's complete lack of concern for security, the public Internet is a cesspool. No, they didn't write and release all that malware. They just made it incredibly easy for any maladjusted dweeb with a smidgen of coding skills to do it. Amazing, isn't it, when they don't even have access to the Windows source code.

And if that weren't enough, now Microsoft is leading the DRM charge, which threatens both our consumer rights like nothing before, and our civil rights, and that's no hyperbole. (Please see DRM - Is It Worth Going To Jail For? and Microsoft Research DRM talk.

I didn't pick a fight with Microsoft. No FOSS advocate did. The giants of FOSS- Richard Stallman, Linus Torvalds, Maddog Hall, Alan Cox, Michael Tieman, Patrick Volkerding, Debra and Ian Murdock, and all the many others that I apologize for leaving out, created this great fertile ecosystem that gave computing back to the do-it-yourselfers. Microsoft could have left us alone. They could have even joined the party. But they won't. They want to kill FOSS dead.

So the next time someone crabs at you for dissing poor old defenseless Microsoft, and I shall go to my grave wondering at these losers who defend giant corporations for no good reason, just remember two things: they started it, and all we want are choices.

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial, LXer Features; Groups: Community, Microsoft

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (90)

Choice is not the goal

41 earlier comments in the full thread.

> Again, I am not advocating forcing them to choose the right terms. I am merely advocating the right labeling of choices. Not all choices get justified by the existance of freedom of choice, as ethical choices. Guys, that is all I am saying!

Libervis, this may go without saying, but you're preaching to the choir. We're not the ones you need to convince. We agree that FOSS licensing is better. Most of us even agree that it's more ethical, since it provides more benefits to more people than the alternatives (I suspect that you consider the alternatives unethical. I don't. I merely agree that FOSS is better).

The people you need to convince are those releasing their software under proprietary licenses. They undoubtably have what they consider good reasons for doing so. You should also be open to the possibility that in some small percentage of the cases, they may even be correct.
> I am actually advocating the same thing as he does.

Well yes, but in this case, you're preaching to the choir :)
lv:

Against my better judgment:

>I think you are actually the one falling into a (il)logical trap now. That's like saying that I don't have freedom to drive a warp starship because it doesn't exist.

No. It's like saying you don't have the freedom to drive a warp starship because you don't know it exists.

Then, when the owner makes the starship known, the owner lets you drive it, but won't let you work on the engines. You have gained freedom, not lost it.
And, perhaps been saved from radiation poisioning....

sorry couldn't resist that :)
@dinotrac

Quoting:I see no point in doing so repeatedly. Those to whom logic and reason matter will read and understand. They will agree or disagree, accept or reject what I have said.


Alright. I disagree and I have said why I disagree in my responses. I suppose we indeed don't have to continue on with that, if you choose so. :)

@jdixon:

Quoting:The people you need to convince are those releasing their software under proprietary licenses.


True. But if I fail to convince them and they still choose to release it under terms that disrespect users freedom, I will consider that choice a step out from the realm of freedom into the realm of mere power. I simply wont see it as an ethically justifiable choice (or choice of freedom). Alot of people will though and that's the problem I'm trying to address. But I suppose I've already expressed this enough times and in enough ways.

Quoting: They undoubtably have what they consider good reasons for doing so. You should also be open to the possibility that in some small percentage of the cases, they may even be correct.


Maybe, at least for the sake of knowing that I am not the all foreseeable, I can be open to the possibility that in some cases a choice of proprietary software licensing would be the correct one and even one I wouldn't consider unethical. In some of those cases someone may even be forced by the circumstances into such a choice.

However, from where I stand today, I don't see how would choosing proprietary terms be ethical in whatever situation in which users are restricted from excercising their basic rights with software they use on their computers.

OK, OK, the positive side of freedom... You won't need a night light.
@dinotrac

Sorry I didn't see your next post before writing my previous.

Quoting:No. It's like saying you don't have the freedom to drive a warp starship because you don't know it exists.

Then, when the owner makes the starship known, the owner lets you drive it, but won't let you work on the engines. You have gained freedom, not lost it.


