Advanced

Linux and The Indianapolis 500

Posted by Scott_Ruecker on · 41 comments
LXer.com; By Scott Ruecker (Phoenix, USA)
Mail this story
Print this story


LXer Feature: 08-May-2007

The idea to have the Open Source community sponsor a car in the Indianapolis 500 put forth recently has more than just the Open Source Press taking notice. Here is my take on it.

First a disclaimer: I am in not in any way, shape or form involved with the Tux500 campaign. I happen to know several of the people involved but other than that I have no connection to it whatsoever. With that said I am free to express any opinions I may have on the subject, which I plan on doing right now..

It all started several weeks ago when Bob Moore and Ken Starks made public the idea of sponsoring a car in the Indianapolis 500. The idea being to have one of the cars say "Linux" and/or have a big "Tux" logo on it. A very cool and very bold idea. Having your name on one of the cars in the biggest motorsports event on the planet does not come cheap. Here's the funny thing, its not the amount of money but where its going to be spent that has gotten underneath some peoples skin. Some like the NASCAR or Motorcycle circuits more and others don't believe that people who watch any kind of Motorsports are who the Open Source community should be advertising too. Then there are those who just don't like anything and some, ok one, who thinks its a scam of some kind.

Does anyone remember when Firefox had the two full page ad in the New York Times? At the time I was very involved in the Spread Firefox campaign and I remember when Asa Dotzler and others proposed the idea of raising money to put an ad in the New York Times and tell the world about Firefox. Something like that had never been done before. Many people immediately questioned why they had chosen the New York Times instead of another publication. Others thought that we should make the ad smaller and put it in several newspapers at once and still others just didn't like it no matter what paper or publication was mentioned. Sound familiar?

Well Asa stuck to his guns and took the time to explain over and over again that putting the ad in the New York Times, because of its national and international circulation would have the greatest effect possible for the money raised. The majority of people involved agreed and the donations came pouring in. So much money was raised that instead of the original one page idea it became two pages in size making certain that the ad could not be glanced over by the reader. Also, having the names of the people who donated to the campaign incorporated into the actual design of the ad was a stroke of genius.

Now whether or not you like the idea of taking out a full page in the New York Times or painting an Indy League Racing Car with Linux logos is your own prerogative. Like it or not you have to respect the fact that someone is trying to do something, anything to get the word out and let the world know about how great Linux and Open Source Software really is. I believe that taking action, any action is better than inaction. The arguments over whether the money is better well spent on something else or your preference of one newspaper or racing league over another are counter productive to what is trying to be achieved, especially the curmudgeons who don't like anything and have to tell everyone about it. The arguments for not taking action never change, no matter the source.

One of the things I like about about Open Source is that it gives the individual the choice to do what they want and nothing more. You can use the software and walk away if you wish. You do not have to participate in the community at all and no can make you. That kind of freedom makes people want to participate and it is just one of the reasons that the Open Source Community is as strong as it is. It is the voluntary bonds of common interest we create that are the strongest and it is the voluntary, and mostly volunteer Open Source Community that is one the strongest communities of common interest on the planet, I challenge anyone to refute this.

The Indianapolis 500 is the single largest Motorsports event on Planet Earth. It is a one of a kind car race with no equal inside or outside of the United States. There are race teams whose only purpose is to attempt to qualify and run in that one race. It is the only race that gets the attention and feeds the imagination of people of all ages no matter where they are or what country they are from. For an entire month people from all over the world watch, listen and read about what is going on in Indianapolis. If you have ever seen a car and know what a "race" is, then you have heard of the Indianapolis 500. It is that full month of publicized qualifying, testing and good old fashion "grandstanding" leading up to the actual race that make it comparable to the World Cup in every way.

With all the corporate entities refusing to help because they think that having a car in the Indy 500 with a Linux logo on it is not enough to make them want to help, it is up to us to make this happen. Its up to us as a community to show the world what we are capable of. With Red Hat not wanting to help, and Novell and Dell playing us against Microsoft, what I have done in response is to contact all of the vendors in our Pre-Installed Linux Vendor Database and ask them for their help in sponsoring the Tux500 car. I can only hope that some of them will like what they see and donate to the cause. I have also been telling everyone I know about it as well. I am only one person but I know I am not alone in my efforts. I am a part of a worldwide community of people who believe in Free and Open Source Software.

My personal goal in writing this article is to inspire you to help out, to tell others and through your actions show the world just how powerful this community is. Are we going to raise the whole $350,000? probably not, but it does not mean that we have failed if we don't. Are we going to be able to raise the minimum $25,000 so that we have a Linux Logo on the car period? I hope so. That goal is certainly within reach and if we do we will have done something that has never been done before. We will have shown the world that a community of people can come together to promote something that they believe in so strongly that it got put on a car in the Indianapolis 500 for the whole world to see.

