Advanced

Dell is not the spoon.

Posted by Aladdin_Sane on · 82 comments
LXer; By Aladdin Sane
Mail this story
Print this story

"Then you will see that it is not the spoon that bends, it is only yourself."

Is Dell's new Linux initiative doomed to failure?



There is some evidence.



Having recently separated myself from Dell, and having worked the next test bench over from where some Ubuntu testing was going on, I have some opinions that I hope are worth expressing.



Internally, Dell's management has noted that the IdeaStorm interest in Linux, while relatively high, consists of less than 1% of the market compared to Dell's Windows client/consumer systems sales. Not good numbers.



Others have already recognized that the retail price will inevitably be the same or higher than the Windows-equivalent system.



The strategy is only a 3-system "market test." There is no evidence (yet) that these Ubuntu systems won't be buried in the deepest dark hole the way the much better (in my opinion) n-Series systems currently are. Parity is not a marketing standard, concept or idea: Marketing sees only bias, they seem to thrive on it.



There is no evidence (revealed at my level) that marketing dollars will be spent equally in web-site ads, TV ads, other ads, or on the dell.com sales site.



Dell's previous attempt to sell Linux on client/consumer systems went from 1999-2001, and failed miserably. Some of those mistakes Dell seems destined to repeat. Corps do not learn from their history, for the most part.



The 'Dell recommends MS' tags are found on current dell.com pages that sell Linux systems, there is no reason to expect that that won't continue. See Dell PrecisionTM open-source Desktops with Linux for example.



I disagree with those who say that this move increases the relative value of Dell stock. Maybe in the long long term, but my Crystal Ball does not extend that far. (See disclaimer at the bottom of this post.)



This market test is US-only, so far.



For non-US news, there is a BBC article at Dell to use Ubuntu on Linux PCs. There has also been significant testing by Dell of Linux in the China market.



If a "lot of folks" express interest, it will not affect Dell, unless Linux becomes, say about, 10% of Dell's consumer/client sales. From the above 1% stat, that means increasing by 10x the interest there is now: And that interest must translate into sales: Dell is not interested in any other metric.



Finally, back to the original thesis: Dell is insensitive to customers wants/needs because one of their offered systems will be the Dell Dimension E520/E521, which the Linux community has already widely rejected as being "too buggy to be worth the time." Knowing this, Dell is going ahead anyway with that as their main offering: This is how-to-make-project-fail textbook-style.



(DISCLAIMER: The above is my personal opinion, feel free to shoot it down at your leisure.)

  Nav
» Read more about: Groups: Community

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

Comments (82)

This gives me a great idea for promoting Linux...

Why don't we start a $350,000 dollar campaign to promote desktop Linux? It's simple, we just get people to pledge to at least buy the cheapest Linux system that Dell offers ($699). Round that up to $700... if we just get 500 people to participate, that would be 500 x 700 = $350,000.00 worth of Linux promotion. Dell sees that there is US market demand for Linux and beefs up its offerings, and everybody who participated got a computer out of it (and who among us couldn't use a new one anyway?).

How could this lose? Win-win for everybody!

(-: I just couldn't resist...
Nice idea Pete... however I just bought a brand new Linux laptop (Micro Star "white box" custom built), so my hardware budget is shot for a while.
I'll support that idea. At least it's a productive one. I can't buy a computer, but I don't have a problem supporting people who want to promote Linux.
You first, Penguin Pete. Show us you're more than a click-hungry libelous mouth.
> we just get people to pledge to at least buy the cheapest Linux system that Dell offers ($699).

That's exactly what I plan to do, but I expect the price to be $450 or less, since the Windows equivalent system is $408, and the only upgrades will be to a DVD burner and a 250 GB hard drive. Those two upgrades shouldn't run more than $70, and I'd hope the discount for not buying Windows and not getting software technical support is at least $30. If it's more than $450, then I'll build my own machine instead, since I can do that for about $300.
I plan to, but am waiting to see what they offer. If it's nVidia video cards and Broadcom wireless they can forget it.
Quoting: I plan to, but am waiting to see what they offer. If it's nVidia video cards and Broadcom wireless they can forget it.
hmm, if they offer nvidia video and intel networking hardware, I'm all over it. Best of the best, that works for me.
Penguin_Pete, out of this room, young man.
Pete,

If you hashed out the details and had a good plan...you'd get my support...regardless of your disdain for me personally. I don't hold grudges and Linux can't afford them :)
devnet goes "I don't hold grudges"

Har har hee hee ho ho ha. Notwithstanding your various barbs, such as your inflamed remarks on my "Ubuntu is not Linux" postings on this very site ("Do I smell glue? Because he's been sniffing it."3/28/07), as a recent example? I still haven't found out which mysterious party traveled the web from end to end posting links to the posts on various websites lying "this is proof that Penguin Pete hates Linux!!!" Just before tux500 launched, coincidentally. Should I look into that next? By the way, note that I, unlike some, do not scream wolf/libel about what you say about me.

