Advanced

Microsoft and Linspire Collaboration Promotes Interoperability and Customer Choice

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 89 comments
PR Newswire
Mail this story
Print this story

Today Microsoft Corp. and Linux desktop provider Linspire Inc. announced a broad interoperability, technical collaboration that also includes intellectual property assurances. The agreement promotes customer choice and strengthens the bridge between the Microsoft Windows and Linux operating systems.

[One more down.. - Scott]

REDMOND, Wash., and SAN DIEGO, June 14 /PRNewswire-FirstCall/ -- Today Microsoft Corp. (Nasdaq: MSFT) and Linux desktop provider Linspire Inc. announced a broad interoperability, technical collaboration that also includes intellectual property assurances. The agreement promotes customer choice and strengthens the bridge between the Microsoft(R) Windows(R) and Linux operating systems.

(Logo: http://www.newscom.com/cgi-bin/prnh/20000822/MSFTLOGO)

Through this agreement, the companies will work to advance office document compatibility, enhance instant messaging interoperability and reinforce existing collaboration on digital media. In addition, Linspire will be providing its customers with the option of acquiring a patent covenant from Microsoft for customers operating the Linspire desktop.

"Linspire has always been about choice, and this announcement continues our tradition of offering options for improved interoperability, enhanced functionality and confidence," said Kevin Carmony, chief executive officer at Linspire. "Over the years, in an effort to expand choice, we have entered into dozens of agreements with commercial software vendors. It certainly made sense to collaborate with Microsoft, one of the most important partners in the PC ecosystem."

"Delivering interoperable solutions for our customers is an important priority," said Bill Hilf, general manager of Platform Strategy at Microsoft. "Through our ongoing collaborative relationships with commercial open source companies, we are demonstrating our commitment to delivering the value and increased interoperability customers want. Covering features from document formats to instant messaging and digital media, our announcement today with Linspire is an important step for our mutual customers."

Enhanced Functionality and Interoperability

Microsoft and Linspire will work together on a variety of technical projects designed to enhance interoperability and expand the functionality of Linspire. These include efforts focused on the following:

-- Document format compatibility. Linspire will join with Novell Inc.,

Microsoft and other companies to develop and distribute open

source-licensed translators that allow OpenOffice and Microsoft Office

users to better share documents. These efforts will enhance customer

choice by enabling effective translation between Ecma Open XML and

OpenDocument Format documents. -- Instant messaging. Linspire will license Microsoft's RT Audio Codec to

promote voice-enabled interoperability between Linspire's Pidgin

instant messaging client and Microsoft's instant messaging clients for

business, Microsoft Office Communicator, and, for consumers, Windows

Live(TM) Messenger. -- Digital media. Future releases of Linspire will now support the latest

Windows Media 10 audio and video codecs, allowing Linspire and

Microsoft Windows users to better share digital media files. -- TrueType fonts. Linspire will license popular Microsoft TrueType

fonts, including Arial, Georgia(R), Times New Roman and Verdana(R), so

Linspire users have improved experiences creating, editing and viewing

files and documents. -- Linspire customers only receive these three technologies (instant

messaging, digital media and TrueType fonts) if they purchase a

patent SKU. The technologies are not shipped with all Linspire 5.0

distributions. -- Web search. Linspire will select the Live Search service of Windows

Live as the Linspire 5.0 default Web search engine, allowing Microsoft

to bring Live Search to a broader set of users and providing leading

search capabilities to Linspire customers.

Intellectual Property Assurance

Through the agreement, Microsoft and Linspire have developed a framework to provide patent covenants for Linspire customers. The patent covenants provide customers with confidence that the Linspire technologies they use come with rights to relevant Microsoft patents. As well, Linspire now joins a growing group of open source software (OSS) distributors collaborating with Microsoft on efforts to establish rich interoperability, deliver IP assurance to customers and build the bridge between open source and proprietary software.

