Advanced

Byebye Google.

Posted by tadelste on · 40 comments
LXer.com; By sal paradise
Mail this story
Print this story

[opionion]Google's recent decision to comply with the Chinese Governments "requirements" have brought things to a head for me. I'm not going to use Google anymore. I don't want anything to do with a company that is prepared to accommodate repression like this.

By doing this Google is setting itself at odds with humanity. It's saying "nevermind the repression, nevermind the intolerance and the injustice, there's 100 million internet users in China and we want a slice". Of course the stated excuse is "we're helping the free flow of information around the world" except it's not free and barely flowing in China.

You could justify this by suggesting that to move in with the tyrant is in fact an attempt to help the tyrant become less tyrannical by force of good example. Except this isn't what happened here. One of the Google execs appeared on Channel 4 News last year and said "we will not compromise with the Chinese Government"! What changed?

Also worthy of note is that in all the crowing, sneering news stories I heard yesterday all reporting on Google's caving in, not one mentioned the fact that Yahoo and Microsoft are also busy helping the same Government repress free speech and knowledge.

So Google join the ranks of the seduced. Just another company that couldn't keep it's principles in the face of money.



Byebye Google.

  Nav
» Read more about: Story Type: Editorial, LXer Features; Groups: Community

» Get new stories by e-mail: nightly or as they are published

« Return to the newswire homepage

Comments (40)

Democratic Search Engines?

So, the big three search engines are all contributing to the repression of freedom.

What alternatives do we have?
http://www.mozdex.com/ should *someday* be a usable replacement, but for now is quite limited in results. (It can't even find my full name, which is bizarre... whereas google returns pages of hits.)

BTW, you mean "Unrestricted search engines." Democratic means rule by the people, and democracy allows repression by consent.
My first impulse is to agree, but the issue is not really that simple. If Google refused to cave in, what would it accomplish? Google would be replaced in China by those companies willing to cave in, and we know who those are.
"BTW, you mean "Unrestricted search engines." Democratic means rule by the people, and democracy allows repression by consent."

Quite so.
I was just looking for alternatives. I know that AltaVista is owned by Yahoo. Not sure what the heritage is for some of these others...

http://channels.netscape.com/search http://www.alltheweb.com http://www.ask.com http://search.aol.com http://www.hotbot.com

...and what was that engine that used to advertise on television with the black retriever?
Well, there's Ask Jeeves for a start. There's also http://www.vivisimo.com This is an interesting search engine because it clusters some results into groups contextually as well as the usual "page after page of links".

A straight search for the term "linux" on vivisimo returns 90.2 million results with 206 "clustered" in a tree type representation on the left of the page. The same term on ask jeeves returns 71.8 million results. The last time I looked on google (from my phone on the bus whilst bored - within the last 10 days) returned 381 million.

The question is, how many million pages do you need in your results?
42. Give or take a milion.

I don't know if this is bad or not, honestly. Google isn't going to change the Chinese government by not going into the market. As far as I can tell, only the Chinese can do that. And with the current "stability at all costs" most other governments are enforcing on their neighbors I don't know how much that'll be possible.

So is Google really aiding the opression?
I don't understand all the uproar about this. People are more than willing to buy Chinese made products, support other companies that do business in China, etc. All of those products and companies operate within the framework of the Chinese government, and all serve to benefit it in one way or another. However, when Google decides to operate within those same guidelines, everyone gets their panties in a bunch.

If you're going to boycott Google, how much sense does that make while you sit at your Dell computer using peripherals that were likely made, at least in part, in China!
A9, an Amazon product, is a great search engine http://a9.com/ The black retriever is Lycos http://www.lycos.com/ Teoma is a product of Ask Jeeves http://teoma.com/ HotBot is a Lycos product and also uses Ask Jeeves or Google search parameters

Overture Services, Inc. is a Yahoo! company http://www.content.overture.com/d/ AlltheWeb's index (provided by Yahoo!) includes billions of web pages AltaVista, a business of Overture Services, Inc.

Search.com is a CNET product http://www.search.com/ Beaucoup! is another alternative http://www.beaucoup.com/

infospace owns Dogpile http://www.dogpile.com/, WebCrawler http://www.webcrawler.com/, MetaCrawler http://www.metacrawler.com/
Boycotting Google over this is stupid. If you have a problem with China or it's policies take it up with the US Government who is happy to do business with China, and who is even happier to allow Google to do business with China.

I suggest you boycott your government as well by moving to Canada.