Not that I could care less; you can't grapple with high philosophical (and controversial) concepts on the Internet and expect to have everyone love you. I can live and let live with enemies, as long as they aren't launching a 24/7 hostile offensive. But the fact remains, you, personally, seem determined to stand waaaaay out of the crowd by being unable to go for a very long time without doing backflips to get my attention. So you can publicly complain to everyone when you get it.

I keep pointing out; all I did was speculate about tux500 in the first place. Just asked an innocent question. Was very careful not to name you or helios. Right away: bam, you're in my face, yadda yadda yadda. Without that, that one post - asking the question and discussing it with my readers, would have ended right there. I barely even thought anything of your involvement before that.

You don't want to hold grudges? Let's see ONE SINGLE SOLITARY WORD FROM ME POSTED ANYWHERE ON THE INTERNET THAT ISN'T IMMEDIATELY TROLLED BY DEVNET. Stay out of my face for a while, and I'd forget you ever existed - it's happened before! Is that so hard? Don't you have other things to do?

My annoyance at you amounts to the same as an irritation from a splinter. When it's out, it's gone; nothing personal. That's what you're mistaking for "disdain". YOU ARE NOT IMPORTANT ENOUGH TO EARN MY DISDAIN. Annoyance mixed with bemusement and pity is all you get. Deal with it, stalker.

As for the buy a Dell idea, I posted "tongue in cheek". I see some discussion of how helios "has a problem" with Dell (like we didn't see that coming?), so, I guess that was shut down already - possibly before I posted.

What a hopeless waste of time bantering with you is. My break's over, I have to get back to work. See you next year, when you'll be standing outside my house passing out petitions to have me banned from the Internet or whatever scheme you're hatching next.
This sniping ends right here. Right now. Not one more word, either way. Period.
Yes I'll buy one if I can. I doesn't look like the DELL Linux machines will be available in Australia.

Off the Mark

50 earlier comments in the full thread.

>if it were me I would broadcast a resounding "NO!" from the rooftops, instead of being dodgy. Since that is a hidden cost, the answer won't be an obvious one that customers can figure out on their own. I do hope Dell isn't pretending that Microsoft doesn't exert considerable control over hardware vendors- we know they do. That's not cynicism, that's reality.

Not to mention that there are a large number of small vendors (System76, Emporerlinux, Los Alamos Computers etc etc etc). who do not charge a Windows tax and provide a more than adequate substitute if Dell does decide to bend to M$.
Microsoft co-marketing funds are a substantial portion of the profit margins for many large PC retailers. Tweaking the nose of the giant might be fun but it’s risky. If Microsoft reduces the per-PC marketing contribution it makes for a particular reseller, that puts them at a huge financial disadvantage relative to their competitors. This means that one of the biggest issues a computer manufacturer or reseller faces in considering Linux pre-installations is the impact it will have on the Microsoft relationship, and hence bottom line.

I did not write that paragraph. This is an unedited quote from Mark Shuttleworth's blog. Do I care about the Windows tax? Not really, I just care about getting the best deal on hardware guaranteed to work with Linux, out of the box. But some people do. And according to SJVN, Shuttleworth and Dell would have been having discussions at the time of the post. He is not just another conspiracy theorist. He is in a position to know.
IIRC, one of the requirements M$ places on resellers that receive those co-marketing funds is the "We recommend Microsoft flavor of the month" line on every page selling a system.
I don't blame Dell for that, I blame US antitrust law, but I can understand why it upsets some Linux users.
Quoting:Tracyanne: the products we'll announce later this month will be for the U.S. No word to share yet on any plans beyond that, but thanks for letting us know you'd be a prospect.


Yes I'm a prospect, so are plenty of Australians, and in my experience plenty of Joe Average computer user types - it takes very little encouragement on my part to get such people to try a none Microsoft Operating system, IF you market desktop Linux properly AND don't get people all confused by recommending Microsoft products on every Linux Page, AND make damn sure that retailers and the public are aware that Linux is on offer.

From discussing such things with retailers I am quite sure that a significant number of the big stores would happily stock Linux branded computers, especially if they could differentiate it from the Microsoft branded ones, as a product/price point.

