Advanced

Christian endorsement of Free Software increases

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 49 comments
NewsForge; By Marco Fioretti
Mail this story
Print this story

Last November I described the Free Software's Surprising Affinity with Catholic Doctrine. Since then, several important things happened, from feedback by Stallman and other Free SW users to the birth, or acceleration, of some projects specifically based on the concept that Christians have even more reasons than others to adopt Free Software.

Full Story

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (49)

problems with this

22 earlier comments in the full thread.

Quoting:Elvis in an Oldsmobile


¿Qué?
lol... Elvis always drove caddys... to say otherwise is sacrilege :D .
Ahh, OK.

My mind is an Elvis-free zone.
caddys and race cars.

and toilets too, 'cause I remember what he was driving when he died. ;-)
To all: Articles and discussion of technology in the context of a religious organization is perfectly acceptable - regardless of the particular faith involved. Turning such discussions into religious debates is not. There is no need to create special forums, etc. Just choose what you read and post wisely. If you're not mature enough to do that, you should consider another forum.

Jimf: Thanks for pointing out what drew your comments. That certainly helps my understanding, and makes your post seem less like an ad hominem attack. You should understand that any religious (or even political, etc.) group is likely to feel that way - mostly because they have a belief system with which to identify, rather than because they want to "hi-jack" the GPL. ;-) I respect their freedom to believe that way. In fact, I would be very afraid of someone who didn't feel their belief system was "the best" or whatever. Just respect mine, and I'll respect yours.

My message throughout has been (essentially) live and let live. When Marco (or your favorite target of the day) comes over here with his sword to offer faith or death, I'll stand beside you because I know no one has a right to force his views on you. Not that he would, but just in case. :-) Until then we must be tolerant of each other.

LXer is not changing policy on the posting of articles or comments.
tuxtom,

Actually, you're right on that comparison. Never thought of it that way...but it does have a ton of similarities.

Tuxchick,

I'm actually concerned for FOSS and don't care about myself, nor my readings here at Lxer. I can skip the articles I don't like and often do.

Nerves get smacked with religion tough, especially Christianity. Hence, my comments. If I upset anyone, I apologize.

I'll leave you with my last thoughts on this subject...

1. It has been blown out of proportion. However, it has hit the nervers of readers. Consider this when posting and writing in the future about FOSS.

2. It is my opinion that rsheim is right. Why? Because he is the "customer" and he perceives there is a problem. Since this is his perception and it is real...then it needs to be addressed...I don't think everyone is a fraud, just that the rules he is quoting are valid and if he feels they were overstepped, a closer look needs to be taken at what those rules mean.

If I operated my business with a "just ignore what you don't like" mentality, I'd be out of business. rsheim, if no one else here apologizes for this. I apologize for them. You pulled the rules in plain English and tried to preserve them. Ignoring them would be hypocrisy.

3. Posting on this subject will always attract the same debate...if not from those currently discussing this, it will from others.

4. You can put the penguin in the pew...just don't put the pew in the penguin.

Quoting:Posting on this subject will always attract the same debate...if not from those currently discussing this, it will from others.


This is definitely accurate. While this doesn't mean that - in this case - religion shouldn't be brought up, it does mean you can't reasonably expect some people to not get upset. If you want to stir the excrement, don't complain about the stench.
I publicly offered rsheim a means by which to bring his complaint to me, or to another LXer editor, if he was not comfortable discussing his complaint with me. I know another editor has approached him with an opportunity to discuss the issue further. To my knowledge, he has not responded to either invitation. It is still open.

In reality, debate on these issues is very important. Jimf's original post makes much more sense in light of his more recent post. It is much easier to respond to that than to his original post. The fact is that some religious groups do and will find affinities between FOSS and their beliefs. As long as they respect the freedom/rights of others, that's fine, and should be celebrated. If they attempted to withhold FOSS from the rest of the world, or even attempted to impose it on everyone, that would be problematic.