Sig.
I agree with stephan, but, don't think that moving to Canada is any remedy...
Isn't it nice and convenient the way people always manage to find a way to keep doing business with crooks, thugs and liars? How principled we all are until those principles mean making life a little harder, and then it's suddenly "principles? what principles?". Google said "we will not compromise with the Chinese Gov". I didn't ask them to say that, they said it of their own free will. Now they've gone back on it. Oh I see, Google doesn't care about the Internet Dissidents, now in prison, because Google, M$ and Yahoo helped the Chinese Gov put them there? And I'm supposed to roll over and say "ok"?

I've been growing uneasy about Google for a while. No one company gets to be the gatekeeper to all human knowledge. That is a recipe for disaster. Who appointed these people to this role? They're a search engine not an educational establishment or a library. The point being that Google just showed precisely how far they can be trusted as gatekeepers to human knowledge. Google will censor - byebye google.

I don't really care whether you join me in this or not, I wasn't calling for a boycot, I just thought something needed saying. And as I moved to Linux partly from a burning sense of outrage at Microsofts behaviour so I'll likewise leave Google.

Because it matters.

"Because it matters."

Well said.
I hope you start inspecting all your PC equipment for those pesky "Made in China" stickers, and prompty refuse to economically empower those "crooks, thugs and liars".

I think that your disappointment stems from having thought of Google as this great champion of human knowledge, when they've always only ever been a great search engine company.

Cheers Stephan

I added LXer to my Bookmarks Toolbar Folder as an alternative to Slashdot and (much worse) Linux Today. After reading this article I added Vivisimo to my search engines in the Firefox search box.

It does matter.
The companies that outsource hardware manufacturing to China are not involved in active censorship. They're taking advantage of the lack of unions and comparatively cheap labour costs. This is morally unsavoury and should be discouraged but it's not quite the same as actively censoring the truth for an already oppressed people.

Quoting: I think that your disappointment stems from having thought of Google as this great champion of human knowledge,


No, I never saw Google as anything other than a search engine. Society itself should be the champion of human knowledge. We seem to have lost our way somewhat though.

While I agree that it demonstrates questionable judgement on the part of Google to reverse their position concerning China, I would also like to point out that change is only going to happen in China when her citizens have had 'enough'. The Cold War wasn't 'won' by the United States having nothing to do with the former Soviet Union. Government reform comes about when the governed decide to make change. I believe that those citizens benefit from exposure to new and better ideas, which they may come across when listening to the radio or reading stories on the internet.

Granted China is attempting to censor what information the masses are exposed to, but as we all know. If someone really wants something, they'll figure out a way to get it. As an example consider how frequently hackers break the encryption codes used by DVD's.

Thankfully here in America we have the ability to make more choices for ourselves. And I certainly applaud anyone who thoughtfully exercises that right. All to often people just blindly accept whatever comes their way.

Bottomline: Google is a business. And the Chinese market is one that will only add to the billions Larry Page and Sergey Brin have already. As I previously posted, there are numerous other search engines that utilize Googles technology. Do you also intend to shun those companies? In which case I think you'll find that your search results will be severly limited.
OK, allow me to propose an alternative viewpoint.

Google is stuck between a choice of two evils: No Google search for the Chinese population, or a censored search. They've decided that the censored search is the lesser of the two evils. This is their public statement, and we have no real reason to doubt it. Note that they are not denying that the fact that they make money off the deal is a nice side benefit.

Now, if I were doing this, I would have the Chinese government tell me exactly what they wanted censored, and exactly how they wanted it censored. Then I would do that, and nothing more. Everything would have to be explicitly defined by them. Then I would carefully document exactly what was being done, in servers outside China, so that the Internet at large could do their best to work around the censorship.

I doubt Google is going to do this, as it's too obvious. But it seems equally obvious to me that they will be doing their very best to comply with the Chinese authorities requirements, while also subverting them as much as possible.

Why do I think this. Well first, they publicly stated what they were doing, which is a lot better than Microsoft or Yahoo ever did. This gives us the warning we need to begin the work needed to subvert the censorship. Secondly, the founders of Google are human, and they make mistakes, but they have not yet done anything to show that they do not share the values of the FOSS community. They appear to be good people, let's give them the benefit of a doubt until we see how things work out.
"but they have not yet done anything to show that they do not share the values of the FOSS community"

They've taken Open Source and made billions out of it, produced some fine software which isn't available for Open Source users and are now busy playing catch me if you can with repressive regimes. That's not quite what I thought the values of the FOSS Community were.
I share your sentiments exactly Sal. It seems like every month, week, even days that we hear about Google doing yet something else for an Operating System they claim to disdain. And yet they can't seem to find the time or resources to produce something valid or beneficial for the Linux Desktop which their own developers use for their desktop PCs.