And just what is it that we will get in return for our support? The ability to tell the world that we were a part of putting a car in the Indy 500. We were a part of making the world take notice of Linux. I don't know about you but that is something I want to be a part of. It is something I am going to brag about to any who will listen to me for a long time to come.

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial, LXer Features; Groups: Community, GNU, Linux, LXer, Mozilla, Novell, Red Hat

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

  Related stories
» More like this

Comments (41)

Life without Linux

Thanks much Scott.

Just think, if Linux wasn't around we'd all be shelling out $200 for Vista (actually It'd be more because there would be less competition). So a small percentage of that Vista money could be donated as a thank you.

It would be nice to see Tux500 in its full decked-out glory, but I really don't want to see any corporate involvement. If it happens fine. Everybody has a right to donate. But my preferred ideal is for us to make it happen on our own.

Great work Scott!

Quoting:what I have done in response is to contact all of the vendors in our The Pre-Installed Linux Vendor Database and ask them for their help in sponsoring the Tux500 car.


Wow. That's a *lot* of work. Thanks. May I ask how many have responded back to you?
Thank You Sander,

So far, about a half dozen. But its only been a day or so since I sent them all out. So I know there will be more..

+1.

Thanks indeed, Scott. Keep up the great work.
Hey Scott,

you should be better a Ghostwriter or Press speaker for Helios.

Your intense of Words could raise the funds a little bit higher.

Maybe you will work at the next project together. :)

Nice article.

Vince
Vince, that's a nice thought. I agree that Scott would serve well in that role. Here's where my "but" comes into play:

Unfortunately, we as journalists have to concern ourselves with conflicts of interest. As an auditor, I am in a position of privileged acccess, and cannot therefore involve myself in the story - not even (dis)approve those submitted about Tux500. It doesn't matter that I'm not actually involved in the campaign. If Scott were to take on the role of spokesman for the Tux500 campaign, he would not be able to write an op/ed piece like this for LXer. He could write all he wants, just not as one of our editors. We have to have at least one editor around here who can review and post Tux500 stories. Mind you, Scott could still be an editor, but would have to abstain from reporting on, or posting, stories about the campaign.

Although LXer is a community news site, we press for high standards of journalistic conduct. Without adhering to well-established principles, we would lose our integrity. Our integrity, as much as anything else, is what has helped us grow. At least, that's what I gather from all the feedback we've had from our registered readers.

I don't mean to be a killjoy, but some in our audience may not understand journalism ethics very well.
Don is absolutely right, as a ghostwriter I could write about it all I want, just not for LXer.

Ethics matter because essentially its all we have..

Besides, I have a funny feeling that people would still know its me anyway. :-)

> Our integrity, as much as anything else, is what has helped us grow.

Yep.

Great enthusiasm, misplaced energy.

13 earlier comments in the full thread.

Quoting:I'm pointing out the flaws of this plan and suggesting that more people take the time to promote it themselves.


Perhaps you would like to provide solutions to those flaws, rather than simply sitting there pointing out those flaws. You claim to run a business or two, ask yourself, what do you prefer to hear from your employees,.. Problems or Solutions?
Why is it that every time someone comes up with an idea for this community all of a sudden, "Its their campaign not ours"?

It is because it wasn't your idea? I think so.. Why?

BECAUSE NOT ONE OF THE PEOPLE WHO SAY THAT HAVE ANY IDEAS OF THEIR OWN!!!!

I'll bet that if you started a campaign similar in scope to this one that it would all of a sudden it would become "your" campaign, not the community's. Wanna bet? I got $20 that says I am right.

Prove me wrong, please. Please!

If all the curmudgeons spent their energy on an idea of their own we wouldn't have to worry about Microsoft and their Billion dollar advertising campaigns would we?

To notamonopoly. I paid for my right to comment on this subject, have you?
"To notamonopoly. I paid for my right to comment on this subject, have you?"

I don't know where you live, but in my country people do not have to pay to have an opinion. Besides, why would I pay for something I think is a poor idea?

It's funny that I keep getting slammed for having an opinion but the whole point of this thread was to point out the problems I see with the campaign. No one has denied that the problems exist, they just keep freaking out that someone has pointed them out.

You dare me to create my own campaign, fine. I'm officially starting a campaign to raise over a quarter of a million dollars to put a Linux logo on the side of my car. I will be advertising to everyone as I travel. It will make more of an impact than the Indy car because it will actually stand out in a crowd instead of blending in with every other ad covered vehicle going 200 mph. Also, it will be advertised all year round instead of a single race. So, how about that?

In all seriousness, I do have an idea for a campaign that would be meaningful. We should do something to counter these endless "Get the facts" ads all over the web. Scroll to the top of this page. What do you see? "Ads by Google" that link to Microsoft, who is eager to lie about their products being better. You and I choose to ignore it because we know that it's untrue, but what does that do to a person that does not know any better? On just about every Linux site I go to I see this same ad being shown. So how about someone put together a massive online campaign that would balance the scales? Again, I have absolutely no time to do such a thing, but for those who keep demanding suggestions, there's one that I would contribute to if it was properly organized.