While I am at it, I should have taken the opportunity to ask Jimf why he felt the way he did, rather than assume he was making an ad hominem attack. Especially so, since I knew he understands the difference between proselytizing and articles about technology in the context of a religious organization. I will try not to make myself look so foolish in the future. Jimf, I hope you'll find it within yourself to forgive me.
I thought you handled it just fine, dcparris. There will always be rsheim's.
Devnet, much of the time you're right on. In this instance you're not. As you say

"I'm actually concerned for FOSS and don't care about myself..."

Remember what the F stands for? (any answer that starts with "yes but" is disqualified) " 2... the rules he is quoting are valid and if he feels they were overstepped, a closer look needs to be taken at what those rules mean."

I agree that the TOS is not consistent with what is published on LXer. "3. Posting on this subject will always attract the same debate...if not from those currently discussing this, it will from others."

It's a sad day when religious intolerance enters the FOSS world. Not that it's perfect, but this knee-jerk aversion to the mention of religion, and saying that talking about it is the same as forcing it on people, is all goofy. The GPL and the FSF are fundamentally about values and morals, so any discussion of values and morals is completely in keeping with talking about Free Software.
Nothing to forgive Don :) I should have clarified earlier.
SFN: I appreciate your encouragement. I'm sure I'll have more such opportunities in the future. ;-)
Jimf: Thanks for understanding and for helping me to understand you better as well.
GO GO GO GO TUXCHICK !!!!!

SIS BOOM BAH AND RAH RAH RAH!!!

Five stars and a brownie point besides.

Long lost Carla, I know that you and I don't see eye to eye on every bye and bye, but on this the five is high:

Real freedom and tolerance is not restricted to the freedom to shut up so that you or I will be unoffended. That, in fact, is the epitome of intolerance.

Understanding is not advanced by the unspoken thought. Unexpected alliances and areas and interests are not discovered by turning away.

You give as good as you get, girl. That, I think is the point. Giving AND getting.
hey dino, nice to see you. Sometimes life bites, sometimes I try biting it back.:) I think I'm gaining ground.

'Understanding is not advanced by the unspoken thought.' Indeed. As long as folks are talking, we can figure it out.
Tuxchick --

Nice to see you back around, too.

Sorry for the silence after the am posts...but daughter's birthday gift (on hold since her real birthday on Valentine's day) was a daddy-daughter date day.

We went into Chicago on the train, saw Millenium Park (including the amazing bean), went to Wicked (Ouch!!! $35 t shirts -- but how do you look into a ten year old face that is just brimming with daddy love and say no? -- walking around town and having a good time.

For that, I can leave posting behind for a day.
Quoting:Is this a joke? What the heck is wrong with you people, and I mean devnet and rsheim, LXer's shiny new troll?


I looked this word up in the Internet jargon. A troll is a user of a newsgroup, forum or message board that posts messages with the intent of inciting an argument or flame-war.

I looked the meanings up also.

It seems that I should not visit this site further. I can only see that you do not want new readers or people who express their opinion as in discussions sense.

You can say that your terms of service should change. That's seems convenient. In the interim time, you represent a product/service and one could say that it does not meet the new user's expectation. So, you maybe should change it to fit the actual situation one will find.

With regard to the quote, you seem intending to hurt someones feelings and so obviously, you do not want new readers. You should indicate that in your registration program. "We do not want readers, beware because you will achieve insults. Also, you will not receive service we state."

I have found it enlightenment. German Linux sites lack much good content. Other sites advertise for Microsoft, not very popular in Europe at the moment. So, I had hoped this would provide a cure. "You people " is a derogatory term in many other cultures and demeaning.

My job for your information involves deploying Debian clusters in Germany for governments. I travel in the AME. I cannot recommend this site for others.
rsheim: I offered to work with you to resolve your complaint(s). Since you have rejected my offer, it seems there is little recourse beyond your decision to leave. I wish you all the best, whatever you decide in the end.

As for the charge that you might be a troll, consider this:

>If this dcparris has taken over the site and he is a baptist minister, I guess he will preach to us. Should we go to the alter and on one knee say we accept your version of Jesus? What makes you right and everyone else not right?