For Microsoft, the agreement is the latest in a series of collaborations with Linux platform and OSS providers. This list of collaborators includes JBoss, LG Electronics, Novell, Samsung Electronics Co. Ltd., Xandros Inc., XenSource Inc. and Zend Technologies Inc.

About Linspire

Linspire, Inc. (http://www.linspire.com) was founded in 2001 to bring choice into the operating system market. The company's flagship product, the Linspire operating system, is an affordable, easy-to-use Linux-based operating system distributed primarily pre-installed on PCs for use in homes, schools and businesses. Linspire also pioneered the CNR Technology (http://www.cnr.com), which allows desktop Linux users access to thousands of software programs, packages and libraries, each of which can be downloaded and installed with just one mouse click.

About Microsoft

Founded in 1975, Microsoft (Nasdaq "MSFT") is the worldwide leader in software, services and solutions that help people and businesses realize their full potential.

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: News Story; Groups: JBoss, Linspire, Linux, Microsoft, Novell, Xandros

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (89)

more linspire-talk here

Manufacturing perceptions.

48 earlier comments in the full thread.

Perhaps it is time we formed a group umbrella announcing that our distros have banded together and agreed not to sue each other?
@ helios

I hope your problem with depth perception didn't come about as a result of your efforts in expanding the ever-growing usage of Linux. If so, you may hold the distinction of being the guy who's lost more body parts in the name of Linux.

@ anybody

It seems Microsoft has finally realized that the simplest, most direct way to solve the "Linux Problem" is to use their most powerful and plentiful asset, money. Money, it seems, can't buy and ideal, but sure can destroy one.
> ESR hasn't returned my calls yet.

I guess I hadn't thought about that. The Linspire deal is a straightforward implementation of his plan for domination (or whatever it is this week) isn't it?
>The Linspire deal is a straightforward implementation of his plan for domination (or whatever it is this week) isn't it?

?????

What planet do you live on? I don't recall any indications of love between ESR and Microsoft on this one. Please enlighten me.
Quoting:For those that don't, I just lost my left eye.


Ouch. I'm sorry for you. Lacking depth perception is a big PITA (I lost use of one eye for two months a couple of years back after a fight). I hope you can cope.
> I don't recall any indications of love between ESR and Microsoft on this one. Please enlighten me.

Here's a quote from http://desktoplinux.com/news/NS4091414098.html

[Eric said that "We need a good answer for the twenty-year-old whose first question about Linux is 'Will it run my iPod?'"

Freespire can't. It's doable on Linux, but you need WINE or Crossover Office.

Raymond thinks, though, that, "No matter how painful, no matter how ugly, we must enable the Linux desktop to run Windows media, to support iPods. We may not want binary programs in user-space, but we must have them."

If we don't, Raymond thinks the Linux desktop will miss its one opportunity to make a significant dent in the Windows desktop monopoly.]

From Carmony's letter:

[This agreement will offer several advantages to Linspire Linux users not found anywhere else, such as Windows Media 10 support, genuine Microsoft TrueType fonts, Microsoft patent coverage, improved interoperability with Microsoft Windows computers, and so on.]

and

[Today, Linspire announced our latest partnership, one with Microsoft, to bring even more choices to desktop Linux users, and together, offer a "better" Linux experience.]

ESR believes Linux can't move forward unless all of this proprietary stuff is available for Linux. That is exactly what the Linspire deal provides.
Quoting:ESR believes Linux can't move forward unless all of this proprietary stuff is available for Linux. That is exactly what the Linspire deal provides.


You have a very good point, and at the same time, I don't believe ESR meant to do what is being done by LinSpire and others.

There are other ways and means, e.g (Samba) and the many of FOSS applications that run on Windows. FOSS has done and continue to do its parts but MS isn't. Making MS products run on Linux is the responsibility of MS alone and don't need any one else because FOSS is open.