I would rather put it this way. Before you knew the starship existed there was no freedom to have about it. There was no restriction whatsoever as how could there be a restriction with something that you don't even know exists.. It doesn't make sense.

Once the owner made the starship known it was not freedom that was gained, but merely the knowledge of the starships existance. This may be equivalent to the point where you know software has been released, but don't know under which terms it was released. If you are simply not interested in driving a starship you'll walk away (as you'd walk away from a program that does something you simply aren't interested in).

This is where the starship analogy starts to fail applied to the realm of software, because starship is a physical item. I mean, freedom to share a starship with your neighbour doesn't exactly ring right. :)

However, with software such freedom is indeed important and if you are by the circumstances forced to use software that is released under terms which do not allow you this freedom, then you are being harmed. Maybe in cases where you actually do have a different choice and the ability to make it the damage isn't evident, but as mentioned before, this is simply not always the case. Sometimes people are indeed locked out of alternative choices and hence hurt by the software proprietors freedom-disrespecting choice of terms.

Thanks
> ...I can be open to the possibility that in some cases a choice of proprietary software licensing would be the correct one and even one I wouldn't consider unethical.

See, we do agree. :) Our disagreements are largely a matter of degree, not of kind. I think that's true for the others here too.

The major disagreement you seem to have with myself and some of the others here is that we view software freedom as one aspect of a larger whole. For us, freedom as a whole is more important that just software freedom. After all, having all software be free means little to me if I'm in chains at the time. Thus, we feel it's important to clearly deliniate the points at which other freedoms override those of software freedom. You appear to be arguing solely from the view of software freedom and ignoring what we view as the larger reality.
jdixon:

I think you're right about context and viewing software freedom as a part of freedom writ large.

The whole "you are taking away my freedom" argument makes sense only if the release or proprietary software prevents the release of equivalent free software that people would/could happily choose to use.

This might happen in some cases, but the realistic answer is that the assortment of desirable software available to users would likely decrease, reducing freedom overall. RMS implicitly acknowledges that when he says that he would rather protect his freedom by using inferior (as in fewer features, harder to use, etc) free software in preference to proprietary alternatives.
> The whole "you are taking away my freedom" argument makes sense only if the release or proprietary software prevents the release of equivalent free software that people would/could happily choose to use.

Developers of non-free software tend to entice users into giving up freedom in order to use the software. The user must be willing to give up their freedoms (0-3), but the developer promises to maintain and support the software. Frankly, I feel the promises are broken more often than not. So the user actually gives up some of value for something of less value than anticipated. In that regard, non-free software is essentially a scam.
>So the user actually gives up some of value for something of less value than anticipated. In that regard, non-free software is essentially a scam.

You say that, but what has the user given up? To give something up, you have to have had it in the first place. If, for example, you decide to use MS Office, you are not required to delete your WordPerfect, OpenOffice, StarOffice, Abiword, Gnumeric, etc. As to freedom to much with MS Office internals, you never had it so you never lost it.

You could make a reasonable argument that the software world doesn't support competition...that dominant applications kill of the competition. In that sense, a proprietary application wielding monopoly power could indeed reduce freedom. That, however, has yet to be demonstrated as a long-term fact.

As to proprietary software being a scam. Seems to work out that way, doesn't it?
> That, however, has yet to be demonstrated as a long-term fact.

I would argue that for a number of years, MS Office did exactly that. Even now a .doc is pretty much the accepted standard and before relatively recent versions of OO nothing else could produce good .doc copies.
jimf -

I know that the IT world seems to move at ten times the speed of everything else, but MS Office hasn't even been around long enough to be long-term. Besides, MS Office is not merely a dominant application, it is the product of a monopoly that has abused and exploited its monopoly status. That makes MS Office a poor example -- it is not a dominant app on its own merits (though Excel is very good).

Apache and sendmail might be better examples. For that matter, Quicken.

I think I don't have much more to add without repeating what I already said. I still don't entirely agree with everything said, but there is also such a thing as freedom to disagree so I can leave it at that.