Makes ya wonder... do the developers even use the apps they create?

Yahoo even more repugnant...

quote:"Google's decision to edit its search results in exchange for permission to operate out of China may not be quite as directly repugnant as the 10 year jail sentence a dissident Chinese Yahoo! user was handed after the company released his email details to the authorities" http://blogs.guardian.co.uk/organgrinder/2006/01/googles_chi...

quote:"THE USA government has issued a subpoena to an individual and to Microsoft to view the contents of a Hotmail account." http://www.theinquirer.net/?article=29269

quote:"While removing search results is inconsistent with Google's mission, providing no information (or a heavily degraded user experience that amounts to no information) is more inconsistent with our mission." http://www.theregister.co.uk/2006/01/25/google_censors_chine...

not the place and time

As an EFF supporter, you won't find me supporting any efforts to constrain the free flow of information. Nonetheless, you are misunderstanding Google's role.

Any revolutionary group (and Google's services are indeed revolutionary) has to adopt tactics that reflect the reality on the ground. To ignore reality is to run headlong into the bayonettes and martyr one's self on the altar of idealism. I'm all for idealism, but martyrdom should be the last resort. Google can not change the laws or government of China. To thumb their nose at the Chinese government would just mean more repression.

This is a smart move by Google. It at least gets them into the country and starts getting people used to the free flow of [some] ideas (unlike MSN search, which suppresses Linux hits everywhere!). It is up to the people of China to take it the rest of the way.

[fill in your government here]: "me too!"

and Google will happily oblige.

My opinion.

MrLiberty

Google? No thanks.

Teoma? Yes, thank you.

you don't understand communism

When you have power to the few in such a government, *THEY* have the power, and can easily screw google completely out of the picture.

China doesn't need google. Google can either comply, or they might as well just stop developing their chinese webpage cause they won't need it.

China's not afraid to show it's communist ways. Mao slaughtered 65 million of his own people, and of course there's Tiananmen Square. Just recently the chicom government was doing land grabs. Nothing's changed.
half: For clarification, are you looking at communism - not as a generic concept - but as practiced by a centralist government? Perhaps delineated by more of a militaristic elitist regime than by a mere difference between who owns the means of production?
-----------are you looking at communism - not as a generic concept - but as practiced by a centralist government?------------

I'm looking at both. Every time the generic concept is put into play it turns out militaristic. Vietnam, Cambodia, North Korea, China, Cuba, USSR...... Have you forgotten Milosevic's genocide? It took american intervention to put an end to that.

The only way you can go around telling people "you no longer own what you own" is by strong-arm taking it. That requires force of militarism. Who's just gonna give up their land?

The Venezuelan government is also doing land grabs.
OK. This thread is off-topic to LXer but I appreciate your clarification.
I fail to see how it's off-topic. The opinion article is all about China's oppression.(and google's brown nosing of it's government)

Funny how it doesn't mention what China's government is..... yet the oppression is caused *DIRECTLY* because of it.

If China were capitalist, this wouldn't be happening.

Google's actions are not the cause. They are the effects of the cause. Each cause and effect can be traced, "what cause that" "well what caused that" "well what caused that". At the very core is communism.
half: It's off topic based on our terms of service.

"Discussion and debate of a political or religious nature is not allowed on the site."

I'm not going to moderate the thread unless it goes into further discussion. You made your point and that's all we need to say about it. Let's leave it at that. Sal Paradise is a LXer editor from the UK and he wrote the article. A little discussion seems appropriate. We just don't need to get into a debate about it. I would appreciate just moving on. Thanks.

Thanks!

what illusion!

I don't see any point of mixing politics and IT. I use Google because it is the best search engine, I use Linux because it is better than Windows, ...etc. When I begin to have problems with a software or hardware, I switch to an alternative that doesn't suffer from these problems. So what technical problems that Google will suffer from? Censorship in China will affect my search in Google and I live in South America?

