Novell & Microsoft: What do you Think?
|
|
|
Comments (54)
Untitled
Just to scarry
33 earlier comments in the full thread.
Chicken little was correct in the movie if you recall :D While we don't live in the movies, I'd like to think that this 'deal' is one that's made for them...it seems surreal.
1. The bottom line is, Novell is going to make money off of selling licenses with Microsoft that make sure you are running "Microsoft Certified Linux" to avoid infringement.
At the very least, Novell is guilty of spreading FUD about Linux because this license will be used as leverage and is being used as leverage (and to spread FUD already: see TC's post of the link above)...which goes against everything they sought to build with OpenSuSe. That's enough for many people to "knee-jerk react" away from it. And I don't blame them.
So long as they don't go yammering on about the importance of the GPL. It's clear that they don't believe in it.
Dino and I both go back a bit farther than the movie. :(
License violations tend to be a bit easier to prove than anti-trust violations. And remember that Microsoft was found guilty of anti-trust violations. More importantly, the penalties would not be within the hands of the DOJ, but rather with the people suing them and the judge.
Quoting:If you're going to play Chicken Little, at least take the time to think of how something can happen.
I'm not playing anything. I'm only providing an example why someone could decide to move away from Suse now, other than the "OMG Novell is teh evil!" kneejerk reaction you pointed to.
Devnet and sander nailed it - yes, the GPL is strong, and so is the FUD. I understand why a supposed Linux vendor that is a party to this patent and "eye pee" propaganda would find its customers that are FOSS supporters walking away. The notion of partnering with microsoft is bad enough, especially when they bleat about "interoperability." That part is easy- duh, the code and the standards are open- where's the need to form official partnerships? Sheesh. We all know it's more about trying to dam the river than joining the beach party. Lotsa luck, for the GPL is mighty, but anyone who thinks they're not trying to pull a fast one stand up so we can reboot your brain.
Quoting:Dino and I both go back a bit farther than the movie. :(
Which one of you is runt of the litter? lol
It might be a cheap shot...I believe anyone truly involved in the FOSS/Linux community can see that RH is going to come out on the short end of the stick here. Bullets discharged from a Raven 25 Cal (about 49.95 in any pawn shop) can be just as deadly as one fired from my Glock if aimed correctly, so cheap shot as it may be, RH is in dire need of circling the wagons and posting lookouts thru the night.
Look, I'm just a dumb ol' Linux Advocate who imposters his way through the day as a "Desktop Technology Manager". Even I can see the clear path of these still-unfolding events. Microsoft has found a way to worm their way into our world and begin stockpiling money in doing so. To our advantage, we clearly know who opened the door for them and WE have the ability to shut it and keep it shut. If I have any sympathy here, it is for those who poured their very sub-atomic being into OpenSuse.
Tuxchick sees it with crystal vision. The Mighty Hand of Microsoft can now guide a strong enterprise Linux in any direction it cares to, and bully the others by insinuation and inuendo concerning I Pee litigation...Novell has just relinquished the drivers seat and can only stick around for the ride or ask to be let out on some dark street corner.
I can't help but feel that any participation Microsoft has in Linux Business will taint it for everyone. The very thought of it leaves me with a sense of dread.
How do you figure? Novell has just received an agreement from Microsoft to leave them the hell alone.
And -- oh, by the way -- Microsoft has received and agreement from Novell to leave them the hell alone.
Novell is a lot more than Linux and these two companies have been suing each other for quite some time. In the recent past, Microsoft has shelled out more than half a bil to settle an antitrust suit by Novell.
This stuff reminds of all the wailing and gnashing of teeth when Apple entered its deal with Microsoft.
Last I looked, Apple was still in business, making gobs of money, and Microsoft was trying to figure out how it would compete with the iPod.
By making something too expensive, overly-complex, and too restricted. Oh wait....
http://www.medialoper.com/hot-topics/music/zunes-big-innovat... "If Microsoft’s claims are to be believed, this on-the-fly DRM will be seamless and automatic - which must be some kind of first for Microsoft."
http://www.medialoper.com/hot-topics/microsoft/microsoft-ins... "I clarified that the 3 day or 3 play limitation will still be in effect for ALL shared music. After your trial listen expires your Zune will simply stop playing the song. The file and associated meta-data will remain on your device - it just won’t be usable."
It will probably be a success anyway.
**edit** http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/technology/6120272.stm "People who have bought music from Microsoft's MSN Music store could face problems if they decide to buy the firm's new Zune portable player. ... But in a move that could alienate some customers, MSN-bought tracks will not be compatible with the new gadget."
Maybe it'll be an x-box success...
Sell a lot of units, but not make the company any money to speak of.
Let 'em waster their time on that stuff!!!
And what kind of a moron would name ANYTHING not the child of Frank Zappa Zune?
Quoting:I believe anyone truly involved in the FOSS/Linux community can see that RH is going to come out on the short end of the stick here.
I'm not too sure of that. I think Red Hat is holding up pretty well under the barrage, and are even milking it themselves for all it's worth. Their "UNTHINKABLE" (http://www.redhat.com/promo/believe/) and "unfakable linux" (http://www.redhat.com/promo/unfakeable/) are pretty good.
Red Hat may loose business from less cluefull PHB's but will definately gain in companies that truly value FOSS for the freedoms. They're facing some tough challenges but less tough then their recent 25% drop in stock prices would indicate. On the plus, if you were ever planning to buy Red Hat stock, now is a good time to do so :-)
Quoting:Well, they'd only be infringing after the 5 years if they didn't renew the agreement.
As I understood from the explanation in the other thread, they'd be infringing all the time. They just wouldn't get sued for it.
If that's true, then MS will try to take down as many "unapproved" distro's as it can in the next 5 years, then go after their former parnters when their agreements run out. Maybe there agreements are just a way for MS to ensure then when the patent lawsuits start, they won't get countersued by all distro's at the same time (then again, IBM alone should prove scary enough)
No, they'd only be infringing if they were infringing.
An agreement not to sue does not mean you are infringing or being infringed upon. It means you are not suing or being sued.
Further, if, for example, Microsoft actually licenses some technology to Novell, the 5 year moratorium won't matter because a license is an affirmative (and, generally, a dispositive) defense against infringement.
http://www.groklaw.net/article.php?story=20061107194320461
But it is still scarry as long as one side is Microsoft
Any agreement with Microsoft in it is a scary thing to behold. OTOH, Microsoft is a scary thing to behold whether you have an agreement with them or not.
The reactions I've seen to this agreement remind me just a little bit of the 1980s, when Ronald Reagan and Mikhail Gorbachev reached an agreement to begin dismantling nuclear weapons.
That was a matter of life or death for each side. No matter how much eveybody wanted the nuclear threat to evaporate, it wasn't the sort of thing either side could do strictly on the basis of trust. An old Russian credo came to the rescue: "Trust, but verify." In other words, a certain level of trust is required to reach any agreement, but the fact of satellites and on-ground observers made trust a little easier to come by.
Novell-Microsoft is not about the total destruction of the planet, but a binding legal instrument helps to add some "verifiability" to that trust.
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post

I think Novell has been duped into a Microsoft strategy of 1) creating FUD about possible patent claims (customers are almost never sued in patent claims), 2) playing into a Microsoft "save our Office document format monopoly" strategy, 3) establishing a precedent of paying a Microsoft tax for using the work of free people - freely given to the community.
I think you're going to look silly when your attempts to insert Microsoft viral patented IP into OOo come up against sect. 11 of the LGPL.
B.T.W. In France after the war they shaved the heads of collaborators.