Advanced

Accurate market share statistics and The $60 Billion dollar question

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 13 comments
LXer Linux News; By Scott Ruecker (Phoenix, U.S.)
Mail this story
Print this story


LXer Feature: 26-Apr-2008

Earlier this week an article concerning Vista and market share and one about how Open Source Software has cost the IT Industry $60 Billion dollars over the last five years or so hit the newswire. Needless to say this generated some conversations about their validity. I got to wondering if there have ever been accurate market share statistics for Linux or any operating system for that matter and to ask myself the $60 Billion dollar question.

Earlier this week an article concerning Vista and market share and one about how Open Source Software has cost the IT Industry $60 Billion dollars over the last five years or so hit the newswire. Needless to say this generated some conversations about their validity. I got to wondering if there have ever been accurate market share statistics for Linux or any operating system for that matter and to ask myself the $60 Billion dollar question.

This article draws heavily upon conversations here on LXer about the Should You Give Linux A Chance? and the Open Source Software Is Costing Vendors $60 Billion? articles.

First is this whole 98% market share that Windows has. In the last ten years I don't think that assertion has changed; its been right around 98% the whole time. Just where did this estimate come from? Like the chicken and the egg, we will probably never know. One of our readers wrote "The argument from marketshare has always struck me as a form of special pleading for Microsoft. As in the whole thing isn't testable. There's no way to reverse a given situation and see what results." I agree, just how and when did this 98% get there? And what about e-mail clients? You mean to tell me that Outlook/Outlook Express have a 98% market share? I don't even have to look anything up to know that is not true.

And what about dual-booting machines? I have an HP laptop that came with XP on it and I have since dual-booted it with SuSE, Red Hat (Fedora) along with running Knoppix and DSL live for weeks on end. As of recently, I have fallen in love with PCLinuxOS and have been using on it for almost six months now. I have my main desktop that has XP on it that has had too many different flavors of Linux to count that I have been dual booting Debian on for some time now, my friend jimf helped me with that. I have recently bought a Compaq desktop that has Vista Home Premium on it, for now. I have the two desktops hooked up via a KVM switch. So I actually have more Windows machines that Linux machines running right now. Does that make me? 60% Windows, 40% Linux? Does that mean I am tainted? That just sounds bad doesn't it?

So is any computer that has ever had any Windows installed on it counted in that market share? And what about Apple? One study says that they had 14% of retail sales in Feb 2008, and another says that they have a 6.6% market share for the first quarter of the year in another study. So which is one is true? What about Linux, all the different flavors of Unix and the Apache web server? Are their usage statistics to be believed or are they all sharing pieces of that left over 2%? Apache alone has roughly a 70% share of the web server market and I am not even going to waste time looking for statistics on Unix and Linux to help refute the 98% statistic.

Now on to this lost $60 Billion dollars. According to Jim Johnson, CEO of the Standish Group International "Open Source software is raising havoc throughout the software market. It is the ultimate in disruptive technology, and while to it is only 6% of estimated trillion dollars IT budgeted annually, it represents a real loss of $60 billion in annual revenues to software companies" The ultimate disruptive technology? Just how was this opinion reached? What factors went into it being described as "disruptive technology" and how did it cost the IT industry $60 Billion dollars? Where did the money go and to whom? That is more than one question isn't it, sorry about that.

One of our Editors, Carla Schroder mentioned that the headline could just as easily be "Consumers and businesses save $60 billion, and have money to spend on useful things, instead of predatory overpriced software licenses" and a reader wrote it could be titled "Innovative corporations have saved over $60B by switching to Open Source". Because if we're going to spin it, we might as well spin it our way right? Who's to say that the huge markup in sales price by Microsoft hasn't resulted in many of Microsoft's customers having to get by posting smaller than usual profits. Wouldn't that cost the IT industry money? A ton of money is my bet.

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial, LXer Features; Groups: Community, GNU, Linux, Microsoft

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (13)

Innovation driver

It might be interesting if anyone did a study to see if the supposed $60 billion was on the simple software. Which means companies can't make money doing the simple software (unless it is truly excellent!). If they can't flog simple stuff for lots they have to come up with "value added" software or just genuinely innovative products.

So if it were a real $60 billion it either avoided going to places it wasn't needed (hence a saving), went to companies doing the brilliant new things or horrors it conceivably didn't get spent and instead software was used that was not up to the job and that money wasn't saved because the poor alternatives results in a loss.

But regardless the $60 billion not paid doesn't seem itself to be harmful?
I don't have $1000 to dump for the study itself, but I did take the time to read a number of articles and press releases from the Standish Group. There isn't much in the way of real information, just rehashes of the sensationalistic headlines about "$60 billion flushed down the open source toilet!!" You'd think at least one Real News Organization would pony up for the report.

And one did, but shares precious little from it. This article http://www.cnet.com/8301-13846_1-9921292-62.html excerpts a snippet from the report, and the snippet sounds rather sensible, and seems to support what purplewizard said. So it could be a good report. We can't tell from the available information, which is more hyping the Standish Group than the report anyway. Everyone is all agog over the $60 billion figure and uninterested in digging deeper.

I haven't seen anyone say how businesses benefit from lower costs, too. Really, it's such an obvious no-brainer, and a fundamental premise of capitalism- competition leads to better and cheaper. Microsoft and their ilk have done a fine brainwashing job in pushing the opposite- competition is bad, and if you want cheaper you'll get a chair thrown at you.
Can you imagine the state of things if there was no OS X, no Linux, no Firefox, no OpenOffice, no Thunderbird or Evolution, GNOME or KDE? Microsoft would be a little lamb, right?
Sure they would! And MS Office would directly read your thoughts and create your documents for you....
Quoting:And MS Office would directly read your thoughts and create your documents for you....
They already tried that with Clippy.
techiem, it's a good thing it doesn't, because the content would be 100% cuss words from having to use MS Office.
No, TC, it would read your mind and censor anything negative about Office...you'd never get to type anything but wonderful things about Redmond. You'd be out of a job!! :)
LOL. And it would automatically add a "Produced with perfect MS Office" line to the bottom of every document...that's non-removable.
Quoting:it would read your mind and censor anything negative about Office...you'd never get to type anything but wonderful things about Redmond.


Typed: This >@#^ Office product is a piece of $#!#!

Result: This exclaimed Office product is the nutrient which makes things grow.
LOL!!!

@NoDough: I love it!!

yes a ton of money

1 ton of 10000 dollar bills = $9,080,000,000.00
in pennies or paper, I still have a long way to go for my first Ton.
According to my calculations an imperial ton of pennies comprises about $3,600.00 US. Less if you use pre-1982 pennies.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post