One thing we Australians get very tired of very fast is being treated like an after thought.
I discovered over at the Dell site that if you order a server, you can specify "no OS" and save some $700 over the default, which is the Windows server OS. You can also save if you configure with SLED. It'll cost you more, though, if you choose RHEL (but that comes with three years of support).

Just the fact that Dell offers bare servers -- and provides a big discount with that option -- is a sign to me that the company will "play fair" with the Ubuntu roll-out.

Now, if they promote Ubuntu as a COMPLETE desktop solution, with Open Office and all the other software associated with it, AND let their customers know that thousands of other free applications (and a dozen desktop environments) available for the platform, then they can really open some eyes, promote Linux, save people money and ... move some boxes. After all, for Dell, it's all about moving product and making money -- as it should be.

The other thing Dell can -- and probably should -- do is bundle their Windows boxes with Open Office, the GIMP, and all the relevant free, open-source apps they can find. It won't make Microsoft or Adobe happy, but again, Dell's customers would be very happy. Sure, the experienced among us can populate a box with loads of free apps over the course of an hour, but the "average" user can barely install MS Office from a CD. The more Dell bundles, the more the notion of free software (and NOT accursed "demo" versions) will be implanted in the minds of the general public.

As others have said, the Ubuntu-Dell deal no doubt has more to do with Dell's position relative to Microsoft than anybody is letting on.

And as I've also heard, a triple-boot Dell box -- Ubuntu, Fedora and openSUSE -- would be a great thing, too.
The moment I get my hands on my DELL Linux box, I'll be installing the latest version of Mandriva.
> Please know that not all on this site are so cynical.

No, some of us are more so.

> That it was peppered with questions about a world that was...

Speaking of old hippies and to misquote a song: Was, is, and should never be.

John, let me make this simple for you, speaking strictly for myself, but as an example.

I recently received my federal tax return. Half of went into savings, the other have was split between my wife and myself. What's left, around $450, is set aside for a new computer.

I just went to Dell's site. The low end E521 with the Sempron 3400 is more than adequate for my needs. I upgraded the hard drive to 250 GB and upgraded to a DVD burner. The price on that system, with modem, Windows Vista Basic and the recycling of an old machine, is $429.

I expect Dell to be able to offer me that same machine, with Ubuntu and the recycling option, for $399 or less. I understand that they may not be able to include a modem for that price, as non-Winmodems tend to cost more, but that's the only qualifier I'm willing to accept.

I just checked on MWave, and I can built the exact same type system as a bare bones kit from MWave for $306.15, so I'll be paying Dell almost $93 for preassembling the machine and preloading Linux for me. That seems slightly high, but it's acceptable, and should be more than adequate, especially as Dell should be able to get better prices than MWave.

If Dell can do this, then I expect to buy a Dell later this month. If they can't, I'll write off Dell and buy the bare bones kit from MWave.

That's the type of product I, and probably most of the others here, expect. Our price points and systems will vary depending on our needs, but we'll all expect to be able to build the same systems we would on the Windows side and get some type of discount for not buying Windows. I, and I expect most of the others here, don't think that's too much to ask of a vendor.

I'll be waiting to see if Dell can meet my needs.
>I expect Dell to be able to offer me that same machine, with Ubuntu and the recycling option, for $399 or less.

Why?

Why do you demand a Linux distribution that they will not support, or one that nobody else supports?

Why is it not acceptable to you for Dell to enter a contract with a Linux distributor? To train their own people and spend the money to assure that Linux and their boxes play together well? Etc.

Sounds to me like you should just buy the MWave. Every business has people they cannot serve.

> Why do you demand a Linux distribution that they will not support, or one that nobody else supports?

Dino, Ubuntu is the distro they've stated they'll be preloading. I didn't ask for Slackware.

> Why is it not acceptable to you for Dell to enter a contract with a Linux distributor? To train their own people and spend the money to assure that Linux and their boxes play together well? Etc.

Again, I don't see what this has to do with what I posted.

> Sounds to me like you should just buy the MWave.

I'd love to be proven wrong, but I expect that's what I'll wind up doing.
Dino,

It's all about choice. I don't need a Canonical support package from Dell so why should I pay for it? I am happy to see it added as an optional extra. I agree with jdixon- Dell should offer a cheap PC with a range of add ons for support.

What I object to is obfuscation i.e. pretending that the linux support is included in a price that is actually designed to protect M$'s commercial interest. Not saying that will happen but count me as wary about this possibility.
jdixon, richo123 -

I make no presumptions whatsoever as to what a Linux-loaded machine should cost.