MS trying to avoid admitting that Linux is becoming mainstream is not going to work, it will have to concede. MS is coming in as an uninvited guest to keep its association with FOSS vague. They just can't digest the idea yet and going to have to, especially when MS products are replaced and no one is forced to go to MS because only it has a certain product. That is happening every day.

Quoting:Eric said that "We need a good answer for the twenty-year-old whose first question about Linux is 'Will it run my iPod?'"

Freespire can't. It's doable on Linux, but you need WINE or Crossover Office.


How odd. My Debian/Etch works perfectly out-of-the-box with my girlfriend's iPod Nano. No need for Wine of CO. If he was talking about iTunes he may have a point, but iPod work just fine.
ESR, in his next breath, said -

"No matter how painful, no matter how ugly, we must enable the Linux desktop to run Windows media, to support iPods. We may not want binary programs in user-space, but we must have them."

That's a long way from wanting to play nice with Microsoft. That's more a matter of wanting people to use Linux and being willing to tolerate some unpleasantness to do it. Willing to accept one pain does not imply willingness to accept another, different pain.

>My Debian/Etch works perfectly out-of-the-box with my girlfriend's iPod Nano.

So how does iTunes work for you? I can see my wife's Nano on my Suse box without any grief, but it's hard to say the ipod "works" with Linux if iTunes didn't. The two are rather tightly tied together.

Quoting:So how does iTunes work for you?


Don't care. We have over 200 CD and most of them have been ripped to my server. She just puts a different batch of MP3's on it every week for her ride to work. If we want new music (which hardly ever happens anymore) we'll buy CD's, not DRM'ed downloads.
> I don't believe ESR meant to do what is being done by LinSpire and others.

Clearly most of the objection comes from the patent protection provided by the deal. It appears that the only way Linspire was going to get the deal was with the patent protection included. The question is whether the proprietary goodies are worth accepting the patent protection. For me the patent protection is neither good or bad, and I don't have a use for any of the proprietary crap that they get in this deal. The deal will be good for Linspire, though, because their target customer will only care that his/her computer works like Windows.

> That's a long way from wanting to play nice with Microsoft.

True, but I don't know that Carmony wants to play nice with Microsoft either. He used gentle language in the announcement, but he has always made it clear that Linspire's goal is to steal Windows users, because the Linux market is too small to be worth his time.
>Don't care.

That's what I figured. For most folks, however, iPod really equals iPod + iTunes.

My wife is that way. In fact, much as she loves her iPod, she refuses to buy another one. We have switched over to alternative mp3 players.
> It appears that the only way Linspire was going to get the deal was with the patent protection included.

I'd be interested to know what the terms of that protection are.
mepis will be next - or warren will move to canada

one thing I noticed is all the deals are US based companies -

don't know if that has to do with anything but just an observation

I don't see any company outside the US agreeing to these deals.

I think ubuntu would work with microsoft but they would never agree to the patent clause.

Quoting:mepis will be next - or warren will move to canada
I sympathise with Warren, and I think he could have been more cooperative with the community
Quoting:one thing I noticed is all the deals are US based companies -
I believe you are right and the reason is because other countries don't have the bad type of patent laws that the USA has. It also could be because MS is a BAD US company and don't scare them easily.
Quoting:I think ubuntu would work with microsoft but they would never agree to the patent clause.
It is not too bad to deal with MS on equal terms, but dealing with MS on their own terms is futile. Let's hope Mark is as savvy as you think he is.

Quoting:I'd be interested to know what the terms of that protection are.


Don't we all !!!

@dino,

I recommend the iAudio x5L...best mp3 player I've found out there. Plays anything you throw at it. I also like the Creative Vision:M but it works a bit wonky due to MTP as it communication protocol.

