Advanced

Apple Wants To Stop You Fixing Your iPhone And iPad: Source Says It Will Testify Against 'Right To Repair' Legislation

Posted by BernardSwiss on · 7 comments
Techdirt; By Glyn Moody
Mail this story
Print this story

Even though the idea seems a no-brainer -- you bought it, why shouldn't you be able to repair it? -- progress has been extremely slow, as successive Techdirt articles have chronicled. One of the most important developments is a number of "Right to Repair" bills that are being considered by various state legislatures. These typically require electronics manufacturers to make service manuals available to the public, and to sell repair parts. The hope is that if even one or two of these are passed, manufacturers will find it simpler to comply nationally. However, an article on Motherboard suggests that the "Right to Repair" movement has a rather surprising enemy.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial, News Story; Groups: Community, Intellectual Property, Standards

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (7)

The right to repair is a fundamental right of freedom. Without it, anyone and everyone becomes a criminal.

Unfortunately, the US Constitution does not directly list the "Right to Repair." It is sometimes listed in very fine print under the 1st Amendment.
I personally never "buy" anything I don't fully own. But most sheeple will...
As I understand this issue, Apple will most likely argue that user repairs could damage lithium ion batteries and cause them to explode.

Well, according to what I read in the news 99% of the exploding lion batteries were caused by OEM design flaws. Maybe what we should be pushing for is a demand for open hardware so that we can peer review OEM designs for safety.

Taking steps to further hide OEM design errors works against public safety. I don't think that closed hardware (hardware that fails to permit peer safety review) should be permitted in airline carry-on or checked luggage since we have no way to independently verify that the closed hardware does not contain a potentially exploding battery.

I hope someone presents this counterargument when Apple gets up to make their proposal.
"Well, according to what I read in the news 99% of the exploding lion batteries were caused by OEM design flaws. Maybe what we should be pushing for is a demand for open hardware so that we can peer review OEM designs for safety."

Change that to software and we have MS. We all know how much they want peer review.

From what I've read the problem with the batteries is that they are glued to the case (there are better ways to secure them but then they become replaceable) and there is no good way to remove them without damaging the battery making them non-replaceable.
@GDStewart:

I never tried to remove an iThing battery... but there seems to be a rather long and tedious process:

http://www.wikihow.com/Remove-the-Battery-from-an-iPhone

I have removed a battery from a Mac Book Pro. It's a pain in the butt... and takes way too long if you are trying to limit electrical shorting damage from a liquid spilled into the machine.

Personally, I don't buy expensive electronic things that have no quick and easy way to remove all sources of power.
> Proof that Apple is not your friend

Corporations are a government creation. From the government's perspective, they exist to pay taxes, provide jobs for the populace, and provide goods the government needs. From their own perspective, they exist to make money for their shareholders (I've heard of a few that consider their employees on an equal or near equal footing with their shareholders, but never actually encountered one).

Why would such an entity be considered anyone's "friend".

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post