Advanced

Dell Mail Reeks of Redmond's Fear

Posted by dcparris on · 41 comments
LXer; By D.C. Parris
Mail this story
Print this story

LXer Feature: 01-Feb-2007

Recently publicized Microsoft e-mails about Dell reveal more than Microsoft's thinking about Dell's "betrayal". The e-mails demonstrate Microsoft's warranted fear of the penguin.

Did you read the PDF file containing the e-mail discussion about Dell? In brief, Russ Holt, the guy behind Dell's Linux push, made comments at a forum that Microsoft didn't like. The e-mails focus on Microsoft's position toward Dell. But one of the last e-mails, from Paul Flessner, underscores the severity of the Linux threat.

Microsoft's Motive

It's true that having the complete thread would enlighten us more fully. Yet, this particular thread was brought to light in regards to the relationship between Dell and Microsoft. It is clear that Bill Veghte was, well, surprised by Holt's comments on Red Hat being easier to work with than Microsoft. The ensuing discussion takes us through the various views of each participant on how to address the relationship with Dell. What caught my attention was the resignation with which Microsoft seemed to be accepting Linux as a competitive threat.



Paul Flessner, the man who said Microsoft should "whack" Dell, lets his motive shine brightly. After pointing out that Dell is seeking to expand their profit margin by $50 per PC, he goes on to ask, "Where are our advantages? That is a productive discussion." While any business should continually assess their advantages, I'm not so sure this is one of those discussions. It appears to be a more genuine question, as if he, or Microsoft as a whole, really does not know where their advantages are.



Flessner goes on to say, "This is life. I am not giving up. I don't have a penguin in my basement. I LOVE Windows, which is why I want us to face this..." So, he's not giving up, is he? Is it really that bad? Are things so bad he has to talk about not giving up? Those are usually the words of an underdog - not the king of the hill. People say they're not giving up when they face a serious challenge. It sure looks like Microsoft was facing a serious challenge in 2002.



Business As Usual for Dell

I also think the e-mails point out some interesting things about Dell's relationship with Microsoft. Many in the FOSS community seem to think that Microsoft bullies Dell at will. Yet, these e-mails demonstrate that Dell is quite independent, and even a serious Linux vendor. It's true they haven't put much into desktop Linux, but they apparently have a fairly strong relationship with Red Hat in the server arena. They even see greater synergy with Red Hat. While Veghte called that notion "ironic", the code for GNU/Linux is Free and open - there is nothing ironic about it.



Obviously the Linux community's primary concern with Dell is on the desktop. Still, I think it's important to point out that Dell uses Linux to its benefit, just like the rest of us. They use it in their ordering system. They use it in negotiations with Microsoft. And they sell it with Oracle to enterprises. In other words, I think the Linux community already has a great deal of influence with Dell. And Microsoft knows it.



So maybe Dell still doesn't have any big plans for GNU/Linux on the desktop. The fact remains that Dell and HP both see the value of GNU/Linux. Even if these and other vendors cannot or will not say so publicly, they probably even see the advantages of GNU/Linux over Windows. Here's the thing. Microsoft's response is, increasingly, to crack down on so-called piracy. They trap a lot of innocent "victims" in the process. It's a lot like a government that does not know how to fight a guerrilla war - their actions are too strong and too desperate, and will create a backlash.



Fear Response

Microsoft's current behavior - whacking partners and treating software users like drug users - is driven by fear. It's driven by the fear of losing more than anything else. Microsoft was built on Gates' competitive personality. Neither does Microsoft really understand the power of collaboration, and fear is their response. If Microsoft's latest patent submission - the DRM'ed modular OS - is any indicator, then Seattle needs to prepare for the economic implosion of Mount Saint Redmond.



References

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial, LXer Features; Groups: Community, Linux, Microsoft

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (41)

My wife says it's just coincidence ...

That the latest Dell flyer I received by snail mail depicted a Dell notebook with several penguins on the screen ....

I'm thinking Dell is trying to dilute the power of the Penguin.

Viva la penguinistas!

Error in title: Reeks, not Wreaks

Error in title: Reeks, not Wreaks
Your reeking havoc hear. but if their is a better reason for you're usage then the usual, than I will understand.
herzeleid: If your reply was to suggest that ccady is incorrect, then I must suggest that you are incorrect. If you were agreeing instead, then please disregard. :)

Reek: to smell badly, or to have an element suggesting something

"The kitchen reeked of burnt garlic" "The senators statement reeked of racism"

herzeleid, you apparently forgot the [humor] tag for those of us who are funnily-impaired

I figured no one could make that many grammatical errors by accident.
I no ewe awl are trying to bee funny, but awl of this spell-checker-approved spelling is causing me pane.
Oh yeah, and it should be "reeks."
"Oh yeah, and it should be 'reeks.'"

Nah, just delete the word "of".
Apparently my humor was far to suttel for this crowd. I should of made it more blatent.