I had made no effort in this thread to "preach" up to this point. Nor had I said anything generally, or directly to you that should have led you to accuse me of such a thing. Your remark was both inflamatory (trollish) and unfair. Even so, I made an effort to help you resolve what you saw as rudeness toward you. What more must I do?

The fact is that all of us are human and apt to "miss the mark". Hence, I was man enough to ask jimf's forgiveness when I realized I had assumed something about him I shouldn't have. It seems you and I share that much in common. Perhaps you could simply admit that you're not so perfect either, and join the crowd.

You are welcome to stay here at LXer. You are also free to leave. It's up to you.

Marco Fioretti Responds to Critics

In all fairness to Marco, he deserves a chance to respond to criticism of his article. I have given him permission to do so. I hope those who choose to respond will keep things respectable. :-)
Thanks to Don. While he was posting this request, I was posting my answer in another thread. Please let's send any answer directly to that other thread, to make the discussion easier to follow.

Best Regards,

Marco Fioretti

From the author of FOSS & Christians: Some context and a request

Greetings,

first of all, sincere thanks to all LXer readers for their interest in my articles and all the related feedback.

With respect to most of the critiques on LXer, NewsForge and other forums, I have this comment: sincerely, I must say that most of them only seem justified if their authors did NOT read both my articles first, from beginning to end (or, as far as Catholics are concerned, the Eleutheros Manifesto and FAQ).

By this I do NOT mean that such critics are surely wrong: only that they refer to positions and proposals which I (or D. C. Parris, for example) have NOT taken or suggested.

I think that both my articles can be completely summed up with two sentences:

* According to their own official teaching, Christians have even more reasons than others to use Free SW THEMSELVES, and some of them are starting to realize it and act accordingly. IN THEIR OWN HOME. Without ever imagining that all FOSS users should become Christian, or that Christians "own" the FOSS philosophy, or that it can only "be" Christian.

* To prove this point, here are some references which, by the way, don't exactly look like some extremely narrow-minded, medieval, bigot, unprovable superstition.

If you find in these two points, or in my articles, anything which implies that all Christians are better than all others, than all FOSS users should become Christians (or are intrinsically so), than FOSS is more Christian than Buddist or Islamic or everything else, or simply that this is another reason why any religion is broken, please provide evidence. If not, let's respect each other and remember the closing questions of my article.

Best Regards, Marco Fioretti
Quite simply, you brought to the Apostolate a secular issue which does no seem to belong. You also compare every religion as if they all have equal footing amongst each other which is not so. That is all I have to ever say on this site.
"Quite simply, you brought to the Apostolate a secular issue which does no seem to belong":

I think I fully answered such perplexities with the last question of my second article. Imagine you, or any organization which, like a denominational school or an ecologist club, has some specific set of ethical values in its "mission statement", buying any kind of equipment. How could it ever happen without taking those values into account? When it doesn't, as it often is, it is because of lack of information, time or alternatives, but it doesn't make the method less valid.

If one doesn't practice his or her ethical values, WHATEVER they are, in the secular sphere, what are those values for?

"You also compare every religion as if they all have equal footing amongst each other which is not so":

with respect to THIS specific issue (if and why all religions have specific, "native" reasons to prefer FOSS, or at least if their followers should check if they have such reasons) it certainly is. As far as I am concerned, at least. I'm not certainly going to write a table to find which religion scores "better" from a FOSS point of view (assuming such a quest could ever make any sense or serve any meaningful purpose)

Best Regards,

Marco Fioretti
Then your religion is FOSS.
No, that is Stallman.

Software is just a tool. An essential one in the modern world, one which must be evaluated and used properly, accordingly to one's values (whatever they are). For me, software and software licenses, in and by themselves, are nothing to get really fanatic about.

Said this, I really don't understand what your last answer has to do at all with what we should be discussing. The more I read it, the less it makes sense to me, or seem to be on topic at any level.

Please let's stick to meaningful comments and critics, thanks

Best Regards, Marco Fioretti

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post