The Two Faces of Microsoft: Pervasive Brand Recognition
As Microsoft prepares to launch their next publicity campaign, in an effort to "shrink" their image as a big company, one has to wonder if Microsoft's upper management really grasp the challenges they face with respect to their corporate reputation. In other words, Microsoft's effort to present themselves as "not big" seems to be based on the idea that people don't trust "big". The fact is that "big" isn't the problem - Microsoft's reputation is. In this, the first of four articles examining Microsoft's reputation, we'll examine the pervasive nature of the Microsoft Brand, and how keeping the brand separate from the corporate reputation helps Microsoft maintain its popularity in spite of their largely negative behavior. Pervasive ReputationLet's face it, Microsoft is more than merely pervasive; the corporate name is a household name. I have often asked the less technically-inclined computer users what software they use. The only thing some can tell me is "it's Microsoft". Whatever it is, it's Microsoft. It could actually be Intuit's Quickbooks, but the only thing some people know is that they use Microsoft. One person with an obvious new-found enthusiasm for computing literally thought that Microsoft was the only player in the computer marketplace. Such naivety is commonplace, and spans the range of educational levels from people with a high school diploma to those with masters' degrees. Much of an individual user's knowledge stems mostly from their exposure to various computers. Those with the least exposure to multiple computer systems have the least amount of knowledge on which to base decisions. It works the same with most other things as well. For example, when I bought a 1988 Subaru Justy, I had to get the salesman to prove the car had a 3-cylinder engine. My limited exposure to engines had me thinking that the engine had to have an even number of cylinders. People with limited exposure to the computing field often assume that Microsoft is "it", the only option they have. When the typical computer user learns that there is something other than Microsoft available, they often are not sure what to think. They typically choose Microsoft anyway because that's what others use, or because their friend can help them solve problems. They may assume that Microsoft is giving them the latest and greatest software, even though the actual quality is pretty dubious. These people buy into the claim that "Microsoft was built on innovation, and our future depends on it". They simply do not know that Microsoft has purchased most of the technology it offers. We all know people highly skilled in the fine art of word processing, or who can manipulate a spreadsheet like a doe-eyed daughter wraps her daddy around her little finger. And there is where their knowledge of computing ends. They know little about the computing world beyond the office suite or the database they interact with. They don't know a client from a server from a workstation. All they know is that the computer they use typically has Microsoft software installed on it. We can safely assume that these are the target audience of Microsoft's planned publicity campaign. Those with greater exposure to the computing world are already keenly aware of Microsoft's marketing prowess. The mistrust of the exposed, but unassimilated, computer users is not due to Microsoft's size. Big is fine, as long as it remains functional, responsive, fair and honest. The real problem Microsoft faces is their maligned reputation. Brand Name vs. Corporate ReputationHerein lies the problem. Microsoft is trying to fix their brand name - not their corporate reputation. What's the difference? People often recognize the brand name, even if they are not always aware of the company's actual reputation in the business world. For instance, most people recognize the name Wal-Mart. Many people are not aware, however, of Wal-Mart's more controversial behavior. If you are one of the folks with a limited exposure to the computing world, you will be familiar with the Microsoft brand name, but not as familiar with their reputation as a corporate citizen. Thus, consumers with less exposure to the computing world will likely buy into the Microsoft marketing campaign. When consumers discover the disreputable behavior of other companies, they typically start shopping elsewhere. In this way, the consumers influence the big corporations to mind their manners. So too, when consumers discover the distance between Microsoft's brand and Microsoft's corporate reputation, they will almost surely react. Until recently, there have been few ways of letting Microsoft know that you don't want to do business with someone of their reputation. Consumers now have the ability to reject Microsoft's behavior out of hand by choosing from a range of other viable options in the operating system and productivity software marketplace. Consumers could take any number of actions. Aside from one suggestion of selling off Microsoft shares, consumers can actually go so far as to change the software they use. This could be as simple as choosing other office suites, such as OpenOffice.org, which is freely available over the Internet and highly compatible with Microsoft Office. Consumers could also acquire and install any of the user-friendly GNU/Linux systems without hurting their wallets too badly. Some systems, such as Ubuntu Linux are free (gratis and libre). Others, such as Xandros Desktop or Simply Mepis, cost less than $70.00. By selling shares, Microsoft sees a brief drop in their stock price. By changing software, Microsoft knows they have lost customers. Losing customers is a far more effective way to teach a big corporation to mind its manners. In the next article, we'll examine Microsoft's reputation as the "Evil Empire". We will examine their well-known anti-competitive practices, as exemplified through legal battles in the United States and abroad. We will also point out their penchant for crying about copyright and patent infringement, all while infringing on the copyrights and patents of others. We will link to factual references around the Internet for the sake of the dubious. Subsequent articles will delve into the behavior of their officers and employees, and their reputation as a software development company. |
Comments (12)
Very insightful. I digg it.
I see your point.
Lastly, the comment about the boycotting of the shares, I don't think you meant to support that but I think that is horrible. Ken Hutcherson is a hompohobic, Krazy Khristian and I totally support Microsoft in its support of the civil rights bill. Sell the shares because the stock performs poorly, not for ideology!
If you disagree with someone's viewpoint, fine. However, labeling people is not such a good idea. It might be construed as a personal attack. We don't allow that on the forums here.
Professional Gates watchers, and there are quite a few of us, can cite whole eras in his development as a business leader. At the heart of it all is a sense of competition fostered by his grandmother, and played-out in board games and family athletic contests. The single most driving force in the development of Bill Gates today or any day is his competitive nature. The guy simply has to win, and will do pretty much whatever it takes to succeed. Over the years, this need to win at any cost has changed its appearance a bit as times have changed, but it is still there. Bill plays to win. A graceless win is still a win. And if he can't win, then he'd rather not play.
When you are the richest man in the world, nobody can beat you at giving money away. Gates is competitive even at philanthropy. And if, in the process, you discover in yourself a real streak of humanitarianism, well that's a bonus.
I would only add...
Reputation can be from historical behavior that is no longer practiced. I don't like businesses that have done evil, however if they change their ways I may be inclined to forgive them. (IBM, for instance, is a much better citizen today than 30 years ago. Or so it seems.)
To those aware of the actions of a company doing wrong, what is worse than a bad reputation is the ongoing behavior that earned it in the first place. I especially strive to avoid doing business with companies that fully realize the evil they are doing yet willing choose to continue doing it. Rather than changing their behavior, they try to change the public's perception of their behavior. Underhanded, unfair, misleading, or subversive behaviors are no way to combat a well-earned bad reputation.
The IBM of 30 years ago couldn't exist today. They had no competition and what little competition they did have was easy to blow away.
Microsoft plays in an environment where one fifth of the people on this planet have computers. I dare say all the businesses have them.
So, the fact that they elevate in such an efficient market has to make you wonder. I wonder because I don't care for their products. I just don't see how Windows et al command as large a portion of the market based on technological evaluation. I could see a couple of points above everyone else for being great at marketing but not with their product mix.
Agreed, and all it would take would be a change in management. That's still at least a few years away, but it is possible.
Minor Correction
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post
|
|
LXer Feature: 02-Feb-06
One legislator said, he wishes they would stop proxies from dirty work and people would understand what is Microsoft.