Gosh folks, I was having fun mutilating the english language. 10 points to anyone who corrects all the errors in my 2 posts in this thread.
Newsflash: Editor-in-Chief of popular news site cain't spell worth a hoot! I have to admint, as soon as I saw Scott's e-mail, I felt my face flush 30 shades of red. Duh! And to think my parents wasted all that money on 2 years at a good private school. Sigh!
wow, two whole years a school! You should be darn near perfect.

Very nice commentary

7 earlier comments in the full thread.

>so how does it apply to this article?

Hmmm. Let me put my thinking cap on here.

Well, let's see...

Let's imagine a fictional world where countless Chicken Little's scream out every time Microsoft blows its nose...

The fact that this article demonstrates that even big bad old Microsoft isn't possessed of limitless power might serve as a counterpoint.

Not that Chicken Little ever listens.
Quoting:where countless Chicken Little's scream out every time Microsoft blows its nose...
What can I say? FOSS is very dear to us.

Remember Dino, it is better safe than sorry. And It is safer to overestimate your enemies than underestimating them. We all know how sneaky, sleazy and ruthless MS is, don't we?
>And It is safer to overestimate your enemies than underestimating them.

Not always.

Overestimating your enemies (as we overestimated the Soviets until they collapsed) can result in wasted resources and important things going undone.

Better to appreciate your friends (Hey! IBM and Oracle and others ain't exactly featherweights) for what they are than to puff your enemies into what they are not.
">so how does it apply to this article?

Hmmm. Let me put my thinking cap on here.

Well, let's see...

Let's imagine a fictional world where countless Chicken Little's scream out every time Microsoft blows its nose...

The fact that this article demonstrates that even big bad old Microsoft isn't possessed of limitless power might serve as a counterpoint.

Not that Chicken Little ever listens."

I think that is reaching just a little bit - seems to me they are pretty successful at asserting their limitless power.

try to call dell up today and get a laptop/desktop without windows. and I don't mean by going to some hidden web page either - I mean do it but calling their 800 number on their flyer. looks like they still have microsoft pasted all over their web pages too.

>try to call dell up today and get a laptop/desktop without windows. and I don't mean by going to some hidden web page either

Of course they have Microsoft pasted all over the place. It's what they sell. If they could make more money selling Linux, they'd do that, just as they are doing in the server space.

As e-mail exchanges demonstrate, Microsoft doesn't want them selling Linux in the server space, either. Trouble is, there's money to be made and Microsoft needs Dell as much as Dell needs Microsoft.
"Of course they have Microsoft pasted all over the place. It's what they sell. If they could make more money selling Linux, they'd do that, just as they are doing in the server space.

As e-mail exchanges demonstrate, Microsoft doesn't want them selling Linux in the server space, either. Trouble is, there's money to be made and Microsoft needs Dell as much as Dell needs Microsoft."

I guess we will never know if they could make more selling linux than windows on the desktop and home space. since no one else can even get in the market to even be given a chance. I don't see redhat advertisements all over the place for their servers on their web site. why is that if they do make more money selling linux on servers then why don't they put adds all over the place just like their windows adds.

seems to me microsoft still seems to have their virtual limitless power doing its job. so if I was chicken little I would still say the sky is falling until I see linux adds equal microsoft adds on their website.
>I don't see redhat advertisements all over the place for their servers on their web site. why is that if they do make more money selling linux on servers then why don't they put adds all over the place just like their windows adds.

I would bet that most Linux servers go to large corporate clients, and those are sold a different way.
" would bet that most Linux servers go to large corporate clients, and those are sold a different way."

that is just my point -

why don't they advertise linux on their servers and the common folk just might start to think about buying it for their clients and servers.

but it is hidden and out sight and I have a feeling these emails and more are the reason.
>I have a feeling these emails and more are the reason.

We all have many feelings about many things, but business decisions tend to be dollars and sense. Whey would Dell advertise their Linux servers beyond what they do now?

As it is, they are not hard to find. Many, if not most, of their servers are available with Linux or WIndows, and seperate prices are published for each (are -- hmmmm -- maybe I should say were. Haven't visited the Dell site in a while).

You spend money to advertise something when it will gain you some benefit.
> why don't they advertise linux on their servers

Dell doesn't really advertise any of the large server components, as they expect you already know what you want if you've come to them to buy $20k worth of rack servers. They do have marketing agreements with RedHat though where they list RedHat as a free pre-install OS with a free subscription (some models) along with the "No OS" choice.

I generally select the free RedHat option rather than "No OS" even though I put Debian on them just to send a signal that I'm buying them for use with Linux, and also when doing returns etc. you get the Linux support people.

An example of the difference, when trying to do a return of a HD doing the click of death on one of our laptops, I got Dell's traditional consumer-level Windows support (it wasn't bought through the business support side of Dell). She asked if I had the Windows CD still, I said no, and that started quite a conversation. It went something like this, but longer:

Dell: You will need the Windows CD to be able to use the HD Me: I don't need it, I'll be installing Linux. Dell: But how will you do that sir, if you don't have Windows? Me: It's a different OS, it hasn't been running Windows for years, it's not a problem. Dell: I will call you back when the HD arrives to walk you through installing the OS Me: I don't need your help with this, just send me the HD.