My views pretty much come from my tendency and attempts to make clearer distinctions between what I consider ethical and what I consider unethical. I believe in freedom of choice, but I also believe that this freedom can be abused in a way that negates freedom. When that happens it is no longer freedom that defines the state of things and it is no longer, I believe, possible to justify the abuse of freedom as ethical just because one had the freedom of choice at the beginning.

I agree that it is good to view at the whole thing in a larger context though and I think that point actually wasn't the main point of debate or disagreement here, as already acknowledged. The point of disagreement is seeminlgly a more minor one though still in my opinion important; wether unethical choices can be justified by the existance of freedom of choice or not. I say no.

We also all seem to be more or less in agreement that proprietary software ultimately leads to less choice. Microsoft's monopoly should be a very clear testament to that. Microsoft is a natural development in a world where proprietary software dominates. That said, every time soneone chooses to license software as proprietary he contributes to creating a world with less choice. We can at least agree on that, even if we don't exactly agree about what to call such a choice individually.
> but MS Office hasn't even been around long enough to be long-term. Besides, MS Office is not merely a dominant application, it is the product of a monopoly that has abused and exploited its monopoly status. That makes MS Office a poor example -- it is not a dominant app on its own merits

In the Engineering small business enviorment that iI worked in, MS Word had a lock on pretty much everything from about 95 through 03. Thak's a pretty long streach of time. Now I know that it didn't gain that advantage fairly, but, I'm also not sure how much it maters how the competition and our freedom get eliminated. It's still gone.
This is without a doubt the most profound debate on this issue I have had the privilege of viewing. Don, with all sincerity, I ask you to preserve this thread for future reference and enjoyment. I will do the same. This is a treasure that cannot be lost amidst the silt and salt at the bottom of the philosophical sea.

Carla's article (I refuse to refer to it as a rant) has not only inspired this flow of thought...it has brought out the issues and layed them bare for all to understand. My fear is that the majority of computer users have neither the capacity nor the will to comprehend the importance of this exchange. The irony is that in order for the Greed Machine to break down, understand this they must.

"Ballmergates have devoted their lives and incredible resources to taking away my choices."

This is key. And the motive for this massive expenditure of resources?

$$$

It seems that the FOSS community and the almighty dollar find themselves at odds again, or still...depending on your experience cycle and point of view. In most cases, I would put my money on...uh, the money, but not in this case. I believe that the virtues and strength FOSS is built upon will prevail. This is not a goal I seek from emotional and philosophical bindings, It is an outcome that, after the smoke of battle is cleared, will be triumphant. Argue all day the semantics of "freedom" if we must. Eventually the Greed Machine will grind to a halt because one by one, those who fed it via their wallets will stop providing it sustenance.

That act will come from the soul of man...not his bank account.

THAT is what keeps BallmerGates awake at night...they know it to be true.

grouch Story submitter ·
Opening statement of this thread:

"Users of Microsoft's OS have plenty of choice and yet still, they are prevented from sharing, inspecting, and improving their software (or hiring someone to do so)."

Such users are like prisoners who are offered a choice of meals and bedding. The jailer expends a great deal of money and time to create real or perceived barriers to choices that lead outside the jail.

Closing of the article:

"So the next time someone crabs at you for dissing poor old defenseless Microsoft, and I shall go to my grave wondering at these losers who defend giant corporations for no good reason, just remember two things: they started it, and all we want are choices."

Real choice means freedom. You can't have one without the other. The power to artificially raise the cost of certain choices is the power to effectively quash those choices. Microsoft uses many means to artificially increase the costs of choices they do not want computer users to make.
Helios and grouch: well said guys! :)
Not all non-libre software is bad, though: That very much depends on the provider. I have little problem using Opera, for example, as I feel I can trust the company. Same goes for freeware devs who do the program just for fun and/or to simply help people as a gesture of goodwill. That kind of closed software (though less preferable than FOSS from an ethical standpoint) I simply refuse to group along with M$'s and then call evil. They mean no harm, and just provide the program in the hope that it is useful to someone. It may be preferable to licence such software under an open source/free software licence, but releasing it under a closed one is hardly an evil act.