I know that I can buy Windows Vista Home Edition OEM from Newegg for $90. I presume that Newegg makes money at that price, so I would be surprised to learn that Dell pays more than $50-$60.

That doesn't leave a whole lot of room for savings if Dell offers any kind of Linus support whatsoever.

Maybe $30 is an entirely reasonable discount, as jdixon suggests. That would mean getting the whole cost of providing Linux to $30. Seems doable, but who knows what the final offering would look like.

Seems disconcerting to me, however, that a Linux person would consider a Linux box less valuable than a Windows machine.

But that's another issue altogether.

Aren't we all glad that Dell is merely one alternative, and won't we be gladder if Dell makes pre-loaded Linux desktops --- that work -- as easy and as economical (maybe moreso) than equivalent Windows boxes.

Methinks a few posters on this forum are sounding a little whiny.



> I make no presumptions whatsoever as to what a Linux-loaded machine should cost.

Neither do I Dino. I told John what I was willing to pay for it. Whether they meet that or not is up to them.

> That doesn't leave a whole lot of room for savings if Dell offers any kind of Linus support whatsoever.

Did I mention support anywhere in my post?

> ...that a Linux person would consider a Linux box less valuable than a Windows machine.

Price does not equal value Dino. However, you'll notice that I'm not offering to buy the Windows machine, even at a lower price.

> Aren't we all glad that Dell is merely one alternative...

Yes.

> ...and won't we be gladder if Dell makes pre-loaded Linux desktops --- that work -- as easy and as economical (maybe moreso) than equivalent Windows boxes.

Yes again.

> Methinks a few posters on this forum are sounding a little whiny.

Perhaps, but the Dell representative seems to want feedback. I thought a concrete example of what a potential customer was looking for would be useful. Hopefully he'll find it so, but if not he's free to ignore it. The fact that I bothered should give you some idea of how important I consider this to be.
From the horses mouth:

"Dell plans to start offering Ubuntu as an option on selected consumer PCs in the coming weeks, said Jeremy Bolen, a Dell spokesman. Ubuntu is free, and machines pre-installed with it will be less expensive than PCs of the same configuration that come with Windows, Bolen said. He declined to say by how much. PC buyers also will be able to buy support from Canonical Ltd., which distributes Ubuntu."

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/business/314124_dellfolo03.htm...
Somebody somewhere commented that the true cost of a Windows PC goes beyond just the cost of a single license. Which is good thing to keep in mind. First, multiple versions of Windows, with the less-expensive ones being crippled in various ways. Then anti-virus/malware stuff. Then personal firewall. Then, even if you're savvy enough to find freeware versions, the time it takes to install and set them up, and to replace the three biggest malware vectors of all, IE, Outlook, and Outlook Express.

Then you still have no productivity software- MS Office is hundreds of dollars, and there are not many less-expensive alternatives.

And then the cleanup after the almost-inevitable infestations, and the continual battles with nag- and commercial-ware, and so on and on... I don't see how Dell can make these sorts of comparisons as long as they are so dependent on Windows! But we sure can!
TC -

A linux pc would be cheap at $100 MORE than a Windows pc. As you point out, Windows is pretty useless by itself.

I must admit, I'm a tad puzzled as to why more Windows boxes don't come with OpenOffice, the GIMP, Firefox, etc. Free software runs on Windows, too -- and the price is right.
I think the rub will be the support issue.

Having been a regular denizen of the Ubuntu forum for quite a while I can say that the number of clueless ex-Windows users is pretty frighteningly high.

Canonical are going to have to think through their support strategy very carefully I suspect and coordinate it well with the Dell website.

Large warnings about software on the Dell site will be needed ("WTF where is MS Word and Outlook?").

Some of the ex-Windows users can be VERY demanding so the Canonical support staff better have a good plan for baby stepping these baby starlings through their initial linux experience.
> Some of the ex-Windows users can be VERY demanding so the Canonical support staff better have a good plan for baby stepping these baby starlings through their initial linux experience.

I don't envy those support people. I really hope Canonical pays and treats them like gold. Even then, I wouldn't be at all interested... No way, no how.
dino, microsoft's two cash cows are Windows and Office. Everything else they sell is marginal or unprofitable. So you're not going to see any FOSS alternatives on preinstalls ever, methinks.
>So you're not going to see any FOSS alternatives on preinstalls ever, methinks.

Maybe not. So much the better for Linux.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post