She called back when it arrived and seemed surprised that I had managed to install something without having Windows.
> Dell: You will need the Windows CD to be able to use the HD

That is like, such totally awesome customer service. Maybe by Y3K they'll cop to the radical concept of cluing their personnel into their whole product line. Woa, I get dizzy thinking about it. I might write a "MBAs For Dummies" series based on it.

"We all have many feelings about many things, but business decisions tend to be dollars and sense. Whey would Dell advertise their Linux servers beyond what they do now?"

uh? the point of advertising is to get more people to use it.

if they are making more money by selling linux servers in server space as you say and as these emails show then why don't they advertise the heck out of it.

that is dollars and sense and to me they should do it more. you know maybe if they did just maybe they would get one or two more people to use linux more.

but I think we all know the real reason and these emails give us a glimpse into that reason.
Well, Dell can probably get discounts from MS if they push MS's products to the exclusion of everything else. This would be an incentive, not a requirement to MS doesn't violate any DoJ rulings.

So, is the money gained from extra Linux server sales enough to cover the increased license cost of Windows, especially given the fact that almost all of your server customers will ask for Linux anyway if they want it, regardless of advertising? It makes business sense for dell *not* to advertise they Linus server offerings too loudly.

I really hope that the coming cases against Microsoft will bring their OEM licensing deals into light.
>that is dollars and sense and to me they should do it more. you know maybe if they did just maybe they would get one or two more people to use linux more.

Ummm...probably the same reason they don't advertise Dell servers with pieces of paper with those little "call me" strips thumb-tacked to bulletin boards.

Different markets are approached in different ways.
> It makes business sense for dell *not* to advertise they Linus server offerings too loudly.

Does it? Is it worth being Sauron's slave? Microsoft is telling Dell how to run their business. That doesn't seem very smart no matter how it's spun.
"Ummm...probably the same reason they don't advertise Dell servers with pieces of paper with those little "call me" strips thumb-tacked to bulletin boards.

Different markets are approached in different ways."

umm - well now you are speculating - arguing a different argument - bill g would proud of you.

I would argue that their support calls would drop if they sold linux to the common joe because it would actually work. besides dell support is basically vnc into the persons machine and restore off the original image.

the same could easily be done with linux.

jsusanka, good point. after all, they advertise the heck out of their Windows servers, which presumably are also targeting a primarily corporate market.
Oddly, the point of my article was that Microsoft - weren't they still dismissing Linux as a competitive threat in '02? - was shaken by the discovery that a key partner was selling boxes with something other than Windows. They were caught completely off-guard. I think it also reveals that Dell is more independent than we seem to give them credit for. Sure, Microsoft probably bullies them a bit (that mindset shows through in the e-mails), but Dell is apparently trying to keep its options open.
>Sure, Microsoft probably bullies them a bit (that mindset shows through in the e-mails), but Dell is apparently trying to keep its options open.

Which goes to my point:

Microsoft ain't the only big gorilla in the zoo.
">Sure, Microsoft probably bullies them a bit (that mindset shows through in the e-mails), but Dell is apparently trying to keep its options open.

Which goes to my point:

Microsoft ain't the only big gorilla in the zoo."

well - my point is this shows nothing about what dell is actually thinking. to me it looks like microsoft's bullying is actually working because I still see adds for microsoft all over their website.

but maybe I am judging this a whole different level - but to me things are just status quo as far as the bullying goes.

It's also a kneejerk reaction

Aside from fear, MS's reaction in the e-mails can also be a knee-jerk reaction. Reading the PDF, Bll Veghte states in his opening e-mail that Dell is a key MS partner and MS cannot afford to loose them. Digging back in my memory (and the El Reg archives) I recall 2002 as the first time Dell started pushing Linux hard.

I don't see direct fear/despair in the mails but simple blind panic of a company caught totally off-guard. MS simply didn't see this coming.

Looking back to http://lxer.com/module/newswire/view/57261/index.html in coincides nicely with the timing of their tactic change from saying that Linux is broken or bad to the infamous TCO studies. Dell caught MS by surprise and MS reacted by starting to tout the TCO FUD.

I'll chip (pun intended) in for the monument

"...the economic implosion of Mount Saint Redmond." That line should be chiseled into a granite slab. And soon I hope.

Thanks for the careful screening of those e-mails Don.

Richard

great article

good information and great article.

microsoft is very scared of linux.

they are so scared they are using the law to go after it.

I think it speaks volumes when a company cannot compete technically and has to resort to litigation.

now the great architect in the sky (bill g) has come up with forcing the vendors in creating hardware drm on their devices and forcing them to write drivers for them all in the name of HD content and protecting the right of content producers (riaa and mpaa).

things are just seriously getting out of hand with the riaa, mpaa, microsoft, and apple. they have all reached the point of insanity with this crap.

I personally hope they all go bankrupt.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post