@jsusanka,

I think the next targets are ubuntu and Mandriva...and I think Mark Shuttleworth may think he'll be able to 'grease the wheels' if a deal is made by 'explaining' it. I think he'll believe that he can put a spin on it that is acceptable to the community. Time will tell. I think MEPIS is something that Microsoft isn't interested in.
Quoting:I think MEPIS is something that Microsoft isn't interested in.
I wouldn't be too sure about that. The more the better and they are interested in anyone and everyone without any bias.

As I recall. They did say this offer is available to anyone after closing the deal with Novell, didn't they?



I think Microsoft will absolutely go after Mepis, no doubt in my mind whatsoever. And MS is probably already doing a dance of some kind with Canonical. That would be the big get for MS, and right now Canonical is such a big, big fish (like AOL was before the bottom dropped out of the dialup market) that Shuttleworth might think he can do whatever he wants or needs to see that his distro survives. Perhaps I don't give him enough credit, since I don't know him, and I hope he realizes that making a deal with MS is the beginning of the end.

Another one to watch for is Sun, whose motivation for developing Open Office, I figure, is largely to blunt Microsoft's desktop monopoly. Without OO, Linux wouldn't be doing half as well as it is.

Like it or not, this Microsoft situation is going to divide the FOSS community. Expect positions to harden considerably over the next few months.

Who will sign with Microsoft next? That's what I want to know.
Considering Ubuntu's "Bug #1", I wonder if Shuttleworth will play with MS?

ESR and Shuttleworth?

Anyone care to speculate?

http://www.itwire.com.au/content/view/12899/1090/

If anything...Mr Shuttleworth will need to say something about this.
http://www.linspire.com/linspire_letter_archives.php?id=36 http://www.linspire.com/lindows_news_pressreleases.php

Quoting:As the late Kerry Packer, Australia's richest man, once said during the negotiations with MCC after he organised a rebel cricket series in Australia in the late 70s: "There is a little bit of the whore in every one of us; gentlemen, name your price."

PS: It may be a good idea to read the pages linked above and save them somewhere safe. I have a feeling that at least one will disappear from the public internet soon.


;-P
>If anything...Mr Shuttleworth will need to say something about this.

Why?

Why does anybody need to say anything, particularly given the lack of any details on which to base action?

It's unclear to me exactly what has changed and how much. Linspire has always had a relationship of sorts with Microsoft. That relationship is now better defined. It may -- just may, because we don't have the details -- violate future GPLs.

Shuttlesworth might want to ensure that none of his IP is used in violation of its license, or he may wish to negotiate a deal with Linspire. These days, saying much of anything WRT Microsoft deals seems like risky business.
Let's consider Star Wars Episode V - The Empire Strikes Back:

Lando Calrissian makes a deal with the Empire to deliver Luke Skywalker to them. In return, Darth Vader promises that the Empire will continue to overlook their mining operation and not tax it / blow it up / whatever.

But, as the story progresses, Vader keeps making changes to the agreement... at some point we see Lando saying something like "This deal is getting worse by the second".

Lando eventually realises that all the screwing over of his friends is just not worth it, and switches sides again. He also tells the staff to evacuate, and then abandons the complex entirely.

So... perhaps there's a little Cloud City in Linspire/Xandros/Novell's future.
Quoting:Why?

Why does anybody need to say anything, particularly given the lack of any details on which to base action?


Very surprised you even asked dino...I thought you were more intelligent than that. Take a step outside of your own convictions and mindset on technology and look at this from a third person perspective who doesn't know anything other than Ubuntu and Linux. Now, think back to the 'Linspire is based on Ubuntu' announcement. Think of CNR being ported to Ubuntu.

Now think about...would you expect to not know where Ubuntu stands on the issue? Most people wouldn't. I know you're not most people though..
>Now think about...would you expect to not know where Ubuntu stands on the issue?

Depends on what you say "the issue" is.

If it's Linspire,

I don't know why I would expect to care. I don't use Linspire and I don't know the details of their deal. I know they have always done a dance with Microsoft. From my standpoint, very little is new.