"By doing this Google is setting itself at odds with humanity. It's saying "nevermind the repression, nevermind the intolerance and the injustice ..etc"

So you are concerned about Chinese government crimes against its people? You are concerned about Chinese people freedom and justice? What about US and other governments over the world crimes against humanity? It is not part of the media 'Brain wash' program? How many things we own or use is a direct or indirect result of a crime against humanity or environment? If we can listen to these things, every piece will shout “Crime, Crime Crime!”. But we don't listen to anything but the 'brain wash' program that we receive. We still feel guilty though! “I have principals, and I don't feel 'clean' if I keep using Google”. After not using Google I would say to myself: “Now I feel clean. What wonderful feeling!”. What illusion!
I never used the words "clean" and "unclean" but since you introduced them I'll go along with it. Clean and unclean.

To go along with something you know is wrong and not to speak out about it. How can you feel anything but unclean after such an act?

To go along with something that is wrong based on the idea that wrong is everywhere and there's so much and where do you start, is defeatist.

I can assure you, if let rip with everything I feel over Iraq, 9/11, Guantanamo, climate change etc etc etc I'd be kicked off this site. What would that achieve? Not using Google is a statement, a statement that I won't use the services of a company if that company is exploiting other people. I may be using products based on exploitation but I'm not aware of it yet. When I become aware of that I'll change. Just like I don't buy Israeli Vegetarian foods (and the Israelis make the best vegetarian food bar none) because of the way they treat the Palestinians. Now, I don't think Israel is sitting down saying "oh no, what are we to do? Sal isn't eating Tivoli Sausages anymore, we must sort Palestine out." On the other hand, every penny that doesn't reach them can't be spent on guns!

Every act is a straw. One day the camels back will break.

But if we sit around shrugging in resignation and go along with such behaviour then we are part of the problem.
Greeting salparadise, I'm sorry if my reply sounded 'harsh'. I'll explain some things but not defending my reply. I put some words between quotes because English is not my native and I'm not sure of the correct use of this word although sure of the meaning. Your reply is refreshing and this what you should write in your article. Why you didn't? If you are afraid of being kicked off this site as you said, then we have a problem here in lxer.com and we must find an alternative as well. The article doesn't reflect the person behind this attitude. I'm reading and listening many big sentences from persons just following the 'fashion' of news and they just want to have some attitude that after some time when the 'flash' disappear, their attitude disappear too. And I'm sure you know what I'm talking about. I'm glad that your positive and optimistic reply 'destroyed' my sad and pessimistic one. Not only here, but inside my mind (which is the most important for me). I'm not sure if Freedom and Democracy will make China a better place. I don't want to see another Russia. But we can't accept the wrong because we are afraid from the worst. The dream of seeing a world based on peace, love and justice is coming back after so many disappointments and you have wan a supporter.
Sal has no chance of being kicked off LXer.com. He's a valuable contributor and a UK Editor.

His views are refreshing.
Sal, what about this:
Quoting:"... when results are censored on Google.cn, a notice appears informing the researcher that a specific item has been omitted due to Chinese government regulations – which is arguably far more subversive than the censored links ...
This differs qualitatively and quantitatively from the meek servicing of the CCP policy goals by, e.g. Yahoo and MS.

Check out: http://antiwar.com/justin/?articleid=8467 to see others that share your objective, but not necessarily for the same idealistic reasons.
Reflecting on the word use: idealistic.

Read Freud: The essence of society is repression of the individual. The essence of the indiividual is repression of self. Freud got a lot of things wrong - not that one IMO.

A salute to any individual willing to champion the cause of a world that works for everyone. Let's end repression and protect each other at the same time.

"Check out: [HYPERLINK@antiwar.com] to see others that share your objective, but not necessarily for the same idealistic reasons."

I don't think he shares Sal objective, because he wrote in the end:

" ... let us thank the gods for Google, which is pushing the frontiers of computer science and throwing a scare into governments worldwide."

I didn't feel he wrote it in an 'ironic' way.
EnGee - Have you lost all of your short term memory, thus, seeing only the last lines? I never implied the author of the piece agreed with Sal's stance. Perhaps your intent is to purposely divert attention from its real content. The article cites case after case of hypocritical attacks aimed at Google while these same people ignore or applaud dictatorial moves by their idols?

There is a certain sense of irony on the part of the author, but not pertaining to his view of Google. I suggest you re-read the article without preconceptions, because the author's intent is very clear.

Post a comment

A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.

Your message:
|||||
10
Markdown: **bold**, *italic*, [text](https://link), - lists, > quotes, $x^2$ for math. Formatting help

Sign up and post (it is free)  or  Log in and post