The open source community is the best community on earth, despite disagreements on how we should promote the products we love so much. Our end goal is the same regardless of how we achieve it so I wish this campaign and any future ones all the best.

Microsoft Sucks, nuff said.
> Scroll to the top of this page. What do you see? "Ads by Google" that link to Microsoft...

If so, bring them to the attention of the editors. They're not supposed to be there.
> I'm officially starting a campaign to raise over a quarter of a million dollars to put a Linux logo on the side of my car. I will be advertising to everyone as I travel. It will make more of an impact than the Indy car because it will actually stand out in a crowd instead of blending in with every other ad covered vehicle going 200 mph. Also, it will be advertised all year round instead of a single race. So, how about that?

Sounds good, but why do you need $250K to do so. That's what it costs to get advertising in Indy. You could do what you want for the cost of a paint job, at most a couple of thousand dollars. A magnetic Tux logo for each side of the car could probably be run off on a good inkjet printer (they used to sell the magnetic sheets at Walmart, I don't know if they still do or not). If you think it's a good idea, why not do so.
> I'm officially starting a campaign to raise over a quarter of a million dollars to put a Linux logo on the side of my car.

That's not a bad idea, though a quarter of a million dollars could be used to paint an entire fleet of cars with the Debian logo, driven around in the downtown of America's largest cities.

Now you need to start organizing your project. I'll donate $3.

As I had hoped, Tux500 is getting the good ideas flowing and the marketing projects started.
Quoting:It's funny that I keep getting slammed for having an opinion but the whole point of this thread was to point out the problems I see with the campaign. No one has denied that the problems exist, they just keep freaking out that someone has pointed them out.


Once again, and with feeling.

How about providing solutions to those problem, instead of simply pointing them out. It's damned easy to point out problems real or not, but it's a damn site harder to provide solutions.
As a Tux500 auditor I'm not supposed to comment on Tux500 - and I'm not. I will comment on this discussion though. Nothing I say here should be construed as a defense or criticism or promotion of the Tux500 campaign.

notamonopoly: What people are saying - and pretty much have from the first response - is that, if you disagree with what the Tux500 folks are trying to accomplish, fine. But, you can accomplish far more by launching your own campaign - even if its simply placing door knockers at every house in your neighborhood, than by criticising an honest effort. You can even decline to donate while applauding the effort, and position your own campaign - I like that zoo idea - as a different campaign. You could even form an alliance with these guys to offer mutual support (sharing contacts and so on). Heck, maybe all of you form the Linux Marketing Project, launching various marketing initiatives.

Just *do* *something*. That is the point every one of your critics has been trying to make throughout this thread. Who knows, you may just garned more support than the Tux500 team. But you won't garner anything but arguments if all you're doing is arguing over how dumb the Tux500 idea is.

Mind you, some will feel that idea won't reach enough people. They'll criticize the zoo you choose, right down to the penguin. Then they'll criticize the penguin's keeper, claiming that some other zoo has a much better penguin keeper. Oh yeah, and why a penguin to begin with? Why not a wildebeest? Oh yeah, don't forget how zoos pollute the environment. And then some bozo will come along and claim your campaign is a scam, and that you're really a martian, the result of Elvis' last trip - complete with evidence worthy of the National Inquirer. In short, whatever you try to do, someone is going to criticize your idea.

Even so, if you just act on your vision and stick to your guns, you'll make progress.

Cheers, Don
notamonopoly:

That is a great idea and I am glad to support it! Start a separate thread about it when you get started!

I think I owe you 20 bucks. :-)

Scott
Huzzah tracyanne! What you said.
Actually, with some variations on this theme by this community, he may actually have hit on something...let me get this race car idea working and I will talk with him about it. No, really...with some work...

and if it's ok...I just popped twenty into the tux500 kitty to cover your sins Scotty...then again, he might really WANT his twenty bucks, LOL

h
To dcparris: Who told you about the martian?
> Who told you about the martian?

It's ok... Don has a security clearance.
>It's ok... Don has a security clearance.

C;mon now, we've all seen his legs. That should be an insecurity clearance.
Dino, dino, how many times must you be reminded of proper LXer decorum. They're limbs, not l**s.
I thought the security breach was the pig....
Dino: Catherine Bach's called in person to suggest I insure my legs with Lloyd's. I think I will.

Kozmcrae: I know all about the martian. I'm a news guy. Knowing things is what I do.
DCParris: Simply capitol suggestions, chap!

> As a Tux500 auditor I'm not supposed to comment on Tux500 - and I'm not. Righto. Of course not.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post