It's what you do with the code: The above are well-intentioned. What Microsoft does with the control that the licence gives it? Nothing too nice. FOSS licences force people to be nice because the code is available to all.

To me, it doesn't matter if the provider is nice out of necessity or choice, (or both), to me it is simply enough that they are nice to me and trustworthy in general. Opera Software ASA is a prime example of a good closed soft company.

Sorry, began to ramble. Will stop now.

thanks grouch

well said!!!

don't forget all the false anti-markets that microsoft has created because of their poor product, anit-spam, anti-virus, anti-spyware. these markets too are against linux because they would dry up if everyone ran linux. when I buy a computer I don't want to put anti- anything on it. It doesn't make sense - you have to undo what the os is doing or allowing to be done. silly rather silly!!
grouch Story submitter ·
Huh? That's Carla's article. I agree with your sentiment; it's just aimed at the wrong person. :)
Wow, Carla has a beard now?

You give Microsoft too much credit

>Microsoft's business tactics set all-time records for corruption and bullying.

Oh Carla, Carla, Carla. Your Microsoft worship must cease. It's true that are nasty, ruthless monopolists with the morals of an eel -- my apologies to any and all offended eels.

But...

all-time records?

Compared to the Old railroad and steel guys, or the oil trusts, Microsoft's a bunch of pussycats. Not content to let their paid-off politicians and cops do their dirty work, they happily hired Pinkerton's guards to shoot up and/or beat up whoever needed shooting and/or beating.

You see, Microsoft may be better and nasty business than they are at software, but they're not even world-class nasties.
It's a generally-accepted principal that economic harm is less serious than physically harming someone. I don't agree with that. I'd rather take a sock in the nose than spend the rest of my life subsidizing chairman bill, or any of the other legalized thieves. Weigh the uncounted billions of dollars of economic harm done by microshaft against the dirty deeds of the old-time robber barons, and they might still fall short. But not by much, methinks.
tc -

Only inflation makes Microsoft seem worse. Remember -

The old guys operated in a climate where government regulation wasn't even a concept.

Comparing MS to the Railroad Barons is like comparing the early Mafia to the current one. No need to kill people when you can use lawyers to establish a pseudo legitimacy. The goal is power and money, and, you can get that without physical violence.

In any case I think that a present day Corporation can do untold damage without lifting a finger... Enron comes to mind. MS may not be the worst plague to hit us, but they certainly aren't a beneficent force.
>Enron comes to mind. MS may not be the worst plague to hit us, but they certainly aren't a beneficent force.

In no way to I mean to minimize Micro-nastiness. Simply pointing out that we have some pretty nasty bad guys in our economic history, including all those sweet folks who caused the antitrust laws to be written in the first place.
OK, I concede that Microsoft is not the biggest corporate baddie of all time. Lessee, good candidates for that are DeBeers and the Royal Dutch Oil Company, both of whom adore controlling and manipulating markets, and using slave labor. If there is not a handy slave labor pool, then by gosh they don't sit around crying about it. No, they simply buy laws to force people into poverty and create one. Ingenious.
> Simply pointing out that we have some pretty nasty bad guys in our economic history

Point definitely taken :)
grouch Story submitter ·
tuxchick2: >"It's a generally-accepted principal that economic harm is less serious than physically harming someone. I don't agree with that."

A couple of decades of continuous paper cuts to hundreds of millions of people is pretty serious stuff. That's how I view MS.

The railroads had some people shot, just as the automakers did (see early GM strikes). This caused tremendous grief for those families and their friends. MS has bankrupted businesses in many unethical ways, destroying jobs, has quashed investment into start-ups, sucked resources from taxpayers in every industrialized nation, damaged markets and productivity in every economical area on the planet, for many years. Is the total amount of grief and anguish less than that created by the robber barons?
> Is the total amount of grief and anguish less than that created by the robber barons?

History continues... Same old, same old.
grouch -

Let us not forget that the damage done by robber barons was not limited to people shot. Competitors were destroyed and countless people ripped off by monopoly pricing.

