Advanced

Top U.S. Court Clears Way for More Patent Challenges

Posted by azerthoth on · 10 comments
Bloomberg.com; By Greg Stohr
Mail this story
Print this story

The U.S. Supreme Court made it easier to challenge patents for failing to introduce genuine innovations, siding with Intel Corp. and Cisco Systems Inc. and dealing a setback to the drug and biotechnology industries.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about:

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (10)

On the two U.S. Supreme Court patent issues PJ writes in http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20070430121005424

Quoting:2 Major Patent Rulings from the US Supreme Court Monday, April 30 2007 @ 12:10 PM EDT

There are two major patent decisions from the US Supreme Court today, and here they are, both PDFs:

* Microsoft Corp. v. AT&T, * KSR Int'l Co. v. Teleflex Inc.,

We can read them together, but it looks from media coverage like the patent world as we know it has just changed. For the better.
PDF links to the above two U.S. Supreme Court decisions are http://www.supremecourtus.gov/opinions/06pdf/05-1056.pdf and http://www.supremecourtus.gov/opinions/06pdf/04-1350.pdf -----

Could anyone better clarify how the patent world is "for the better" by these two patent decisions??

> Could anyone better clarify how the patent world is "for the better" by these two patent decisions??

I'm not sure what you mean by your question. One decision said that there are geographical limits to patents. Another said that courts have to expand their notion of whether something is "obvious". At least to me, it seems this is a good thing. A problem with the patent system is that patents are too broad (in loose terminology).
Gotta use the acronym IANAL :)

Perhaps the better question is Who clearly gains the most from these two patent decisions??

As noted, Microsoft actually WON one of these two patent cases (vs AT&T here) geographically limiting patents to the U.S. From this case, one would guess that MS would focus its IP patent litigation FUD threats more and more on large companies headquartered WITHIN the U.S. Would not MS stand to gain the most from this refocus in the future -- in addition to its current billion$ saved from the outcome of the AT&T decision ???

At the same time, one would guess that making it "easier to challenge patents for failing to introduce genuine innovations" in the second case of KSR Int'l Co. v. Teleflex Inc. would lead to actual IP challenges against MS, should MS decide to actually (foolishly?) follow-through on its patent litigation FUD. This taken together with companies (such as Ubuntu's Canonical) tightening up their patent portfolios would grant a better and better outlook for FOSS.

Is any of this partially right ???
@ vainrveenr:

I'll let someone else do the legal interpretation, however...

as far as I can tell, Microsoft does not view the current patent system as their friend. They might be willing to scrap patents altogether if they had the option. Their IP FUD is just playing the current system to their best advantage.

They gain little from patents regarding Linux/open source, yet have to worry about lawsuits over MP3, patent trolls, and other real threats. I think MS and PJ would probably be in agreement about these rulings being a good thing.
>As noted, Microsoft actually WON one of these two patent cases

This is the problem with viewing everything through the lens of good guy/bad guy or friend/enemy.

It's OK for Microsoft to win something that benefits us all. Something that limits the scope of patents is a good thing. Thank you, Microsoft (sound of teeth grating).
> This is the problem with viewing everything through > the lens of good guy/bad guy or friend/enemy.

Good point on this ambigosity! PJ expresses a somewhat similar sentiment within her Groklaw comments on the U.S. Supreme Court decision:
Quoting:I also hope Novell and anyone else who signed a patent agreement with Microsoft over Linux is kicking themselves now.
Directly touches on the gray area of whether the Novell-MS patent deal and the resulting modifications to GPLv3 are to ultimately be considered "good" or "bad" for ALL parties concerned.
Quoting:Directly touches on the gray area of whether the Novell-MS patent deal and the resulting modifications to GPLv3 are to ultimately be considered "good" or "bad" for ALL parties concerned.


Ohhh, it's still "guy/bad guy or friend/enemy" for Some People, it's just that the bad guy/enemy is no longer Microsoft...
I find that I don't trust anyone who censors comments on their own site. I take what she says with a grain of salt.
Considering M$'s recent happiness with tossing everything at the patent office to see what sticks, I think that they would be a little less than happy with the loosening of the original work litmus test. How many of those "patent everything" patents can hold up to the test of "natural progression"?
Few, but consider MS spends more money fighting off the trolls than it spends patenting things it shouldn't patent.

Also remember that MS is very reactionary, much like SCO. They say and do what fits them best *now* and disregard how this might affect their future. They're just going to wait until the future arrived and then react again. That's why they're happy. It's good for them in the short run.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post