Is the BBC Perpetuating the Microsoft Monopoly?
The BBC Trust recently released its Public Value Test for "public consultation" with respect to its proposed on-demand services. The BBC Trust is proposing a "7-day catch-up" service to allow people to view shows for up to 30 days. Not only are the DRM provisions laughable, the questionaire implies that the service is essentially Windows-only. The irony is that Microsoft is being forced by the EU courts to comply with anti-monopoly remedies. First, the major media providers have been learning the hard way that DRM is not working as they had hoped. People will always crack DRM controls. Companies have spent untold sums trying to prevent people from sharing content or using it in ways they did not intend, with questionable success. The publicly-funded BBC will likely face the same challenges. Even more important, the BBC Trust's questionaire asks the question, "How important is it that the proposed seven-day catch-up service over the internet is available to consumers who are not using Microsoft software?" This is akin to asking whether one should be able to watch a program based on whether they own a Sony or Hitachi television. The other way to ask the question is, "how important are a few million people?" With growing numbers of people migrating away from the Windows platform, and the EU courts hammering Microsoft about its monopolistic practices, it The question posed by the BBC Trust seems more rhetorical than an effort to understand the marketplace. Why would the BBC propose a plan to support the Microsoft platform in light of all the commotion? According to Alan Cox, a well-known Linux kernel hacker, "Such a proposal IMHO completely violates the expectations that the BBC does not use public funds to distort markets, and there is no sign that the BBC trust who should be overseeing this have done the relevant market distortion analysis." LXer has requested information from the BBC Trust with respect to its intentions. Members of the public can respond to the questions on the BBC Trust site. Just click the "Questions" tab and use the boxes to answer the questions. Other questions cover how long people should be allowed to view content after it has been stored and whether the BBC should be making such a service a priority. |
|
|
Comments (14)
BBC And Microsoft
In short they are applying an unfair crippling approach that doesn't close the holes it is presumably meant to cover.
Forget the BBC as source of anything other than lies, propaganda and bias. They are a lifestyle propaganda machine, by and large, these days. Their news reporting is low standard, if it's a story that might scare you it's repeated and regurgitated endlessly with all the gory details repeated over and over. If it's a story about corporate greed, government corruption etc, then all of a sudden the details are sparse and the reporting brief. They have not called the governments bluff over it's lies regarding Iraq, Iran, US policy, Afghanistan etc. They seem to have adopted a cap in hand, fawning attitude where they are pitifully grateful when the rich or famous stoop to speak to them.
The BBC execs should be made to sit and watch Goodnight and Goodluck repeatedly till they get the message.
The job of the media is not to follow humbly behind politicians eager for any glance or word from them. Its job is to stand in front of the politicians and DEMAND an accounting of policy and behaviour. Politicians HAVE to be made to squirm periodically or they start to believe their own spin.
Network News: Infotainment based around a cult of the newsreader CNN: Ratings driven sensationalism. Extremely repetitive Fox News: Tass for the Right Comedy Central: Fake news but at least it is entertaining.
Or unless there's a political agenda. At which point even making up your stories is acceptable. :(
Quoting:Comedy Central: Fake news but at least it is entertaining.
The Daily Show does not sell fake news. They actually tell you things about what is going on that would never be shown on a "real" newscast. The Daily Show just makes fun of it, that's not fake news.
Fake news is what you get on CNN and FOX. Why tell you the truth when they can pile the BS so high you can't tell the difference.
Yeah, most times the only ones who give you even a glimmer of the real truth. Unfortunately, even they seem fooled by Billie and his MS minions. Like most Americans, they are clueless that there's a far better solution called Linux out there.
I was using Jon Stewart's description of his own show. I agree if you see the show through the lens of satire it is quite revealing about the political process here. One journalist who was on the show (Mike Wallace?) did say however that in the old days he could talk about serious stuff without having to be funny (i.e. entertaining).
I should add that the Jim Lehrer Show on PBS isn't too bad......
it hits the poor
These are people who can't afford a modern spec' machine the likes of which are required to run Windows Vista. Hence the less well off of that sort won't be able to benefit from the service.
Well, of course they won't, but let's look at that...
'Benefit' and 'service' are already oxymoron's when referring to anything from MS. So, right off the bat, MS & the BBS are doing the underprivileged a big favor. Save them money and drive them toward Linux. And, TV isn't good for you anyway... Now that's real philanthropy.
Quoting:Save them money and drive them toward Linux. And, TV isn't good for you anyway... Now that's real philanthropy.
I could not have said it better myself..
More stories about Microsoft Bias at the BBC
,----[ Quote ] | BBC viewers have flooded the corporation with complaints over how it | covered the launch of Microsoft Vista earlier this week. | | In one cringingly servile interview worthy of Uriah Heep, the | Beeb's news presenter Hugh Edwards even thanked Gates at the | end of it, presumably in appreciation at being allowed to give | the Vole vast coverage for free. | | In other TV news items presenters excitedly explained how Vistac | ould be obtained and installed - details courtesy of the BBC's | website. | | But British viewers, currently forced to pay a £131.50 licence | fee to maintain the BBC's "impartiality", were less than impressed. | | Scores got in touch to complain that so much was Auntie up Bill's | bum that you could barely see her corset. `----
http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=37411
http://slated.org/bbc_microsoft_bias
Brits! Act now to save the BBC from Microsoft
,----[ Quote ] | The BBC are holding an open consultation regarding how they're | going to delivery on-demand content, they want answers to | questions like: "How important is it that the proposed seven-day | catch-up service over the internet is available to consumers who | are not using Microsoft software?" `----
http://www.boingboing.net/2007/01/31/brits_act_now_to_sav.ht...
Beeb breaks out with Windows WMA protection
,----[ Quote ] | According to a press release from Sonos, the blokes over | at the Beeb have decided to jump ship for relying on | Realplayer for web content, and have switched over | entirely to the Windows-friendly WMA format. Now | that the BBC has made The Big Switch, BBC radio | stations will be received automatically for users | of wireless music and radio provider Sonos. `----
http://www.theinquirer.net/default.aspx?article=35282
BBC Looks To Microsoft For Web 2.0
,----[ Quote ] | However, you don't sign deals or commitments if you're a quasi-autonomous | Public Corporation operating as a public service broadcaster, as the BBC | is. BBC Director General Mark Thompson met Microsoft Chairman Bill Gates | in Seattle on Wednesday to sign the non-exclusive memorandum of | understanding and discuss the BBC's digital strategy. `----
http://www.forbes.com/2006/09/28/bbc-microsoft-internet-cx_c...
Post a comment
A free account is needed to post. Write your comment here first: your text is kept in this browser while you sign up or log in, and is waiting for you when you come back.
Your message:Sign up and post (it is free) or Log in and post