If the issue is Ubuntu doing a deal with Microsoft, I would say there is more risk in making a statement that being quiet.
Microsoft is mostly interested in gaining a foothold with companies that choose to hold back part of their systems as proprietary/closed source code. Xandros with their file systems and yet still, Linspire with bits and parts of their system. There is a specific reason for that and I am surprised no one has made the connection.

I have rang ESR until my right ear is sore from phone contact. I actually started attempting to contact him during the Xandros deal, knowing full well Linspire was next. I talked about it here so there is open record of it. Someone mentioned PCLinuxOS as the "next to fall". No, the next one pitched is Mepis. Fact is, it may have already been done and either not announced or flat out rejected. My crystal ball isn't saying which.

Shuttleworth hasn't spoke to me since Tux500...with good reason ;-O). Brad Smith doesn't fear Shuttleworth, he fears the community behind it. If for that reason only, any "deal" done with The Big Cannon/Shuttleworth will be more subtle.

h

Quoting:Xandros with their file systems and yet still, Linspire with bits and parts of their system. There is a specific reason for that and I am surprised no one has made the connection.


I have, see my recent post in another thread on this subject.
That's true, helios - I didn't get the chance to post earlier, but I was going to say she had been talking right up your alley.
another connection people aren't making...*buntu derrivatives.
> *buntu derrivatives.

AFAIK, Xandros is a Debian derivative, but not an Ubuntu one.
helios- why even bother with ESR? Other than to poke at him with a stick to make him emit his usual quota of "I am so wonderful to me" blather. It seems the only people who pay attention to him these days are the free-as-in-freeloader demographic; the ones who want operating systems just like Windows or Mac, only free of cost. So they are gung-ho to lard down free software with whatever proprietary crud it takes to get there, using the "we need to temporarily abandon freedom in order to gain freedom" rationale. There is also a lot of mumbo-jumbo about 'World Domination Is Necessary Now!' http://catb.org/~esr/writings/world-domination/world-dominat...

I figure if a Windows-clone environment is what Linux Users Really Want, Linspire and Xandros would be the dominant Linuxes. But they're not, and since Mr. Raymond deploys many more hundreds of words than that to explain his position, which of course has nothing to do with getting a paycheck, I might be missing something subtle and important.

>I figure if a Windows-clone environment is what Linux Users Really Want, Linspire and Xandros would be the dominant Linuxes.

Silly logic. Xandros and Linspire are not going after Linux users.
Quoting:Silly logic. Xandros and Linspire are not going after Linux users.
They are after any users, including Linux.

>They are after any users, including Linux.

They won't turn 'em down, but their target market is converts.
Quoting:They won't turn 'em down, but their target market is converts.


And that's why, or at least one reason why, Microsoft wants to control them.
Linspire has no idea what their target market is. I talked to Kevin Carmony when Linspire 5.0 was released last year, and he told me their target market was not Windows users, nor Linux users, nor Mac users, but people who were new to personal computers. Sometimes I think he makes it up as he goes. The whole default-root-user issue (which Mr. Carmony defended), Rob Enderle keynoting the Desktop Linux Summit (DLS), their not-very-good tech support, and the confusing assault of commercial crapware when you boot a new Linspire system- it all adds up to "ew no thanks" for me.

All of this parroting of the "Interoperability and Customer Choice" baloney is a smokescreen for "we're desperate and that Microsoft money spends real nice." No more complicated than that. If it gets Linux into new markets, cool, but that would be purely an accidental side-effect. Anyone who believes that Microsoft has kindly intentions towards Linux please report to the Brain Examination Institute for a thorough workup.
>we're desperate and that Microsoft money spends real nice.

I'd actually feel a lot better if that is the case.

There was no mention of Microsoft money going to Linspire in the reports I read, but... The more Microsoft spends for what will, in the end, amount to nothing much, the better.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post