FLOSS

Linux vs. Windows - The Principle of Evolution Think about how evolution works....nature creates a workable platform so that a better solution can evolve. So it is with Windows. Thank you Mr. Gates, from chaos you created a common understanding so that millions of very talented people from around the world can work together. We call this working together "Linux" and we call the original unifying force "Windows". Now that we all speak the same language, Windows cannot deny the creativity of millions of minds working together.

FLOSS YOUR TEETH

grouch Story submitter ·
>"Incidentally, FLOSS is stupid. It's FOSS, Free and Open Source Software. This is computing, not dentistry."

It ain't stupid; your funny bone has just been battered by too many didiots, lately.

As I told dinotrac in response to his challenge: http://lxer.com/module/forums/t/22592/

Free Libre Open Source Software

Yields Open Unrivaled Reviewable

Technological Excellence Evolving Through Humaneness.
That would make a dandy Burma Shave-type campaign! Little signs all lined up along the highway.
Yeah, I miss those.

My god, we're really showing our age tuxchick :)
Libre is not ambigious, Free is. Therefore, I say, we should get lost of the stupid word Free, because I get pissed of of the Beer and Freedom, and just call it LOSS.

Great marketing, huh? Forget about Microsoft and switch to LOSS! (Darn English language!)
I just call it all libre most of the time. RMS' philosophical stance aside, he explained to me that the X-11 styled licenses are still free (libre) software. I just use libre because I find it easier to explain the definition of the term than to wrestle with someone's pre-conceived notions about "free".
>Libre is not ambigious

It's the one in between Virgo and Scorpio, right?
No, that seems to be "Libra". It's the one with 'Logiciel' in front of it. Which makes clear again why English language is confusing and made by alcoholics: In French you can say FOSS in only two words without having to talk about beer and RMS, the latter also being ambigious for a measure of power.
>No, that seems to be "Libra"

That depends entirely on how well you spell. We here in the good ol' US of A ain't perzactly the best spellers.

Besides -- Iff'n you say it, it sounds the same!
In a nutshell...

first wife is German...taught her English myself. (I am now bald and way older than my 50 something years for the effort.)

Explained the simple rules of vowels in 4 letter words: If there is a silent e at the end of the word, then that dictates the middle vowel is long in sound; Bone, home, etc.

Sat down to dinner that night...wife said to me, "Why is "gone not following the rule you taught me today...and why is i before e except after c and in foreign? And why is..."

It didn't lead to my divorce directly, but having a wife that thinks you lied to her trying to teach her english isn't exactly the road to a healthy marriage. In a way...I'm glad she's gon(e). and no...I didn't learn my lesson...you would think I would marry someone fluent in the english language...nope...I married a Texas girl. We speak some of the most uh...let's see...uh, "creative" dialects of the language ever heard.
> "creative" dialects of the language

Ah... but that is the joy of English. A lifetime of fun and games.
Helios:

The first rule of English is that there are no rules. Any specific rule you may come up with only applies to a subset of the language, not the whole. The are just too many influences from too many other languages at various times in it's development. A process that is continuing to this day, as anyone who has kids who watch anime can tell you.

More people need to see it this way.

As I put it in one of the random taglines on http://penguinpetes.com/b2evo/index.php my blog, "I don't hate Microsoft. I just love Freedom. Microsoft hates Freedom. So we're enemies."

More people do indeed need to see it this way:

Windows also violates the International Law of the Sea, Murphy's law, the first and second laws of thermodynamics, and the principle of separation of church and state.

Windows is fully compliamt with P.T. Barnum's Law of Applied Economics.

Windows violates the law of gravity. Windows makes Baby Jesus cry.

About the use of Windows: it is impossible to sharpen a pencil with a blunt ax. It is equally vain to try to do it with ten blunt axes instead.

Beware the lollipop of mediocrity, lick it once and you'll suck forever.

phsolide I should have thought that Windows actually was demonstration of the second law of thermodynamics (chaos/disorder increases with time).

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post